FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:     | 1 || 3 | 4 |   ...   | 5 |

«1 Contested science in the media: linguistic traces of news writers’ framing activity Trine Dahl, Norwegian School of Economics, Department of ...»

-- [ Page 2 ] --

In addition to the already noted divergence in the understanding and application of the notion of framing, another problematic aspect of framing research is the lack of compatibility across studies in terms of suggested frame categories (Hertog & McLeod 2001; de Vreese, 2005). Each new study tends to develop its own more or less unique frame set. In an attempt at developing a more unified application of framing as a process, de Vreese (2005) suggested a media frame typology consisting of generic and issue-specific frames. Porter & Hulme (2013), however, make the observation that “[e]ven in the seemingly unique context of geoengineering, journalists employ similar framings to those used for a diverse range of other issues” (p. 351). Several of the frames that have been posited for geoengineering are of a clearly generic nature, e.g., innovation and economics (Porter & Hulme, 2013), ambivalence, benefits for society and norms & values (Scholte et al., 2013), and war and fight (Luokkanen et al., 2013). Others, like controllability (Luokkanen et al., 2013) and messing with nature (e.g., Corner et al., 2013, a survey-based study of public perceptions), tend toward the issue-specific, even if they, too, may apply to other issues than geoengineering, e.g., nuclear power and biotechnology. Perhaps the clearest proposed label for a geoengineering-specific frame is plan B (posited as an independent frame in Nerlich & Jaspal, 2012, as a sub-frame of the controllability frame in Luokkanen et al., 2013, and as a subframe of the avoiding catastrophe frame in Scholte et al., 2013). The issue of frame categories will be further considered below.

A text linguistic approach to framing Content analysis and metaphor studies (uncovering the ‘stories’ told), experiments and surveys (showing how the ‘stories’ are being perceived), and critical discourse analysis (focusing on ideological effects on discursive practices) are obviously relevant analytical approaches to studying framing. However, I believe that a text linguistic approach can add to our understanding of framing by providing insight into how writers exploit their rhetorical competence to strategically frame the issue at hand in the communicative context within which they operate.

Irrespective of methodological approach, a crucial first step in any empirical study is to define the relevant units of analysis. According to Entman (1993), the framing researcher needs to look for “the presence or absence of certain key words, stock phrases, stereotyped images, sources of information, and sentences that provide thematically reinforcing clusters of facts or judgments” (1993:52). Similar lists of framing elements are suggested in the geoengineering-related studies involving news discourse briefly introduced above, e.g., policy recommendations, headlines, and lexical choices (Porter & Hulme, 2013, p. 344), mentions of…, any material that…, and statements (Buck, 2013, p. 171), or sentences and phrases referring to… (Scholte et al., 2013, p.

7). As indicated in the introduction, a text linguistic analysis of framing will have to involve a systematic linguistics-based approach to the selection of features to be considered in the analysis.

In the next sections, the aim is therefore to outline such an approach in order to investigate news writers’ framing activity.

Key framing locations As already indicated, I here suggest that genre features may serve as a point of departure for identifying key framing locations. News texts tend to be classified into two broad categories, news and comment/opinion (e.g., Bell 1991),2 each with its own genre or register repertoire (e.g., hard versus soft news (White 1998) and comment in the shape of, e.g., feature articles or editorials). Headlines and leads are considered to be genre defining text features of news reports, where they serve the pragmatic functions of marketing and attention grabbing as well as information structuring and summarization (e.g., Cotter, 2010). Another defining feature of news reports is sources’ statements, which, inter alia, serve the function of authenticating the information and making it more ‘objective’ (Cotter, 2010), but which may also serve the news writer’s own ‘mission’ (Calsamiglia & López Ferrero, 2003), and mediate a specific value position (White, 2012).3 All these functions appear compatible with the notion of framing. It is therefore assumed that headline, lead, and sources’ statements are likely to represent important text locations for framing activity.

Framing indicators When it comes to news writers’ exploitation of linguistic resources for framing purposes, lexis reflecting semantic field (e.g., science, politics, economics; or risk, uncertainty, ethics) serves as an important indicator of which aspect (or aspects) of a potentially multifaceted phenomenon the journalist has chosen to make salient to his/her readers in a given context. In addition, it is suggested that the notion of evaluation offers a fruitful basis from which to study the framing process. Even if news reports are typically considered impersonal and ‘objective’, it has been demonstrated (e.g., White, 2012; see also Oddo, 2013) that there, too, attitudinal mechanisms are at work, serving to advance specific value positions. Evaluation is a complex notion which has been discussed within a variety of analytical frameworks (see, e.g., Hunston & Thompson, 2000).

The analysis here draws on Martin & White’s (2005) conceptually based Appraisal framework.

Martin & White (2005) establish a framework of appraisal resources related to attitudes, feelings, and values, used to construe interpersonal meaning. The framework comprises three interacting domains: attitude (involving emotions, judgment and appreciation), engagement (relating to the writer’s stance towards his/her own and others’ value positions), and graduation (involving gradability in terms of force (high/low intensity) or focus (core/marginal category membership)).4 The next section presents a case study intended to illustrate how a qualitative framing analysis based on the principles outlined above − linked to framing location and framing indicators − may be carried out.

Case study I start by a description of the material, including a brief overview of the context in which the texts were produced. I then go on to analyze framing activity, first in headline and lead, and then through sources’ statements.5 Next, I discuss the outcome of the analysis, drawing together framing information from each text in a table. This information in turn serves as a basis for undertaking a frame classification of the analyzed texts.

Material As indicated, the material for this case study consists of six news items which all report on a scientific study involving one of the very few geoengineering experiments carried out outside the scientific drawing board. The experiment was presented in the paper “Deep carbon export from a Southern Ocean iron-fertilized diatom bloom” (Smetacek et al., 2012), published in Nature (online) on July 18, 2012. The six texts have not been not arbitrarily selected. In August 2012, as I was googling for information on geoengineering, I accidentally came across two reports on the Nature experiment, published in the Guardian and the Daily Mail, respectively. The reports seemed to draw attention to different aspects and implications of the experiment. This spurred me to carry out further web searches − based on combinations of the search strings ‘geoengineering’, ‘climate’, ‘Smetacek’, ‘ocean iron fertilization/fertilisation, and ‘Nature’ − with the purpose of identifying more texts on the same event. My intention was to establish a corpus which could serve as a basis for a text linguistic framing analysis. The six texts to be analyzed here represent the only English-language written news items reporting on the study that I was able to identify through this search process.

As already indicated, the experiment involves ocean iron fertilization (OIF), a geoengineering technique which implies lacing the sea with iron. The iron stimulates the growth of blooms and plankton that sequester CO2, and the most important novelty feature of the research is the recording of what actually happens to the fertilized biomass as it sinks deep into the ocean. On July 18, AWI − the Alfred Wegener Institute for Polar and Marine Research in Bremerhaven, Germany, the home institution of the lead researchers − issued a press release on the paper. The Nature paper refers to geoengineering in its general motivation for undertaking the study: “The issue is currently receiving broad attention because OIF is one of the techniques listed in the geoengineering portfolio to mitigate the effects of climate change” (Smetacek et al., 2012, p.

313). Interestingly, the press release does not mention geoengineering at all, and motivates the importance of the study in the lead paragraph as follows: “These results […] provide a valuable contribution to our better understanding of the global carbon cycle” (AWI, 2012). The six news items were published on the same day as the scientific paper and press release, or the next, indicating that they may be responses to an embargoed text offer by the research institution to the media.

The analyzed texts come from the following sources (online versions): the US-based Scientific American (SA), New York Times (NYT), and Washington Post (WP), and the UK-based Guardian (GUA), Daily Mail (DM), and BBC News (BBC). In the following, the source abbreviations SA, NYT, WP, GUA, DM, and BBC will be used to indicate the texts or text producers. As for the American texts, SA appeared in the Energy & Sustainability News section of the popular science magazine, while NYT and WP are blog posts, from the New York Times’ ‘Green – A blog about energy and the environment’ (discontinued in March 2013) and Washington Post’s ‘Wonkblog’, respectively. As for the British texts, GUA appeared in the ‘Environment’ section of the newspaper, DM in the ‘Science’ section, while BBC appeared on the broadcaster’s website section ‘Science & Environment’. The six journalists are all environment and/or science reporters.

Four of the texts − SA, GUA, DM, and BBC – thus are news reports, while NYT and WP are newspaper blog posts. However, in terms of overall structure, the texts appear quite similar in that they all have a headline, a lead element, and sources’ statements. As for intended readership, it also seems reasonable to assume that readers of news reports found in the Science/Environment section of a newspaper/popular science magazine (interested non-specialist) are likely to share crucial features of readers of the dedicated Green blog (NYT). A cursory reading of the WP blog post indicated that the treatment of the issue/event reported on was also targeted at nonspecialists interested in climate change-related issues. Hence, on the basis of textual and contextual features (including the journalists’ field of expertise), the texts were considered sufficiently similar for current purposes to be discussed together. They will all be referred to as news reports.

Framing activity in headline and lead News text headlines (and in some cases also leads, e.g., Cotter, 2010) have been described in terms of, e.g., linguistic form (Bell, 1991), communicative function (Dor, 2003; Ifantidou, 2009) as well as in terms of their importance in framing a story (Pan & Kosicki, 1993). As regards news media practices, it is common knowledge that headline and lead are typically not produced by the reporting journalist, but by a subeditor (Bell, 1991; Cotter, 2010). This might lead to a different frame being exploited in headline/lead that in the body of the text. Readers will in such cases be left to negotiate potentially diverging messages. Whether there are instances of this kind in the current material will be addressed in the discussion below. The headlines for the six reports are given in Table 1, which also includes reporter name and publication date. The more extensive leads can be found in the Appendix.

Table 1. Headlines of the six news reports.


SA Controversial Spewed Iron Experiment Succeeds as Carbon Sink (David Biello,18 July) NYT A Way to Trap Carbon Deep in the Ocean (Rachel Nuwer, 19 July) WP Could plankton help us tackle climate change? (Brad Plumer, 19 July) GUA Dumping iron at sea can bury carbon for centuries, study shows (Damian Carrington,18 July) DM Could dumping iron in the oceans cure climate change? First 'geo-engineering' trial is hailed a success (Rob Waugh, 18/19 July) BBC Climate ocean tech fix 'can work', research suggests (Richard Black, 18 July) As Table 1 shows, the headline producer of four of the texts makes use of lexis which refers to a research activity, marking this as the selected frame: experiment (SA), study (GUA), trial (DM),

and research (BBC), while the producers of two blog post headings only do so implicitly (NYT:

a way to trap carbon; WP: plankton…tackle climate change). Three of the headline producers (WP, DM, BBC) refer to the broader context (the climate issue), while the other three (SA, NYT, GUA) refer to the substance involved in the experiment, carbon, which is also the focus of the title of the Nature paper (see the previous section).

Pages:     | 1 || 3 | 4 |   ...   | 5 |

Similar works:

«Electricity Generation in Fiji: Assessing the Impact of Renewable Technologies on Costs and Financial Risk Matthew Dornan* and Frank Jotzo Resource Management in Asia-Pacific Program, Crawford School of Economics and Government, The Australian National University. *Corresponding author/presenter. E-mail Address: matthew.dornan@anu.edu.au Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society 55th Annual National Conference, Melbourne, 8-11 February, 2011 Electricity Generation in Fiji:...»

«Development Economics Spring 2014 Economics 2390c (also HKS PED 319) Monday and Wednesday 1:00-2:30pm Class Location: Harvard Hall 103 Version: January 23, 2014 Nathan Nunn M-25, Littauer, Harvard nnunn@fas.harvard.edu Office Hours: By appointment (please email Prof. Nunn) Michael Kremer M-20, Littauer, Harvard mkremer@fas.harvard.edu Office Hours: By appointment (please email Jeanne Winner: jwinner@fas.harvard.edu) Shawn Cole 271 Baker Library, HBS scole@hbs.edu Office Hours: By appointment...»

«WWW.ALSTON.COM Financial Services & Products ADVISORY n JUNE 8, 2016 CFPB Seeks to Expand Its Dominion Over Consumer Lending with Strict Proposed Rules On June 2, 2016, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) released a long-anticipated proposal pursuant to its authority under the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act to regulate the provision and collection of certain short-term, small-dollar credit products, including payday and vehicle title loans, as well as...»

«A Public Company as a Challenger to a Private Monopoly: Providing Water to the Eternal City, 1865-1964 Denis Bocquet To cite this version: Denis Bocquet. A Public Company as a Challenger to a Private Monopoly: Providing Water to the Eternal City, 1865-1964. Business and Economic History On-Line, Business History Conference, 2004, 2, pp.1-13. halshs-00138752 HAL Id: halshs-00138752 https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00138752 Submitted on 27 Mar 2007 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open...»

«Taxes and Corporate Finance: A Review John R. Graham Duke University July 3, 2001 Abstract: This paper reviews tax research related to domestic and multinational corporate financing decisions, leasing, pensions, debt maturity, start-ups, small firms, risk management, personal taxes, dividend policy, organizational form, compensation policy, and tax shelters. Updated information is provided about simulated corporate marginal tax rates, the relation between corporate tax rates and debt ratios,...»

«Public Document Pack Committee Agenda City of Westminster Title: Housing, Finance and Corporate Services Policy and Scrutiny Committee Meeting Date: Wednesday 16th September, 2015 Time: 7.00 pm Venue: Rooms 5, 6 & 7 17th Floor, City Hall Members: Councillors: Brian Connell (Chairman) Adnan Mohammed Antonia Cox Gotz Mohindra Peter Freeman Adam Hug Richard Holloway Vincenzo Rampulla Members of the public are welcome to attend the meeting and listen to the discussion Part 1 of the Agenda Admission...»

«Modern Medicine: The 150 best financial advisers for doctors Page 1 of 27 November 7, 2008 The 150 best financial advisers for doctors By Leslie Kane, MACC The financial turmoil that has gripped the world since mid-September has put Wall Street on a rollercoaster ride of record-high gains and record-low plunges. If there was ever a time when doctors needed financial advice, that time is now. To help you get control of your financial picture, Medical Economics offers the 150 Best Financial...»

«Session X INSPECTION OF EMBANKMENT DAMS Chris J. Veesaert, P.E. Bureau of Reclamation INTRODUCTION Understanding how embankment dams are designed and constructed enables a dam inspector to be especially alert for certain deficiencies or to concentrate on certain features of the dam during examinations. Some types of embankment dams are more susceptible than others to certain kinds of deficiencies. Therefore, a brief discussion of embankment dam design and construction characteristics precedes...»

«OECD SECRETARY-GENERAL REPORT TO G20 FINANCE MINISTERS Ankara, Turkey September 2015 OECD SECRETARY-GENERAL REPORT TO THE G20 FINANCE MINISTERS AND CENTRAL BANK GOVERNORS ANKARA, TURKEY SEPTEMBER 2015 This document and any map included herein are without prejudice to the status of or sovereignty over any territory, to the delimitation of international frontiers and boundaries and to the name of any territory, city or area. The statistical data for Israel are supplied by and under the...»

«PICKING WINNERS AND AVOIDING MUG PUNTERS: QUALITY AND SELECTION IN AUSTRALIA’S UNIVERSITIES ADDRESS BY GREG CRAVEN TO THE NATIONAL PRESS CLUB Mug punters and the bad news of education It has been unkindly suggested that I begin this speech by noting that it is the first time that a Vice-Chancellor has addressed a room in Canberra without asking for money. However, this would not be accurate. As Vice-Chancellor of a Catholic University, there will be a collection after questions. As this is a...»

«Water for a Thirsty Urban World ASIT K. BISWAS The great city is that which has the greatest men or women, If it be a few ragged huts it is still the greatest city in the world. – Walt Whitman, Song of the Broad-Axe WATER HAS STEADILY CLIMBED the global political agenda during the first decade of the twenty-first century. During the 1980s and 1990s, water was not an important resource issue in international environmental and humanitarian dialogue. Issues like climate change and biodiversity...»

«Afghanistan Public Financial Management Performance Assessment Executive Summary May 2008 Acknowledgements This is the second PFM Performance Assessment, based on the information as of December 2007, two and half years after the first assessment as of June 2005. This second assessment aims to measure reform progress during this period and to identify outstanding issues. Comparison between the first and second assessment shows significant improvements within the area of PFM. The process of...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.