«OPTIMIZATION AND MONITORING OF GEOLOGICAL CARBON STORAGE OPERATIONS A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE PROGRAM IN EARTH, ENERGY AND ENVIRONMENTAL ...»
130 CHAPTER 6. SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE WORK Nomenclature Greek Symbols vector of time-averaged top layer mobility error ∆ variables characterizing leaks in the cap rock η ˆ Λ measure of the similarity of leaked CO2 between two models ˆ λ CO2 mobility Ω feasible region for optimization variables φ porosity scaling parameters θ vector of K-L parameters ξ Variables a constant in permeability/porosity relationship b constant in permeability/porosity relationship dobs observed injection and monitoring well data F expected error from approximate history match forward model for ﬂow simulation f (il, jl ) grid block indices for a leakage site J optimization objective function Jλ time-averaged total CO2 mobility in the top layer over 500 years Jave time-averaged mobile CO2 over 1000 years J1000 mobile CO2 at 1000 years J100 mobile CO2 at 100 years K number of brine cycling events k permeability 132 CHAPTER 6.
Aliyev, E. 2011. Use of Hybrid Approaches and Meta-Optimization for Well Placement Problems. MS thesis, Stanford University.
Anchliya, A, Ehlig-Economides, CA, & Jafarpour, B. 2012. Aquifer management to accelerate CO2 dissolution and trapping. SPE Journal, 17(3), 805–816.
Artus, V, Durlofsky, LJ, Onwunalu, J, & Aziz, K. 2006. Optimization of nonconventional wells under uncertainty using statistical proxies. Computational Geosciences, 10(4), 389–404.
Audet, C, & Dennis Jr, JE. 2002. Analysis of generalized pattern searches. SIAM Journal on Optimization, 13(3), 889–903.
Bangerth, W, Klie, H, Wheeler, MF, Stoffa, PL, & Sen, MK. 2006. On optimization algorithms for the reservoir oil well placement problem. Computational Geosciences, 10(3), 303–319.
Bellout, MC, Echeverr´ Ciaurri, D, Durlofsky, LJ, Foss, B, & Kleppe, ıa J. 2012. Joint optimization of oil well placement and controls. Computational Geosciences, 16(4), 1–19.
Bennion, D, & Bachu, S. 2006. Dependence on temperature, pressure, and salinity of the IFT and relative permeability displacement characteristics of CO2 injected in deep saline aquifers. SPE 102138. In: SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition.
134 BIBLIOGRAPHYBenson, S, Cook, P, Anderson, J, Bachu, S, Nimir, HB, Basu, B, Bradshaw, J, Deguchi, G, Gale, J, & von Goerne, G. 2005. Underground geological storage. Pages 195–276 of: Metz, B (ed), IPCC Special Report on Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage. Cambridge University Press.
Bergmo, P, Grimstad, A, & Lindeberg, E. 2011. Simultaneous CO2 injection and water production to optimise aquifer storage capacity. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control, 5(3), 555–564.
Boyd, S, & Vandenberghe, L. 2004. Convex Optimization. Cambridge University Press.
Chabora, ER, & Benson, SM. 2009. Brine displacement and leakage detection using pressure measurements in aquifers overlying CO2 storage reservoirs. Energy Procedia, 1(1), 2405–2412.
Chaloner, K., & Verdinelli, I. 1995. Bayesian experimental design: A review.
Statistical Science, 10(3), 273–304.
Chen, Y, & Durlofsky, LJ. 2006. Eﬃcient incorporation of global eﬀects in upscaled models of two-phase ﬂow and transport in heterogeneous formations. Multiscale Modeling & Simulation, 5(2), 445–475.
Class, H, Ebigbo, A, Helmig, R, Dahle, HK, Nordbotten, J, Celia, M, Audigane, P, Darcis, M, Ennis-King, J, Fan, Y, Flemisch, B, Gasda, SE, Jin, M, Krug, S, Labregere, D, Naderi Beni, A, Pawar, RJ, Sbai, A, Thomas, S, Trenty, L, & Wei, L. 2009. A benchmark study on problems related to CO2 storage in geologic formations. Computational Geosciences, 13(4), 409–434.
Clerc, M. 2006. Stagnation analysis in particle swarm optimisation or what happens when nothing happens. Technical Report CSM-460, Department of Computer Science, University of Essex.
Clerc, M. 2010. Particle Swarm Optimization. Wiley-ISTE.
BIBLIOGRAPHYConn, AR, Scheinberg, K, & Vicente, LN. 2009. Introduction to DerivativeFree Optimization. Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics.
Daley, T, Myer, L, Peterson, J, Majer, E, & Hoversten, G. 2008. Timelapse crosswell seismic and VSP monitoring of injected CO2 in a brine aquifer.
Environmental Geology, 54(8), 1657–1665.
Doughty, C. 2007. Modeling geologic storage of carbon dioxide: Comparison of non-hysteretic and hysteretic characteristic curves. Energy Conversion and Management, 48(6), 1768–1781.
Doughty, C, Freifeld, B, & Trautz, R. 2008. Site characterization for CO2 geologic storage and vice versa: the Frio brine pilot, Texas, USA as a case study.
Environmental Geology, 54(8), 1635–1656.
Ebigbo, A, Class, H, & Helmig, R. 2007. CO2 leakage through an abandoned well: Problem-oriented benchmarks. Computational Geosciences, 11(2), 103–115.
Echeverr´ Ciaurri, D, Isebor, OJ, & Durlofsky, LJ. 2011. Application ıa of derivative-free methodologies to generally constrained oil production optimisation problems. International Journal of Mathematical Modelling and Numerical Optimisation, 2(2), 134–161.
Ennis-King, J, Dance, T, Xu, J, Boreham, C, Freifeld, B, Jenkins, C, Paterson, L, Sharma, S, Stalker, L, & Underschultz, J. 2011. The role of heterogeneity in CO2 storage in a depleted gas ﬁeld: History matching of simulation models to ﬁeld data for the CO2CRC Otway Project, Australia. Energy Procedia, 4, 3494–3501.
Fan, Y, Durlofsky, LJ, & Tchelepi, HA. 2012. A fully-coupled ﬂow-reactivetransport formulation based on element conservation, with application to CO2 storage simulations. Advances in Water Resources, 42, 47 – 61.
Fernandez Martinez, JL, Garcia Gonzalo, E, & Fernandez Alvarez, JP. 2008. Theoretical analysis of particle swarm trajectories through a mechanical analogy. International Journal of Computational Intelligence Research, 4, 92–104.
Fessenden, JE, Clegg, SM, Rahn, TA, Humphries, SD, & Baldridge, WS.
2010. Novel MVA tools to track CO2 seepage, tested at the ZERT controlled release site in Bozeman, MT. Environmental Earth Sciences, 60(2), 325–334.
Flett, M, Gurton, R, & Taggart, I. 2004. The function of gas-water relative permeability hysteresis in the sequestration of carbon dioxide in saline formations.
SPE 88485. In: SPE Asia Paciﬁc Oil and Gas Conference and Exhibition.
Gasda, SE, Bachu, S, & Celia, MA. 2004. Spatial characterization of the location of potentially leaky wells penetrating a deep saline aquifer in a mature sedimentary basin. Environmental Geology, 46(6-7), 707–720.
Guyaguler, B, & Horne, R. 2000. Optimization of well placement. TransactionsAmerican Society of Mechanical Engineers Journal of Energy Resources Technology, 122(2), 64–70.
Guyaguler, B, & Horne, R. 2004. Uncertainty assessment of well-placement optimization. SPE Journal, 7(1), 24–32.
Haber, E., Horesh, L., & Tenorio, L. 2008. Numerical methods for experimental design of large-scale linear ill-posed inverse problems. Inverse Problems, 24(5), 055012.
He, J, Sarma, P, & Durlofsky, LJ. 2013. Reduced-order ﬂow modeling and geological parameterization for ensemble-based data assimilation. Computers & Geosciences, 55, 54–69.
Hooke, R, & Jeeves, T. 1961. Direct search solution of numerical and statistical problems. Journal of the ACM, 8(2), 212–229.
Hovorka, S, Benson, S, Doughty, C, Freifeld, B, Sakurai, S, Daley, T, Kharaka, Y, Holtz, M, Trautz, R, Nance, H, Myer, L, & Knauss,
BIBLIOGRAPHYK. 2006. Measuring permanence of CO2 storage in saline formations: The Frio experiment. Environmental Geosciences, 13(2), 105–121.
Isebor, OJ. 2013. Derivative-Free Optimization for Generalized Oil Field Development. Ph.D. thesis, Stanford University.
Isebor, OJ, Echeverr´ Ciaurri, D, & Durlofsky, LJ. 2013. Generalized ıa ﬁeld development optimization using derivative-free procedures. SPE 163631.
SPE Reservoir Simulation Symposium.
JafarGandomi, A, & Curtis, A. 2012. Assessing the monitorability of CO2 saturation in subsurface saline aquifers. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control, 7, 244–260.
Jansen, JD. 2011. Adjoint-based optimization of multi-phase ﬂow through porous media–A review. Computers & Fluids, 46(1), 40–51.
Jansen, JD, Brouwer, D, Naevdal, G, & Van Kruijsdijk, C. 2005. Closedloop reservoir management. First Break, 23(1), 43–48.
Javandel, I, Tsang, CF, Witherspoon, PA., & Morganwalp, D. 1988. Hydrologic detection of abandoned wells near proposed injection wells for hazardous waste disposal. Water Resources Research, 24(2), 261–270.
Jordan, PD, Oldenburg, CM, & Nicot, JP. 2011. Estimating the probability of CO2 plumes encountering faults. Greenhouse Gases: Science and Technology, 1(2), 160–174.
Juanes, R, Spiteri, E, Orr, F, & Blunt, M. 2006. Impact of relative permeability hysteresis on geological CO2 storage. Water Resources Research, 42, W12418.
Kennedy, J, & Eberhart, R. 1995. Particle swarm optimization. Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Neural Networks, 4, 1942–1948.
Kitanidis, PK. 2007. On stochastic inverse modeling. Geophysical Monograph Series, 171, 19–30.
Kolda, T, Lewis, R, & Torczon, V. 2003. Optimization by direct search: New perspectives on some classical and modern methods. SIAM Review, 45(3), 385–482.
Krause, M, Perrin, J, & Benson, S. 2009. Modeling permeability distributions
in a sandstone core for history matching coreﬂood experiments. SPE 126340. In:
SPE International Conference on CO2 Capture, Storage, and Utilization.
Krevor, S, Pini, R, Zuo, L, & Benson, S. 2012. Relative permeability and trapping of CO2 and water in sandstone rocks at reservoir conditions. Water Resources Research, 48(2), W02532.
Kumar, D. 2007. Optimization of Well Settings to Maximize Residually Trapped CO2 in Geologic Carbon Sequestration. MS thesis, Stanford University.
Leeuwenburgh, O, Egberts, P, & Abbink, O. 2010. Ensemble methods for reservoir life-cycle optimization and well placement. SPE 136916. In: SPE/DGS Saudi Arabia Section Technical Symposium and Exhibition.
Leonenko, Y, & Keith, D. 2008. Reservoir engineering to accelerate the dissolution of CO2 stored in aquifers. Environmental Science & Technology, 42(8), 2742–2747.
Lewicki, JL, Hilley, GE, & Oldenburg, CM. 2005. An improved strategy to detect CO2 leakage for veriﬁcation of geologic carbon sequestration. Geophysical Research Letters, 32(19).
Lewicki, JL, Birkholzer, J, & Tsang, C. 2007. Natural and industrial analogues for leakage of CO2 from storage reservoirs: Identiﬁcation of features, events, and processes and lessons learned. Environmental Geology, 52(3), 457–467.
Li, L, & Jafarpour, B. 2012. A variable-control well placement optimization for improved reservoir development. Computational Geosciences, 16(4), 871–889.
Loeve, M. 1977. Probability Theory, I and II. 4th edn. Springer-Verlag.
BIBLIOGRAPHYMagnant, Z. 2011. Numerical Methods for Optimal Experimental Design of IllPosed Problems. Ph.D. thesis, Emory University.
Matott, S, Leung, K, & Sim, J. 2011. Application of MATLAB and Python optimizers to two case studies involving groundwater ﬂow and contaminant transport modeling. Computers & Geosciences, 37(11), 1894–1899.
Nghiem, L, Yang, C, Shrivastava, V, Kohse, B, Hassam, M, & Card, C. 2009. Risk mitigation through the optimization of residual gas and solubility trapping for CO2 storage in saline aquifers. Energy Procedia, 1(1), 3015–3022.
Nghiem, L, Shrivastava, V, Kohse, B, Hassam, M, & Yang, C. 2010. Simulation and optimization of trapping processes for CO2 storage in saline aquifers.
Journal of Canadian Petroleum Technology, 49(8), 15–22.
Nordbotten, JM, Celia, MA, Bachu, S, & Dahle, HK. 2005. Semianalytical solution for CO2 leakage through an abandoned well. Environmental Science & Technology, 39(2), 602–611.
Oliver, D. 1996. Multiple realizations of the permeability ﬁeld from well test data.
SPE Journal, 1(2), 145–154.
Oliver, DS, & Chen, Y. 2011. Recent progress on reservoir history matching: a review. Computational Geosciences, 15(1), 185–221.
Oliver, DS, Reynolds, AC, & Liu, N. 2008. Inverse Theory for Petroleum Reservoir Characterization and History Matching. Cambridge University Press.
Onwunalu, J, & Durlofsky, LJ. 2010. Application of a particle swarm optimization algorithm for determining optimum well location and type. Computational Geosciences, 14(1), 183–198.
Owunalu, J. 2010. Optimization of Field Development Using Particle Swarm Optimization and New Well Pattern Descriptions. Ph.D. thesis, Stanford University.
Pruess, K, Garc´ J, Kovscek, T, Oldenburg, CM, Rutqvist, J, Steefel, ıa, C, & Xu, T. 2004. Code intercomparison builds conﬁdence in numerical simulation models for geologic disposal of CO2. Energy, 29(9), 1431–1444.
Remy, N, Boucher, A, & Wu, J. 2009. Applied Geostatistics with SGeMS: a User’s Guide. Cambridge University Press.
Reynolds, AC, He, N, Chu, L, & Oliver, DS. 1996. Reparameterization techniques for generating reservoir descriptions conditioned to variograms and well-test pressure data. SPE Journal, 1(4), 413–426.
Riaz, A, Hesse, M, Tchelepi, H, & Orr, F. 2006. Onset of convection in a gravitationally unstable diﬀusive boundary layer in porous media. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 548(1), 87–111.
Ringrose, P, Atbi, M, Mason, D, Espinassous, M, & Myhrer, O. 2009.
Plume development around well KB-502 at the In Salah CO2 storage site. First Break, 27(1), 85–89.
Saadatpoor, E, Bryant, S, & Sepehrnoori, K. 2010. New trapping mechanism in carbon sequestration. Transport in Porous Media, 82(1), 3–17.
Sarma, P, & Chen, W. 2008. Eﬃcient well placement optimization with gradientbased algorithms and adjoint models. SPE 112257. In: SPE Intelligent Energy Conference and Exhibition.
Sarma, P, Durlofsky, LJ, Aziz, K, & Chen, W. 2006. Eﬃcient real-time reservoir management using adjoint-based optimal control and model updating.
Computational Geosciences, 10(1), 3–36.
Sarma, P, Durlofsky, LJ, & Aziz, K. 2008. Kernel principal component analysis for eﬃcient, diﬀerentiable parameterization of multipoint geostatistics. Mathematical Geosciences, 40(1), 3–32.
Schlumberger. 2010. Eclipse Reference Manual. Version 2010.2.
BIBLIOGRAPHYShamshiri, H, & Jafarpour, B. 2012. Controlled CO2 injection into heterogeneous geologic formations for improved solubility and residual trapping. Water Resources Research, 48(2), W02530.
Singh, V, Cavanagh, A, Hansen, H, Nazarian, B, Iding, M, & Ringrose, P. 2010. Reservoir modeling of CO2 plume behavior calibrated against monitoring data from Sleipner, Norway. SPE 134891. In: SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition.
Solomon, S. 2007. Climate Change 2007: The Physical Science Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press.
Spycher, N, & Pruess, K. 2005. CO2 -H2 O mixtures in the geological sequestration of CO2. II. Partitioning in chloride brines at 12-100 C and up to 600 bar. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 69(13), 3309–3320.
Suman, A. 2013. Joint Inversion of Production and Time-Lapse Seismic Data: Application to Norne Field. Ph.D. thesis, Stanford University.
Sun, AY, & Nicot, JP. 2012. Inversion of pressure anomaly data for detecting leakage at geologic carbon sequestration sites. Advances in Water Resources, 44, 20 – 29.
Sun, AY, Zeidouni, M, Nicot, JP, Lu, Z, & Zhang, D. 2013. Assessing leakage detectability at geologic CO2 sequestration sites using the probabilistic collocation method. Advances in Water Resources, 56(1), 49–60.
Tarantola, A. 2005. Inverse Problem Theory and Methods for Model Parameter Estimation. Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics.
Wang, H, Echeverr´ Ciaurri, D, Durlofsky, LJ, & Cominelli, A. 2012.
ıa Optimal well placement under uncertainty using a retrospective optimization framework. SPE Journal, 17(1), 112–121.
Xu, T, Kharaka, Y, Doughty, C, Freifeld, B, & Daley, T. 2010. Reactive transport modeling to study changes in water chemistry induced by CO2 injection at the Frio-I Brine Pilot. Chemical Geology, 271(3-4), 153–164.
Yamamoto, H, & Doughty, C. 2011. Investigation of gridding eﬀects for numerical simulations of CO2 geologic sequestration. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control, 5(4), 975 – 985.
Yeten, B, Durlofsky, LJ, & Aziz, K. 2003. Optimization of nonconventional well type, location, and trajectory. SPE Journal, 8(3), 200–210.
Zandvliet, MHM, van Essen, G, Brouwer, R, & Jansen, JD. 2008. Adjointbased well-placement optimization under production constraints. SPE Journal,