FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 13 | 14 || 16 | 17 |   ...   | 38 |

«Leif Atle Beisland University of Agder Dissertation submitted to the Department of Accounting, Auditing and Law at the Norwegian School of Economics ...»

-- [ Page 15 ] --

In an international study comparing value relevance in 20 countries (one of which is Norway), Brown et al. (2006) investigate whether conditional conservatism affects the value relevance of earnings. They conclude that the association between conditional conservatism and the value relevance of earnings depends on the country-specific accrual intensity. Specifically, in countries with higher accrual intensity, more conditionally conservative earnings have a Hope’s (1999) main finding is that the introduction of deferred tax accounting in Norway in 1992 significantly increased the value relevance of earnings numbers.

–  –  –

recognition of gains and losses in earnings. In this study, Norwegian GAAP (NGAAP) is characterised as an accounting system with a high use of accrual accounting. On the presented “accrual index”, NGAAP scores approximately equal to the scores of Australia, Canada, the UK, and the USA. Ali and Hwang (2000) evaluate the value relevance of cash flow, earnings and accruals in 16 countries, among them Norway. For Norway and 11 other countries, Ali and Hwang find that accruals have incremental value relevance beyond that of cash flow.

3 Predictions and Research Design

3.1 Prediction Development and Variable Definitions The purpose of this three-step analysis is to investigate cash flow and accruals’ predictive ability and value relevance, and then to examine possible relations between steps 1 and 2.

Specifically, step 1 analyses the predictive ability of cash flow and accruals for short term future cash flows and earnings. Step 2 examines the value relevance of the same explanatory variables. Step 1 can be regarded as an indirect investigation of value relevance (compare Finger’s statement from section 1 that the value relevance of earnings is studied by testing their ability to predict future earnings and cash flow from operations). This section starts out by discussing possible relations between the prediction analysis of step 1 and the association studies of step 2. The discussion is founded on traditional valuation theory.

The ultimate return of every investment is the cash flow generated by the investment.

Financial theory says that an asset’s value is the present value of its future cash flows. The current value of firm equity is the present value of all future dividends (the dividend model is often attributed to Williams, 1938). The dividend model can be restated in several equivalent forms. For instance, Feltham and Ohlson (1995) show that, under some fairly reasonable

–  –  –

Calculation of cash flow predictions is a vital task in asset valuation. One objective (compare Holthausen & Watts, 2001) of financial reporting is to assist investors, creditors, and others in predicting cash flow. This is accomplished through the accruals, and the FASB asserts that information about earnings and its components (i.e., cash flow and accruals) is generally more predictive of future cash flows than current cash flow. However, modern valuation theory has proven that different versions of cash flow discounting are not the only methods for computing intrinsic equity values. Ohlson (1995) shows that if the clean surplus relation holds, then the dividend model can also be expressed as the book value of equity plus the

present value of all future residual income:

–  –  –

Specifically, the Financial Asset Relation (FAR) and the Financial Asset Marked-to-Market Relation (FAM) must hold. FAR says that all transfers to the common equity holders are made through the financial assets, and these assets are further influenced by financial income and the free cash flows from operations. FAM says that the risk-adjusted expected financial income equals the riskless spot interest rate times the opening book value of the financial assets (Christensen & Feltham, 2003).

–  –  –

Hence, equity value can be computed both as a function of cash flows and as a function of accounting earnings. Both of the presented models are deduced from the dividend model and will therefore give the exact same equity estimate when applied consistently. Today’s accounting earnings should help investors and others assess the level of future cash flow and the level of future earnings. In theory, equity value is a function of the infinite cash flows or earnings. However, one may expect that shorter term firm performance, as measured by cash flow and earnings, gives an indication of company value. For instance, numerous studies document that both cash flow and earnings are relatively persistent (Barth et al., 2001;

Dechow et al., 1998; Finger, 1994; M. Kim & Kross, 2005; Sloan, 1996). Thus, the current accounting measures that predict short term future firm performance should also be associated with current stock returns. This assumption is implicit in most papers studying the accounting variables’ ability to forecast future cash flows or earnings; compare the vast amount of what I earlier referred to as indirect value relevance research. I expect that the accounting measures that are significant predictors of future firm performance are also significantly related to current stock return. Specifically, if accruals and cash flows are related to short term future firm performance as measured by accounting earnings and cash flow, it is reasonable to expect that they are also significantly associated with current stock return.

–  –  –

accruals are totally unrelated to short term firm performance but are still value relevant.

Transitory cash flow and/or earnings items may be associated with stock return even if they, by definition, are not related to future cash flows or earnings. However, if current earnings are highly related to earnings and cash flows one to three years ahead, I suggest that current earnings on average will also be related to current stock return. Prior research strongly proposes that permanent cash flow or earnings are more value relevant than transitory cash flows or earnings (Elliot & Hanna, 1996; Ramakrishnan & Thomas, 1998). Overall, my prediction suggests that there is an association between accounting variables’ predictive ability and their value relevance, but that the association may not be as one-to-one as implicitly assumed in the indirect value relevance studies (compare O. Kim et al., 2007). It should be noted that if there is no association between accounting variables’ relation with future firm performance and their value relevance, then previous studies of accounting variables’ predictive ability would give no indication of value relevance whatsoever.

The primary focus of many value relevance and prediction analyses (e.g., Ball & Shivakumar, 2006; Barth et al., 2001; Francis, LaFond, Olsson, & Schipper, 2005; Rayburn, 1986) is the role of accruals. Accruals, and consequently earnings, are a function of the prevailing accounting regime. Accountants cannot, in principle12, influence the size of the cash flow. In contrast, the size of the accruals follows from subjective judgements of legislators, standard setters and accountants. Thus, particular attention is given to the predictive ability and value relevance of accruals. As for cash flows, there are several versions of the cash flow valuation The net cash flow, the change in cash, is a one hundred percent objective measure. No accounting law or standard can change this measure. However, as soon as one starts to use other measures of cash flow, for instance, cash from operations, the prevailing accounting regime may perfectly well influence the measure. For example, the treatment of intangibles will directly influence the cash flow measure applied in this study; see later in this section.

–  –  –

examines this issue more thoroughly. However, since this study focuses on the possible connection between cash flow/earnings predictions and value relevance, it can be regarded as a follow-up paper of prior research. I leave, therefore, the choice of cash flow concept to future research and choose to employ the same cash flow definitions as the other papers within this research tradition (compare Subramanyam & Venkatachalam, 2007). Hence, cash flow from operations (CF) is defined as (Biddle et al., 1995; Finger, 1994; Klein &

Marquardt, 2006; Rayburn, 1986)14:

–  –  –

I focus on EARN before extraordinary items, since extraordinary items are expected to have little persistence (Barth et al., 2005; Dechow & Ge, 2006) and bear little value relevance Although not specifically related to this discussion, Bowen et al. (1986) look into the relationship between various measures of cash flow.

According to Biddle et al. (1995), this cash flow measure is designed to approximate the definition of cash flow from operations specified by FASB’s Statement No. 95.

The ratio of earnings to cash flow from operations is affected by leverage. Since leverage varies over time and across companies, one might argue that earnings exclusive of interest payments should have been applied in the analysis.

The change variables are defined as follows: X t − X t −1. X is the accounting variables in question, while MVE is MVEt −1 market value of equity, compare also section 4.

Including first-year instalment of long term debt.

–  –  –

variables – CF, EARN and ACC – are scaled by market value of equity at the beginning of each year; this is the preferred scaling factor according to Easton and Sommers (2003). In this study, observations are pooled cross-sectionally and over time. Christie (1987) states that scaling avoids spurious correlation due to size and reduces problems with heteroskedasticity.

In comparable studies, there seems to be no standard for which variable is preferable for scaling. Some researchers choose to deflate by average total assets (for instance Barth et al., 2001; Francis & Smith, 2005; Sloan, 1996), while others scale by market value of equity (for instance Biddle et al., 1995; Dechow, 1994; Francis et al., 2003; Rayburn, 1986). Barth and Kallapur (1996) claim that scale should be handled by including a scale proxy as an independent variable in cases where the true scale factor is not known. Easton and Sommers (2003), however, state that the scale factor is known in market-based accounting research.

They maintain that market capitalisation is more than just a possible scale proxy - it is scale.

In this study, the choice of scale factor follows from my econometric models (see the next section). Step 2 of the analysis uses a return specification. In the return specification, market value of equity is the scale factor. To assure a consistent analysis of my proposed prediction, it is essential that the same scale factors are used in both steps of the study.

3.2 Econometric Model Step 1 of the study is to analyse the predictive ability of cash flow and accruals for future cash flows and earnings. Step 2 is a value relevance analysis of the same explanatory variables.

The following regression specifications are used in steps 1 and 2, respectively (compare Ali &

Lee-Seok, 2000; Easton & Harris, 1991; Baruch Lev & Zarowin, 1999):

–  –  –

Step 1 starts out by regressing next year’s cash flow on current cash flow and accruals. Kim and Kross (2005) find it puzzling that there is no relationship between earnings’ ability to predict one-year-ahead cash flow and their value relevance. However, since value is a function of all future cash flows and not only the first one, I test the measures’ predictive ability for a slightly longer horizon as well. Kim et al. (2007) show that individual years might be contaminated by value irrelevant noise that even out over time and thus are not priced. It may be the case that this year’s accruals and cash flow are related to longer term firm performance even if they are not related to next year’s cash flow and earnings18. Hence, in part b of step 1, the mean of the next three cash flows ( meanCFt +1, 2,3 for simplicity) is regressed on current cash flow and accruals. Regression specifications (1a) and (1b) are in some sense based on the “cash is king” perspective. One acknowledges that because cash is the ultimate return from all investments, the predictive ability with respect to future cash It may also be the case that the relations are non-linear; compare discussion of positive versus negative earnings at the end of this section.

–  –  –

to modern valuation theory, current equity value may be estimated as a function of future accounting earnings. Hence, the predictive ability of accruals and cash flow with respect to future earnings is as important as their ability to predict future cash flow. Specifications (1c) and (1d) are equivalent to the previous specifications with the exception that earnings are now used as the dependent variable. Generally, one will expect that three-year averages of the variables are less noisy than individual observations. As such, the influence of temporary noise in cash flow and/or earnings will be less in specifications (1b) and (1d) than in (1a) and (1c).

In step 2 of the analysis, future cash flow and earnings are replaced by current stock return as the dependent variable in order to evaluate the value relevance of cash flow and accruals19.

The prediction says that if cash flow and accruals are related to future cash flow and accounting earnings, it is reasonable to expect that they are also associated with current stock returns. In other words, if the β' s are significantly different from zero in step 1 of the analysis, I expect them to be significantly different from zero in step 2 as well. Cash flow and accruals might be related to long term cash flows and earnings even if they are not associated with the more short term measures of firm performance employed in this study. Hence, current cash flow and accruals may be value relevant even if they are non-significant in step 1 of the study.

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 13 | 14 || 16 | 17 |   ...   | 38 |

Similar works:

«What consensus? Geopolitics and policy paradigms in China and the United States MARK BEESON AND FUJIAN LI The bilateral relationship between the United States and the People’s Republic of China (PRC) has rapidly become the most important in the world. The reasons for this pre-eminence are not hard to fathom: the US and China are the two biggest economies in the world, and they are also the world’s most consequential strategic actors. Even though China’s military capabilities and spending...»

«DO INSIDERS WHO PLEDGE THEIR SHARES MANIPULATE REPORTED EARNINGS? Aman Asija IMImobile, Hyderabad 1.amanasija@gmail.com Vijaya B. Marisetty Department of Economics, Finance, and Marketing, RMIT University vijayabhaskar.marisetty@rmit.edu.au Srinivasan Rangan Finance and Control Area, Indian Institute of Management, Bangalore srinivasan.rangan@iimb.ernet.in First Draft: June 2014 This Draft: December 2014 We are grateful to Nagpurnanand Prabhala, our discussant at the NSE NYU Stern Initiative on...»

«Wellcome to the Econophysics Colloquium 2016! In this booklet you will find relevant information about the colloquium such as the program, list of abstracts, list of participants and participating institutions. We hope you all have a pleasant and productive stay in São Paulo! Program Wednesday, 27 Thursday, 28 Friday, 29 Registration 8.30 – 9:15 am Welcome 9:15 – 9.30 am Universality in the interoccurrence times in Multiplex dependence structure of Measuring economic behavior using online...»

«HOME ENERGY EFFICIENCY May 2016 Westgate House 2a Prebend Street London N1 8PT 020 7359 8000 joanne@ukace.org Bright Blue report on Home Energy Efficiency: evidence from ACE Introduction The Association for the Conservation of Energy represents the energy efficiency sector in the UK. It works to enable the UK to become energy efficient, driving productivity and business competitiveness, providing warm and healthy homes, delivering a secure energy future and a vibrant low carbon economy. Working...»

«      ETUDE DE FAISABILITE SUR L’INSERTION  ECONOMIQUE DES PERSONNES EN  SITUATION DE HANDICAP                       janvier 2011    Rapport final      Impasse Thévenoud‐330‐Secteur 01‐ Ouagadougou  01 BP 6490 Ouagadougou 01, Burkina Faso  Tel: +226 50 30 88 60 – Fax: +226 50 31 25 43  Email: ici@fasonet.bf/ ici@mail‐bf.com   Site web: www.ici‐burkina.com   2  SOMMAIRE  1  Introduction  1.1 ...»

«Ten Thousand Businesses Would Thrive in a Harmonious Family: Chinese Conflict Resolution Styles in Cross-Cultural Families Shaorong Huang University of Cincinnati Abstract Traditionally, Chinese see a conflict as a deviation from harmony. They believe that jia he wan shi xing (ten thousand businesses would thrive in a harmonious family). This attitude toward conflict has its links with Chinese traditional concept of family, and traditional Chinese thought represented by Confucianism and Taoism....»

«NUMERICAL METHODS IN FINANCE GERAD 25th Anniversary Series Essays and Surveys in Global Optimization Charles Audet, Pierre Hansen, and Gilles Savard, editors Graph Theory and Combinatorial Optimization David Avis, Alain Hertz, and Odile Marcotte, editors Numerical Methods in Finance Hatem Ben-Ameur and Michele Breton, editors Analysis, Control and Optimization of Complex Dynamic Systems El-Kebir Boukas and Roland Malhame, editors Column Generation Guy Desaulniers, Jacques Desrosiers, and Marius...»

«VOLUME 61, NO. 1 FEbRUaRY 2008 Economic History Review, 61, 1 (2008), pp. 26–53 Consumption, retailing, and medicine in early-modern London By PATRICK WALLIS This article examines the early development of specialized retail shops in early modern London. It argues that apothecaries’ shops were sites of innovative shop design and display. These practices were responses to attitudes to consumption, the problematic nature of the medical commodities which apothecaries sold, and, particularly,...»

«Dr. Charlene Zietsma Associate Professor, Ann Brown Chair of Organization Studies, Director of Entrepreneurial Studies Schulich School of Business, York University Room N317, Seymour Schulich Building 4700 Keele Street, Toronto, ON M3J 1P3 Tel: 416.736.2100 Ext 77919 czietsma@schulich.yorku.ca EDUCATION Doctor of Philosophy, Organizational Behaviour, University of British Columbia, 2003. Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council Doctoral Fellowship Recipient, 1997-2000. Dissertation:...»

«What do all these numbers mean? Odds ratios, relative risks, and number needed to treat. Steve Simon P.Mean Consulting www.pmean.com 2. Why do I offer this webinar for free? I offer free statistics webinars partly for fun and partly to build up goodwill for my consulting business, – www.pmean.com/consult.html. Also see my Facebook and LinkedIn pages – www.facebook.com/pmean – www.linkedin.com/in/pmean I provide a free newsletter about Statistics, The Monthly Mean. – www.pmean.com/news...»

«RAY KING & ASSOCIATES Incorporated Public Accountants Registered Auditors 5 Bridge Court, City Gate, St Augustine Street, Dublin 8 Telephone: 01 679 1017 and 01 679 8960 Fax: 01 679 8960 E-Mail: rayking@rayking.ie and rayking@ireland.com Website: www.rayking.ie DUBLIN DOCKLANDS DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY Report on Finance Function – Particularly Procurement and Payroll 1 February 2010 DUBLIN DOCKLANDS DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY Report on Finance Function – Particularly Procurement and Payroll...»

«Munich Personal RePEc Archive Macroculture, Athletics and Democracy in ancient Greece Emmanouel/Marios/Lazaros Economou and Nicholas Kyriazis University of Thessaly Department of Economic Studies 8 May 2012 Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/45903/ MPRA Paper No. 45903, posted 6 April 2013 16:11 UTC Macroculture, Athletics and Democracy in ancient Greece Emmanouil Marios L. Economou and*Nicholas Kyriazis Abstract In the present essay we examine whether and how sports affected the...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.