FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:     | 1 | 2 || 4 | 5 |   ...   | 6 |

«Green Revolution in Africa August 2009 Report Contributions: Sam Moyo, Walter Chambati, Tendai Murisa and Amade Sucá TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. ...»

-- [ Page 3 ] --

The AGRA initiative does not directly call for a public sector programme to support the infrastructural needs of resource-poor smallholder farmers, although its partners, including the state, are expected to address the capital investment challenges beyond the farm (e.g. roads and other essential infrastructure). AGRA argues that these fall outside its mandate (Rockefeller Foundation, 2006).

AGRA appears to subscribe to the mainstream development paradigm of a ‘minimalist state’ and ‘active market’, with some space being provided for NGO partnerships. It has used largely private consulting firms for programme design, sidelining the planning role of African governments, while including African universities and farmers’ unions in minor implementation roles. African agricultural development must be based on participatory national development strategies and led by national governments. AGRA seems to believe that technology transfer is not an intractable problem, but rather that African markets and the state have failed to provide these to small-scale producers. Yet planning in the first green revolution was coordinated by the state, with donor support. The AGRA approach may suffer from weak coordination and risk duplication in the absence of a central role for the state and civil society engagement.

Furthermore, AGRA’s financiers seem to believe that Africa has to play ‘catch up’ with the developed West without the need to reform global agrarian structures of capital, aid and trade (e.g. WTO), despite the inequalities and crisis (food, energy and financial) these have generated.

4.2 The small farmer focus The AGRA initiative is correct to focus on smallholder farmers since they produce the bulk of the food and other agricultural commodities. However these farmers are food insecure themselves and poverty is largely a rural phenomenon in Africa. Such a focus should not forget women farmers as they are the main actors in small farmer systems.

Beyond technology per se smallholder farmers in Africa face wider structural constraints, such as access to land, water, infrastructure, information and credit that need redress to facilitate meaningful production. Only since September 2008, has AGRA initiated activities in some of these broader areas. It is envisaged that AGRA would implement a holistic small producer support system; including essential services such as infrastructure, extensions, training, marketing and distribution services etc. For it is not clear how the technologies being promoted by AGRA would be accessible to the majority of poor small scale producers, without such public support. Indeed the supply could not be captured by large scale farmers, as happened in the first green revolution in Asia and Latin America, leading to increasing inequality in the countryside (see Freebairn, 1995). For instance, access to improved seeds through credit has proved to be tied to land ownership as found in Kenya, where many small farmers without their own land are excluded. AGRA needs to be cautious not repeat the mistakes of the previous green revolution, whose ‘one-size-fits-all’ plant breeding strategy, led to the support of increased monocultures.

Assessing the Alliance for Green Revolution in Africa

P a g e | 12 Moreover, most of the inputs supplied by TNCs have tended to focus on export crop biotechnology and genetic engineering research rather than the staple food crops grown by most smallholder farmers (FAO, 2004; Forum for Environment and Development, 2007).

Although smallholder involvement in export crop production has been growing (e.g. horticulture and floriculture in Kenya), such exports are mostly dominated by larger-scale farmers in both volume and value terms.6 A key contradiction in AGRA’s smallholder farmer focus is that some of its key partners, such as the International Institute for Tropical Agriculture in Nigeria (IITA), have recently shifted focus away from smallholder farming to the development of industrial production and processing of cassava for export biofuel markets. AGRA´s strategy entails encouraging a transformation which moves from ‘subsistence’ to large scale farming (GRAIN, 2007).

In general, AGRA is perceived as being likely to contribute to the deepening of class differences between the rich and poor farmers (Gimenez, et al 2006), given that AGRA seems to assume that small-scale farmers are a homogenous group, who can respond to input markets and extension incentives in the same manner. Although AGRA indicates that they will concentrate efforts on small holder farmers with land size between 1/4ha to 4ha it does not elaborate on other criteria such as labour and capital intensities. Linked to the fact that AGRA does not implement activities (as it works through partners) there is no clear mechanism to guarantee that the partners will have the poorer small farmers as the actual beneficiaries.

4.3 Access to land and water resources and tenure security Although AGRA recognizes the importance of land access and security of tenure, these have not been part of its direct interventions, until early 2009, when land, gender and environment programmes were set up in the policy unit. The priority instead was ‘stimulat[ing] investment[s] by small scale farmers in technologies, farm inputs and off farm inputs’ (AGRA, 2008a, p4) through the PASS programme. AGRA expects to work with the AU, New African Partership for African Development (NEPAD) and United Nations Economic Commission on Africa (UNECA) ‘to further advocate equitable land access and security of land tenure’ (Ibid, pp.4) but falls short of advocating for extensive land redistribution and tenure reform. Moreover, its NEPAD partner neglects the inequitable land redistribution of land and water resources and tenure insecurity in its founding policy documents. Instead, it poses Africa’s land problem primarily as being the declining fertility of soils and climatic variability (Moyo, 2006). Without balanced (re)distribution of land and water resources and the security of women’s land rights the predicted ‘benefits’ of AGRA would most likely accrue to the larger scale male farmers, with more secure land rights.

The current AGRA support to seed improvement is fortunately (presently) focused on Africa’s main food crops such as cassava (eight grants), sorghum (five grants), maize (38 grants), banana (two grants), beans (eight grants), cowpea (four grants), groundnuts (three grants), millet (three grants), rice (six grants), soybean (two grants), sweet potato (two grants) and wheat (one grant). It cannot be ascertained yet whether export-oriented land uses and production goals will find their way into AGRA, as has been the case with most African agricultural initiatives. Moreover, the AGRA project could still find itself contending with existing and new private sector-led and government facilitated export-oriented land uses, as we have seen with biofuels. For instance, agribusiness dominated initiatives to increase biofuels indicate that over 5 million hectares in Africa are being converted to biofuel production with the target exceeding 55 million hectares by 2012 (see Thompson, 2008). For example in Ethiopia and Assessing the Alliance for Green Revolution in Africa P a g e | 13 Mozambique, 1.2 million and 3.5 million hectares, respectively, have been earmarked for biofuel feedstock production.

The AGRA strategy is also unclear as to the effects of the technological revolution on Africa’s complex social relations of agricultural production, including widespread tenancy sharecropping among rural households.7 Experiences from India and Brazil show that the green revolution undermined existing tenancies, where some small land owners, who suffered viability problems related to expensive external inputs (HYVs, fertiliser, pesticides and herbicides), lost control of their land (Muller, 1988; Babu, 2006).

4.4 Technology (seeds, chemicals, fertiliser, machinery, irrigation and labour) The AGRA initiative is probably correct in identifying some of the technological shortfalls underlying African agriculture. Yet AGRA’s focus on training mainly crop scientists and neglecting social scientists reinforces the critique of its excessively technical orientation, by defining Africa’s agriculture problem as technological. Since Africa is characterised by complex social relations of production, it requires that social scientists assess the effects of technical change. Alumira and Rusike (2005) argue that the development of new technologies for small farmers should be based on understanding the behaviour of households.

Moreover, smallholder farming is mostly practiced through self-exploitation of backbreaking family labour, and thus a key source of employment for over 60 percent of the largely rural population in Africa. It remains unclear (especially for females and children) whether AGRA technologies are benignly labour intensive and/or would have a positive impact on rural employment generation. There is evidence that capital intensification of agriculture has led to job displacement in Africa, prior to and during the era of neo-liberal reforms.8 Agricultural job displacement in Africa would have severe consequences for poverty reduction, given the limited job opportunities in non-farm rural and urban sectors.

There are also concerns about the forms of technology and transfer models proposed by AGRA.

On the transfer of technology and development, the initiative proposes to work with local seed companies and smallholder farmers using local knowledge for the development of improved seed varieties. However there are concerns about the role of TNCs, as their monopolistic control of seed technology patents is increasing through the privatization of public research results and technologies. For example, Zambia and Zimbabwe transferred publicly owned seed patent to private firms. This raised concerns about the security of intellectual property rights, even where public institutions are involved. While AGRA reports that its support to seed breeding is directed at public institutions, it is not clear that this patrimony will not again be privatized.

There is need to investigate further the sources of the 1000 seeds to be improved and their intellectual property rights status, as many observers feel that small holder farmer’s local seed banks and breeding systems need to be given greater consideration. For that purpose, AGRA should support the local small and medium private companies that are producing improved seeds that originate from the farmer’s locality and assist agro-dealers to provide those seeds to the communities, in order to avoid dependence on large TNCs and expensive credit.

Assessing the Alliance for Green Revolution in Africa

P a g e | 14 AGRA’s agro-dealer development programme if not well monitored may end up facilitating trade for TNCs that provide agricultural inputs. In its current form AGRA does not supervise the outcomes and trends of agro-dealers it has supported in their development. As indicated by Veronica Kingoo, co-owner of Nduki agro-chemical shop in Machakos, Kenya ‘currently we work with seeds from Syngenta, Buyer, Seminis, Monsanto and others and fertilizers from Yara.

Syngenta supports us with technical training and refer people (farmers and local agro dealers) to us. It is good because they publicize our work and provide clients to us’. Veronica Kingoo further indicated that ‘we advise farmers to buy the hybrid seeds and chemical fertilizers because they will get high yields. Today there’s no more traditional seeds as these were infected by the new hybrids through cross pollination’. A seed company – Leldet Ltd affirmed that it ‘recognizes that for sustainability of the business, the emphasis must lie on developing demand for seed at the farmer level’ (AGMARK, 2009:8). These reinforce the idea that the private sector will do all they can to make sure farmers buy the inputs they are selling.

As such, AGRA could potentially induce smallholder farmer dependency on expensive, externally driven inputs from TNCs (Holt-Gimenez et al, 2006). Hybrid and genetically modified (GMO) seeds undermine smallholder seed independence, based on saving and sharing own seed, as well as practices such as intercropping, which are critical in farmers’ food security strategy (Ibid, Gill, Lindberg, Thandi and Babu, 2006; Mayet, 2007). Mainstream research and development has focused on uniform seed varieties which promote monoculture farming systems that could potentially displace multiple seed varieties in Africa leading to loss in agrobiodiversity as happened in the Philippines where over 7,000 rice varieties were displaced by green revolution rice (Freebairn, 1995). Hybrid and GMO seeds also require heavy application of fertilisers, pesticides and herbicides meaning increased input costs for smallholder farmers in the absence of state subsidies, and rapid input price increases.

ActionAid does not reject technology. However there are concerns that this be socially constructed, informed by the needs of the people and suitable for local context. Technology must be owned and controlled by the people and not driven by profit motives, otherwise it will deepen the power imbalances between smallholder farmers and TNCs, represented by the ‘local’ agro dealers and regional wholesalers.

The GMO question Doubts are also being raised about AGRA’s position on GMOs through the inherent contradictions that have been exposed since its formation. For instance in July 2007, Kofi Annan indicated that GMOs will not be part of AGRA programmes. For this he was criticized by the pro-GMO lobby around the world (Mayet, 2007). In reaction, AGRA released a statement stressing GMOs were not part of the current programmes but remain an option for future programmes depending on their endorsement by African governments and availability of provisions for their safe use (Ibid; AGRA, 2007). Prior to that, a meeting on ‘Biotech, Breeding and Seed Systems for African Crops’ organized by the Rockefeller Foundation which included many of AGRA’s collaborators, heard a number of presentations on research and trials on GMO crops in Africa (Mayet, 2007). Thus, at this point in time, AGRA’s position on GMOs remains unclear and ActionAid is not in a position to predict whether they will be introduced or not in later phases of the programming.

Pages:     | 1 | 2 || 4 | 5 |   ...   | 6 |

Similar works:

«Tsakiri, Ioannidis, Carty 1 LASER SCANNING ISSUES FOR THE GEOMETRICAL RECORDING OF A COMPLEX STATUE Maria TSAKIRI1, Charalambos IOANNIDIS1, Alistair CARTY2 1 School of Rural and Surveying Engineering, National Technical University of Athens, Greece. 2 Archaeoptics Ltd, Glasgow, UK KEY WORDS: laser scanning, heritage applications, three-dimensional, close range, data capture ABSTRACT Recent advances in laser scanning technology allow for fast and efficient 3D documentation of cultural heritage...»

«ANDREW G. VAUGHN Gustavus Adolphus College 800 West College Ave. St. Peter, MN 56082 507–933–7475 (O); 507–934–1225 (H) email: avaughn@gustavus.edu http://www.gac.edu/~avaughn POSITIONS HELD Associate Professor of Religion: Gustavus Adolphus College, St. Peter, MN. Appointment with continuous tenure in area of Hebrew Bible. 2002 – present. Chair, Department of Religion: Gustavus Adolphus College, St. Peter, MN. 2003 – present (on sabbatical 2004–5 academic year). Supply Preacher:...»

«2013 South Dakota Crop Protection Guide Corn Weed Control (text) Weeds: Mike Moechnig, Darrell L. Deneke, Leon J. Wrage, Jill Alms, Dave Vos, and Mark Rosenberg Insects: Adrianna Szczepaniec and Buyung Hadi Diseases: Kay Ruden “This document represents only a portion of the 2013 Corn Crop Protection Guide. The complete guide is available at iGrow.org. Information in this publicationis based on SDSU and other research and observations and provides a summary of label recommendations. It is not...»

«1 116173 NQF Level: US No: Assessment Guide Primary Agriculture Ev a lu a t e Ba s ic Ex t er n al An im al An atom y an d M o r p ho lo g y Assessor:.......................................... Workplace / Company:................................. Commodity:................... Date:................. The availability of this product is due to the financial support of the National...»

«Research in ISSN : P-2409-0603, E-2409-9325 AGRICULTURE, LIVESTOCK and FISHERIES An Open Access Peer Reviewed Journal      Open Access Res. Agric. Livest. Fish. Research Article Vol. 2, No. 1, April 2015: 125-133 FISHERS ACCESS TO THE COMMON PROPERTY WATERBODIES IN THE NORTHERN REGION OF BANGLADESH Md. Amzad Hossain1*, Mousumi Das1, Md. Shahanoor Alam2 and Md. Enamul Haque3 1 Department of Aquaculture, Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman Agricultural University (BSMRAU), Gazipur-1706,...»

«As. J. Food Ag-Ind. 2012, 5(02), 96-103 Asian Journal of Food and Agro-Industry ISSN 1906-3040 Available online at www.ajofai.info Research Article Effect of vacuum cooling on physico-chemical properties of organic coriander Apichart Sirinanuwat1, Danai Boonyakiat 2,3 and Pichaya Boonprasom 1,3* 1 Division of Food Engineering, Faculty of Agro-Industry, Chiang Mai University, Thailand, 50200 2 Department of Horticulture, Faculty of Agriculture, Chiang Mai University, Thailand, 50200 3...»

«Digital soil map of Cyprus (1:25,000) AGWATER Options for sustainable agricultural production and water use in Cyprus under global change Scientific Report 6 Deliverable D15, D16 Zomenia Zomeni1, Corrado Camera2, Adriana Bruggeman2, Andreas Zissimos1, Irene Christoforou1, Jay Noller3 1 Geological Survey Department of Cyprus 2 Energy, Environment and Water Research Center, The Cyprus Institute 3 Department of Crop and Soil Science, Oregon State University Nicosia, 15 November 2014 Table of...»

«52 Chimera 26: Geographical Journal, University College Cork Suburbia: social and spatial trends that emerged in Celtic Tiger Ireland. Matthew Williams Department of Geography, University College Cork, Ireland. Long after the roar of the “Celtic Tiger” has become inaudible; its effects remain in the form of ghost estates, incomplete rural development and inadequate service provision across the Irish landscape. This paper will give a brief account of suburban housing development in Ireland...»

«Rural Sociology 78(1), 2013, pp. 1–28 DOI: 10.1111/j.1549-0831.2012.00095.x Copyright © 2012, by the Rural Sociological Society A More Perfect Commodity: Bottled Water, Global Accumulation, and Local Contestation Daniel Jaffee Department of Sociology *Washington State University Soren Newman School of the Environment Washington State University Abstract Bottled water sits at the intersection of debates regarding the social and environmental effects of the commodification of nature and the...»

«Kara Loo and Jennifer Young Eastridge@SchoolForAdventurers.com EASTRIDGE ACADEMY: SCHOOL FOR ADVENTURERS BY KARA LOO AND JENNIFER YOUNG Eastridge Academy: School for Adventurers Prologue Explain why you would be a strong candidate for attending Eastridge Academy, School for Adventurers, in 500 words or less. “Hey, Farmington. You stupid farmboy, what have you got there?” Fell Farmington gulped and quickly tried to hide the application for Eastridge Academy: School for Adventurers. But he...»

«Patient & Family Guide to Hospice Care Serving Colorado’s Front Range The Kingfisher, calm and at peace, nested upon water, quieter of restlessness. A Patient & Family Guide to Hospice Care To All, I just want you to know what an honor it is for Halcyon to be invited into your lives in such an intimate way. We are very much committed to living up to your expectations, wishes and desires. Halcyon is a clinician owned hospice. It’s vision is to provide patient centered care to people who...»

«FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS (FAQs): MINNESOTA’S STAFF DEVELOPMENT STATUTES Minnesota Statutes, sections 122A.60 and 122A.61 Created September 2001 Updated July 2002, March 2006, February 2008, November 2010, August 2013 In response to many interpretation and implementation questions about Minnesota’s staff development statutes, the organizations listed below have jointly developed this set of Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs). The statutes discussed in this set of FAQs can be found at Minn....»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.