«Abstract Sedentism is usually regarded as a pre-condition for the development of crop husbandry in Southwest Asia and, consequently, sedentary ...»
Where grasses were indeed an important part of hunter-gatherer subsistence strategies, they may have been neither the main nor the only staple food: for example, in the Qermez Dere and M’lefaat assemblages, legumes also played an important role throughout the occupation of the site. Published results at comparison sites have also shown that other food-plants, such as legumes, were often at least as important as grasses in terms of proportions. Finally, Mureybit illustrates that, when grasses are dominant within the overall assemblage of a site, they are not necessarily dominant in all sub-phases, especially those associated with the initial occupation.
At Hallan Cemi, where there is bioarchaeological evidence for year-round occupation, ¸ sedentism was possible without the exploitation of grasses as an important subsistence strategy. At M’lefaat, where there is also strong bioarchaeological evidence for year-round occupation, other food plants are as important as grasses in terms of proportions and ubiquity.
Sedentism and dietary diversity The model by which hunter-gatherers became sedentary by exploiting a small number of staple foods, typically thought to include grasses (particularly the wild progenitors of cereals) and nuts, was based on data from a small number of Levantine sites. New data suggest that this model may not be applicable throughout Southwest Asia or, indeed, in the Levant itself. Furthermore, the archaeobotanical remains from Ohalo II show some continuity in food-plant gathering between 19,500 BP and 10,000 BP (uncal.), suggesting that there might have been little diﬀerence between the diet of hunter-gatherers thought to be mobile in 19,500 BP and sedentary in 10,000 BP. Even in the Levant, the exploitation of 192 Manon Savard et al.
grasses might not have triggered nor have been an important factor for sedentism, as argued earlier by Olszewski (1993). As suggested by Peter Rowley-Conwy (2001: 58–65), the ﬁrst domesticates in this and other agricultural societies would not have been the staple foods of pre-agrarian societies.
The progressivist perspective usually applied to sedentary hunter-gatherer sites, and the quest for the earliest evidence for agriculture, translate into a quest for ‘wild cereals’.
Instead, the archaeobotanical assemblages of Hallan Cemi, Demirkoy, Qermez Dere and ¸ ¨ M’lefaat and those of broadly contemporary sites ﬁt with elements of Flannery’s (1969) broad spectrum model. Subsistence strategies seem to have been as diverse as the local environments. Although the exact causes of the variability in plant diet between diﬀerent sites remain to be established, it appears that hunter-gatherers were taking an opportunistic advantage of the resources available. Sedentism was possible in areas oﬀering a wide diversity of resources, both locally and seasonally. The presence of reliable resources (such as valley-bottom plants) probably had more importance for sedentism than ‘wild cereals’.
The authors would like to thank an anonymous reviewer for insightful comments, and are grateful for research and/or technical support from M. Rosenberg, B. Peasnall, T.
Watkins, D. Baird, S. K. Kozłowski, P. Miracle, G. Willcox, S. Colledge, D. Fuller, S. Gagnon and the McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research. Funding is acknowledged from the Gerald Averay Wainwright Near Eastern Archaeological Fund, the Cambridge Commonwealth Trust, the Association of Commonwealth Universities, the British Council, the Canadian Centennial Scholarship Fund, St. Edmund’s College (Cambridge), the NERC and the Oxford Radiocarbon Accelerator Unit.
Horizon. The diversity in chrono-cultural labels is not linked with a lack of consistency, but rather reﬂects the diﬃculty of classifying these sites within strict categories.
2 There are over ﬁfty species of dock/knotgrass documented in Turkey and their seed edibility varies between species.
Algaze, G., Breuninger, R., Lightfoot, C. and Rosenberg, M. 1991. The Tigris-Euphrates archaeological reconnaissance project: a preliminary report of the 1989–1990 seasons. Anatolica, 17: 175–240.
Anderson, P. C. 1999. Experimental cultivation, harvest and threshing of wild cereals: their relevance for interpreting the use of Epipalaeolithic and Neolithic artifacts. In Prehistory of Agriculture: New Experimental and Ethnographic Approaches (ed. P. Anderson). Los Angeles, CA: UCLA, Institute of Archaeology, Monograph 40, pp. 118–44.
Aurenche, O. and Kozłowski, S. K. 1999. La Naissance du Ne´olithique au Proche Orient. Paris:
Bar-Yosef, O. and Kislev, M. E. 1989. Early farming communities in the Jordan valley. In Foraging
and Farming: The Evolution of Plant Exploitation (eds D. R. Harris and G. C. Hillman). London:
Unwin Hyman, pp. 632–42.
Bar-Yosef, O. and Meadow, R. H. 1995. The origins of agriculture in the Near East. In Last Hunters-First Farmers: New Perspectives on the Prehistoric Transition to Agriculture (eds T. D. Price and A. B. Gebauer). Santa Fe, NM: School of American Research Press, pp. 39–94.
Belfer-Cohen, A. and Bar-Yosef, O. 2000. Early sedentism in the Near East: a bumpy ride to village life. In Life in Neolithic Farming Communities: Social Organization, Identity, and Diﬀerentiation (ed.
I. Kuijt). New York: Kluwer, pp. 19–37.
Cauvin, J. 1999. Problems and methods for exploring the beginnings of agriculture: the archaeologist’s view. In Prehistory of Agriculture: New Experimental and Ethnographic Approaches (ed. P. Anderson). Los Angeles, CA: UCLA, Institute of Archaeology, Monograph 40, pp. 180–2.
Cauvin, J. 2000. The Birth of the Gods and the Origins of Agriculture. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Chapman, J. 1996. Lepenski Vir. In The Oxford Companion to Archaeology (ed. B. M. Fagan).
New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 388–9.
Colledge, S. 2001. Plant Exploitation on Epipalaeolithic and Early Neolithic Sites in the Levant.
Oxford: Archaeopress, BAR S986.
Colledge, S., Conolly, J. and Shennan, S. 2004. Archaeobotanical evidence for the spread of farming in the Eastern Mediterranean. Current Anthropology, 45: S35–S49.
Dittemore, M. 1983. The soundings at M’lefaat. In Prehistoric Archaeology along the Zagros Flanks (eds L. S. Braidwood, R. J. Braidwood, B. Howe, C. A. Reed and P. J. Watson).
Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago, pp. 671–92.
Dobrowolski, A. 1998. Biology and habitats of birds found in excavations at M’lefaat. In M’lefaat:
Early Neolithic Site in Northern Irak (ed. S. K. Kozłowski), Cahiers de l’Euphrate 8, pp. 224–31.
Ertu-Yaras¸, F. 1997. An ethnoarchaeological study of subsistence and plant gathering in Central g Anatolia. Doctoral dissertation. Department of Anthropology. Washington University.
Flannery, K. V. 1969. Origins and ecological eﬀects of early domestication in Iran and the Near East. In The Domestication and Exploitation of Plants and Animals (eds P. J. Ucko and G. W. Dimbleby). London: Duckworth, pp. 73–100.
194 Manon Savard et al.
Harlan, J. R. 1999. Harvesting of wild-grass seed and implications for domestication. In Prehistory
of Agriculture: New Experimental and Ethnographic Approaches (ed. P. Anderson). Los Angeles, CA:
UCLA, Institute of Archaeology, Monograph 40, pp. 1–5.
Henry, D. O. 1989. From Foraging to Agriculture: The Levant at the End of the Ice Age. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Hillman, G. C. 2000. Abu Hureyra I, the Epipalaeolithic. In Village on the Euphrates: From Foraging to Farming at Abu Hureyra (eds A. M. T. Moore, G. C. Hillman and A. J. Legge). Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 327–98.
Hillman, G. C., Legge, A. J. and Rowley-Conwy, P. A. 1997. On the charred seeds from Epipalaeolithic Abu Hureyra: food or fuel? Current Anthropology, 38: 651–9.
Keeley, L.H. 1988. Hunter-gatherer economic complexity and ‘population pressure’: a cross-cultural analysis. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology, 7: 373–411.
Kislev, M. E. 1997. Early agriculture and paleoecology of Netiv Hagdud. In An Early Neolithic Village in the Jordan Valley, Part 1, The Archaeology of Netiv Hagdud (eds O. Bar-Yosef and A. Gopher). Cambridge, MA: Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology, pp. 209–36.
Kislev, M. E., Simchoni, O. and Weiss, E. 2002. Reconstruction of the landscape, human economy, and hut use according to seeds and fruit remains from Ohalo II. In Ohalo II: A 23,000 Year Old
Fisher-Hunter-Gatherers’ Camp on the Shore of the Sea of Galilee (ed. D. Nadel). University of Haifa:
Hecht Museum, pp. 21–3.
Kislev, M. E., Weiss, E. and Hartmann, A. 2004. Impetus for sowing and the beginning of agriculture:
ground collecting of wild cereals. Proceedings of the National Association of Science, 101: 2692–5.
Kozłowski, S. K. (ed.) 1998. M’lefaat: early Neolithic site in Northern Irak. Cahiers de l’Euphrate, 8:
` Kozłowski, S. K., Kuzma, K. and Szymczak, K. 1991. La reprise des fouilles a M’lefaat (saison 1989/ ´ 1990). Polish Archaeology in the Mediterranean, 2: 112–18.
Lasota-Moskalewska, A. 1998. Mammal bone remains from M’lefaat, Irak (excavation seasons 1989 and 1990). In M’lefaat: Early Neolithic Site in Northern Irak (ed. S. K. Kozłowski), Cahiers de l’Euphrate 8, pp. 215–21.
Lev, E., Kislev, M. E. and Bar-Yosef, O. 2005. Mousterian vegetal food in Kebara Cave, Mt. Carmel. Journal of Archaeological Science, 32: 475–84.
McCorriston, J. and Hole, F. 1991. The ecology of seasonal stress and the origins of agriculture in the Near East. American Anthropologist, 93: 46–69.
Mazurowski, R. F. 1998. The ground and pecked stone industry. In M’lefaat: Early Neolithic Site in Northern Irak (ed. S. K. Kozłowski), Cahiers de l’Euphrate 8, pp. 200–11.
Nesbitt, M. 2002. When and where did domesticated cereals ﬁrst occur in Southwest Asia? In The Dawn of Farming in the Near East (eds R. T. J. Capper and S. Bottema). Berlin: Ex Oriente, pp. 113–32.
Olszewski, D. I. 1993. Subsistence ecology in the Mediterranean forest: implications for the origins of cultivation in the Epipalaeolithic southern Levant. American Antiquity, 95: 420–35.
Oxford Radiocarbon Accelerator Unit (ORAU) in press. Archaeometry datelist 32. Archaeometry.
Peasnall, B. L. 2000. The round house horizon along the Taurus-Zagros arc: a synthesis of recent excavations of Late Epipaleolithic and Early Aceramic sites in Southeastern Anatolia and Northern Iraq. Doctoral dissertation. Department of Anthropology. University of Pennsylvania.
Peasnall, B. L. 2002. Intricacies of Hallan Cemi. Expedition, 44(1): 5–6.
¸ Peasnall, B. L. and Rosenberg, M. 2001. A preliminary description of the lithic industry from
Demirkoy Hoyuk. In Beyond Tools (eds I. Caneva, C. Lemorini, D. Zampetti and P. Biagi). Berlin:
¨ ¨¨ Ex Oriente, pp. 363–87.
195 The role of wild grasses Perrot, J. 1966. Le gisement Natuﬁen de Mallaha (Eynan), Israel. L’Anthropologie, 70: 437–84.
¨ Rielly, K. 1998. Bird bones. In M’lefaat: Early Neolithic Site in Northern Irak (ed. S. K. Kozłowski), Cahiers de l’Euphrate 8, pp. 222–3.
Rosenberg, M. 1994. Hallan Cemi Tepesi: some further observations concerning stratigraphy and ¸ material culture. Anatolica, 20: 121–40.
Rosenberg, M. 1999. Hallan Cemi, In Neolithic in Turkey: The Cradle of Civilization, New ¸ ¨ Discoveries (eds M. Ozdoan and N. Basgelen). Istanbul: Arkeoloji ve Sanat Yayınları, pp. 25–33.
g Rosenberg, M. and Davis, M. K. 1992. Hallan Cemi Tepesi, an early aceramic Neolithic site in ¸ Eastern Anatolia: some preliminary observations concerning material culture. Anatolica, 18: 1–18.
Rosenberg, M. and Peasnall, B. L. 1998. A report on soundings at Demirkoy Hoyuk, an aceramic ¨ ¨¨ Neolithic site in Eastern Anatolia. Anatolica, 24: 195–207.
Rosenberg, M. and Redding, R. W. 2000. Hallan Cemi and early village organization in Eastern ¸ Anatolia. In Life in Neolithic Farming Communities: Social Organization, Identity, and Diﬀerentiation (ed. I. Kuijt). New York: Kluwer, pp. 39–61.
Rosenberg, M. and Togul, H. 1991. The Batman River Archaeological Site Survey, 1990. Anatolica, 17: 241–54.
Rosenberg, M., Nesbitt, M., Redding R. W. and Strasser, T. F. 1995. Hallan Cemi Tepesi: some ¸ preliminary observations concerning Early Neolithic subsistence behaviors in Eastern Anatolia.
Anatolica, 21: 1–12.
Rosenberg, M., Nesbitt, M., Redding, R. W. and Peasnall, B. L. 1998. Hallan Cemi, pig husbandry, ¸ and post-Pleistocene adaptations along the Taurus-Zagros arc (Turkey). Pale´orient, 24: 25–41.
Rowley-Conwy, P. 2001. Time, change and the archaeology of hunter-gatherers: how original is the ‘original aﬄuent society’? In Hunter-Gatherers: An Interdisciplinary Perspective (eds C. Panter-Brick, R. H. Layton and P. Rowley-Conwy). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 39–72.
Savard, M. 2005. Epipalaeolithic to early Neolithic subsistence strategies in the northern Fertile Crescent: the archaeobotanical remains from Hallan Cemi, Demirkoy, M’lefaat and Qermez Dere.
¸ ¨ Doctoral dissertation. Department of Archaeology. University of Cambridge.
Savard, M., Nesbitt, M. and Gale, R. 2003. Archaeobotanical evidence for Early Neolithic diet and subsistence at M’lefaat (Iraq). Pale´orient, 29: 93–106.
Smith, B. D. 1998. The Emergence of Agriculture. New York: Scientiﬁc American Library.
Starkovich, B. 2005. Faunal data from Hallan Cemi Tepesi: a Late Epipaleolithic/Neolithic transition ¸ site in Southeast Anatolia. Master’s report, Department of Anthropology, University of Arizona.
Van Zeist, W. and Bakker-Heeres, J. A. H. 1982. Archaeobotanical studies in the Levant, 1.
´ Neolithic sites in the Damascus basin: Aswad, Ghoraife, Ramad. Palaeohistoria, 24: 165–256.
Van Zeist, W. and Bakker-Heeres, J. A. H. 1984. Archaeobotanical studies in the Levant, 3. Late Palaeolithic Mureybet. Palaeohistoria, 26: 171–99.
Van Zeist, W. and de Roller, G. J. 1991–2. The plant husbandry of aceramic Cayonu, SE Turkey.