FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:   || 2 |

«CROSS CULTURAL THEORY AND MODELS This attachment contains a variety of internet based texts, regarding cross cultural management with an emphasis on ...»

-- [ Page 1 ] --


This attachment contains a variety of internet based texts, regarding cross cultural management with

an emphasis on the theories and models of Geert Hofstede and Fons Trompenaars.

Please read the texts.

The Effects of National Cultures on Organizational Behavior

Intimidated by the Arab businessman standing so close, the US businessman takes a step

back. The Arab comes even closer.

After waiting half an hour, the German account executive becomes very annoyed and makes a call to the office of the Mexican manager who had agreed to meet her at 12:30 for lunch.

After outlining the parameters of the project, the Canadian project leader asks the members of his Indian project team for their recommendations as to how they should proceed. The team members are bewildered.

With the increasing globalization of business, differences among the cultures of various nations can complicate interactions among business people from different nations. National culture can be viewed as the norms, values and beliefs shared by individuals from a particular nation that distinguish it from other nations. Our cultural environment causes us to act in ways that we believe are appropriate but that people from other cultures may not be comfortable with or may not understand.

As the illustrations above demonstrate, when individuals from different cultures interact, the behaviours that are consistent with the norms of one culture may violate the norms of another. In the first example, the Arab businessman is most comfortable having a conversation standing very close to the other man--much closer than the typical distance between two people conversing in the US. In the second example, the time that the German account executive expects the Mexican manager to arrive at their 12:30 lunch appointment is 12:30. When the Mexican manager agreed on 12:30, he didn't know that she would be annoyed by him not arriving or calling before 1:00. In the third example, the Canadian project leader intends to show his respect and confidence in his team by asking for their input. The Indian team members wonder why he's unwilling or unable to lead the team himself.

An appreciation of cultural diversity helps managers function in the increasingly global business environment. Cultures affect the way people act and what they expect from others. In the future, getting work done with and through other people will require an understanding of differences among national cultures.

A Caveat Regarding Stereotyping When we talk about differences between cultures, we are speaking in generalities, and we must remember not to expect every individual to behave in a manner consistent with those generalizations in every situation. Although there's value in making predictions about human behaviour based on the patterns we see in different cultures, there's also the risk of doing great harm by stereotyping. If we assume that all individuals in a certain group have exactly the same characteristics, then we are stereotyping. Of course, individuals within a country differ from each other to a certain extent, and nations have subcultures too. In addition, people often adapt their behaviours to suit their situations.

Predicting individuals' attitudes and behaviours based on their nationality is imprecise, and it's better to learn each individual's beliefs and preferences when possible because they can differ from the national norm. The information below about national cultures are generalizations rather than hardand-fast rules that apply to every individual at all times. With that caveat in mind, let's look at models of culture and their implications for organizational behaviour.

Hofstede's Model

The best-known model of national cultures as they relate to behaviours in a business context was developed by Geert Hofstede. Hofstede found that cultures differed on the dimensions of individualism versus collectivism, power distance, uncertainty avoidance, and achievement versus quality of life orientations1.

Individualism versus collectivism. In cultures that are highly individualistic, people are expected to be self-reliant and independent, and to focus primarily on caring for themselves and their immediate families. In cultures that are highly collectivist, people are expected to serve the groups to which they belong (e.g., extended families, businesses or churches). Employees from collectivist cultures tend to have more favourable attitudes toward teamwork, and they prefer reward systems that provide incentives for group achievement. They prefer group recognition to personal recognition for accomplishments, and may even see recognition that singles them out as a disincentive for accomplishments. Employees from individualistic cultures tend to have more trouble committing to teamwork as highly as they commit to their personal goals. Employees from individualistic cultures tend to prefer individual-based performance appraisals and incentive systems.

The US, Czechoslovakia, Australia, and countries of the former Soviet Union are examples of highly individualist cultures. Most Asian cultures are highly collectivist.

Power distance. Power distance is the degree to which people accept large differences between the most and least powerful members of society in terms of privileges, wealth and well-being. Countries high in power distance are more accepting of disparities in wealth and authority between high and low status members of a group or organization. In high power distance cultures, it is expected that leaders will use the privileges inherent in their position to give orders, and therefore the use of a participative leadership style may be viewed as a sign of incompetence or irresponsibility. In high power distance cultures, subordinates would tend not to be comfortable with a management-by-objectives (MBO) system or other forms of participative goal setting. Countries low in power distance expect all members of society to have comparable wealth and authority. They have more egalitarian values.

Subordinates in low power distance cultures tend to appreciate being asked for their input in decision making, and they often expect to be consulted about decisions that affect them.

France and India are examples of countries that are high in power distance. The Netherlands is an example of a country that is low in power distance. The US is closer to the average than either extreme, but slightly lower than average.

Uncertainty avoidance. Watch for the "double negative" on this one. Countries that are low in uncertainty avoidance are relatively comfortable with events and people that are unpredictable. They are relatively comfortable with risk taking and nonconformist behaviour, which in turn help promote creativity, innovation and entrepreneurship. Countries that are high in uncertainty avoidance are less comfortable with events and people that are unpredictable. They are less comfortable with risk taking and nonconformist behavior. They develop elaborate formal and informal systems to control their environments and have strict behavioral norms.

Japan is an example of a country that is high in uncertainty avoidance. India and the US are examples of countries that are low in uncertainty avoidance.

Achievement versus quality of life. Cultures that are high on the achievement end of this dimension value competition, assertiveness and materialism. Whether competing as individuals or as members of a group (i.e., individualistic versus collectivist), achievement-oriented cultures value winning and the rewards that accompany success. Cultures that are high on the quality of life end of this dimension value other's well-being, positive relationships among people and the quality of their work life more than they value achievement and wealth. Employees from countries at opposite ends of this continuum respond differently to various types of rewards such as bonuses, promotions, a sense of meaningfulness in one's work and relief from stress.

Japan and the US are examples of countries high on the achievement end of the continuum, and the Netherlands is an example of a country high on the quality of life end.

Trompenaars's Model

While similar to Hofstede's findings in many ways, the dimensions of culture identified by Fons Trompenaars provide additional insights into cultural differences. Trompenaars found that cultures also differed on universalism versus particularism, neutral versus affective, and achievement versus ascription dimensions.

Universalism versus particularism. Universalism is the degree to which people believe that various ideas and practices can be effective in all circumstances. People who are high in universalism believe they can develop rules and standards that can be reasonably applied to everyone in every situation.

They tend to use contracts, formal systems, and procedures to convey what they expect from others.

People who are low in universalism (i.e., high in particularism) develop their expectations of others based on their personal relationships with them and their trust in them rather than on rules. When negotiating deals, people from highly particularistic cultures will want to develop a relationship with the other party before having substantive discussions toward making an agreement. People from highly universalistic cultures are prepared to proceed with substantive discussions much more quickly, but then expect to document their agreement with an enforceable contract.

The US, Australia, Germany and Switzerland are examples of countries high in universalism.

Venezuela, the former Soviet Union's countries, Indonesia and China are examples of nations high in particularism.

Affective versus neutral. In highly affective cultures, people tend to openly express their feelings. In highly neutral cultures, emotions are not expressed as openly and naturally. People from highly affective cultures are more likely to smile, talk loudly when excited, and greet each other enthusiastically. People from highly neutral cultures experience the same emotions, but are less inclined to express them, and they express them more subtly. Implications for behavior in the workplace include how demonstrative people are when showing appreciation and affection for each other and when celebrating successes.

Mexico, the Netherlands, Switzerland and China are examples of highly affective cultures. Japan, Britain and Singapore are examples of highly neutral cultures. (Is "highly neutral" an oxymoron?) The US is average.

Achievement versus ascription. In highly achievement-oriented cultures, social status is largely derived from a person's achievements. In highly ascription-oriented cultures, social status is largely derived from personal attributes such as age, experience, social connections, or gender. In organizations, a person's status is reflected in his or her privileges such as access to resources and perks, deferential treatment, and input in decision making.

Australia, the US, Switzerland and Britain are examples of highly achievement-oriented cultures.

Venezuela, Indonesia and China are examples of highly ascription-oriented cultures.

Other Dimensions of Culture

Other dimensions on which cultures differ include high and low context, interpersonal space, monochronic versus polychronic time, and orientations toward the past, present and future.

High context versus low context. The high- versus low-context dimension of culture relates to norms of communication. In low-context countries, communication relies more heavily on the literal meaning of the words used. Meanings of written and spoken communication are more explicit. To people from high-context cultures, the bluntness and directness of low-context communication styles can seem insulting or aggressive. In high-context cultures, much more of the context surrounding the written or spoken communication is involved in conveying the message. Factors such as the social status of the communicators and the nature of the relationship between them are key. The meaning of everything said in high-context communication has to be interpreted in the context of the social relationship between the individuals.

Interpersonal space is also related to the high-context versus low-context dimension of national cultures. In low-context cultures, people tend to be uncomfortable standing closer than three feet from each other when conversing. In high-context cultures, people tend to stand relatively close when conversing. They perceive a distance of three feet between communicators as something that interferes with their communication, and they will tend to step closer in order to be more comfortable. A range of one foot is the norm in Latin America and Asia. Arabs prefer to be even closer.

Germany, Switzerland and the US are examples of low-context countries. China, Korea, Japan and most Latin American countries are examples of high-context countries.

Monochronic versus polychronic time. In cultures where a monochronic view of time is prevalent, people tend to do only one activity at a time, keep a strict schedule of their appointments, and show a strong resistance to deviating from plans. In cultures where a polychronic view of time is the norm, people tend to do more than one activity at a time, appointments are approximate and may be changed at any time, and schedules are not as important as relationships.

Inflexible adherence to schedules and plans is only as beneficial as the quality of those schedules and plans. In the turbulent environments that many managers are now working in, such inflexibility can be a liability because unforeseeable events often necessitate changing plans. Similarly, the habit of working on multiple tasks at once may also help in coping with rapid change.

North Americans and Northern Europeans tend to have a monochronic view of time. Mediterranean, Latin American, and Arab cultures tend to have a polychronic view.

Past, present and future orientations. Cultures differ in the emphasis that they place on the past, present, and future. North American countries tend to focus more on the present and the immediate future than other countries do. Most European countries have a more balanced focus on past, present and future. Many Asian countries focus heavily on what North Americans would consider the distant future.

The implications of differing emphases on past, present and future may be most apparent in planning.

Pages:   || 2 |

Similar works:

«Man In India, 94 (3) : 427-438 © Serials Publications THE OIL EMBARGO, THE APARTHEID STATE AND PIRACY ON THE HIGH SEAS Ashwin Desai In the 1970s, a partial oil embargo was imposed upon South Africa. This had a potentially crippling effect. The state responded by scouring the world for oil supplies, using shadowy networks that opened them to fraudsters ready to make quick cash. At the same time the apartheid state created local conditions off the Durban coast for the speedy off-loading and...»

«Working Papers on The Nature of Evidence: How Well Do ‘Facts’ Travel? No. 28/08 A Journey Through Times and Cultures? Ancient Greek Forms in American Nineteenth-Century Architecture: An Archaeological View Lambert Schneider © Lambert Schneider Archäologisches Institutan Universität Hamburg April 2008 “The Nature of Evidence: How Well Do ‘Facts’ Travel?” is funded by The Leverhulme Trust and the ESRC at the Department of Economic History, London School of Economics. For further...»

«International Review of Business Research Papers Vol. 5 No. 3 April 2009 Pp. 189-201 The Impact of Interest Rate Changes on Islamic Bank Financing Radiah Abdul Kader* and Yap Kok Leong** This study investigates the impact of interest rate changes on the demand for Islamic financing in a dual banking system. Theoretically, any change in the interest rate would lead customers who are guided by the profit motive to substitute Islamic financing for conventional bank loans and vice versa. Using...»

«Our Star September, 2001 Oestreich Associates Redmond, Washington 1 2001 Oestreich Associates September 25, 2001 Dear friends and colleagues The tragedies of September 11th raise enormous questions for all of us. These are questions on a grand scale – what our country should do to respond to the attacks, why our country was attacked in this horrible way, how we repair the emotional and economic damage. We will all be involved with these questions and ambiguities for a long time, and we are...»

«Federal Reserve Bank of New York Staff Reports Financial Stability Policies for Shadow Banking Tobias Adrian Staff Report No. 664 February 2014 This paper presents preliminary findings and is being distributed to economists and other interested readers solely to stimulate discussion and elicit comments. The views expressed in this paper are those of the author and are not necessarily reflective of views at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York or the Federal Reserve System. Any errors or...»

«Case 1:12-cv-00431-TCW Document 172 Filed 09/01/16 Page 1 of 20 IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF FEDERAL CLAIMS GRACE M. GOODEAGLE, et al., ) ) Plaintiffs, ) No. 12-431L ) v. ) Hon. Thomas C. Wheeler ) UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, ) ) Defendant. ) ) UNITED STATES’ REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT Case 1:12-cv-00431-TCW Document 172 Filed 09/01/16 Page 2 of 20 TABLE OF CONTENTS I.  INTRODUCTION II.  ARGUMENT A.  The doctrines of claim preclusion and issue preclusion bar...»

«PhD Thesis: ‘Money, Financial Capability and Well-being in Indigenous Australia’ Money, Financial Capability and Well-being in Indigenous Australia Vinita Godinho MBA, BSc (Economics Honours) Graduate School of Business & Law College of Business RMIT University October 2014 i PhD Thesis Vinita Godinho Graduate School of Business & Law PhD Thesis: ‘Money, Financial Capability and Well-being in Indigenous Australia’ “We are still negotiating and affirming the value of Indigenous people...»

«Minimum resting times and transaction-to-order ratios Review of Amendment 2.3.f and Question 20 Economic Impact Assessment EIA2 Foresight, Government Office for Science Minimum resting times and transaction-to-order ratios Contents 1. Objective 2. Background: review of relevant research 3. Risk assessment: the potential risks from no intervention to contain market speed 4. Policy options 5. Costs and benefits of each option 6....»

«ZOLTÁN SZABÓ Evaluation of environmental impacts of crop production, with particular focus on biodiversity External impacts of an intensive farm and an ecological farm Department of Environmental Economics and Technology Supervisor: Zsuzsanna Marjainé Szerényi department chair © Zoltán Szabó ii CORVINUS UNIVERSITY OF BUDAPEST Doctoral school of management and business administration Evaluation of environmental impacts of crop production, with particular focus on biodiversity External...»

«A NEW INTERNATIONAL ECONOMIC ORDER. CHALLENGES FOR FUTURE THEORETICAL AND PRACTICAL DEBATES Authors: Valeriu IOAN-FRANC1, Napoleon POP1 A bstract: Globalisation requires a transition based on an agenda of national priorities consistent at a world level, and the new international order should take over projects related to the planet. Since the lessons of history are always forgotten, no matter how much they are being debated in times of tensions just like now, one should take from the past at...»

«Vol. No. 5922 campusnews@uaf.edu.pk Dated: 12-04-2016 ASSUMPTION OF CHARGE Prof Dr Riaz Ahmad Chairman Department of Agronomy, and Prof. Dr. Muhammad Sajjad Khan Director, Institute of Animal Sciences have assumed the charge to look after the duties as Dean, Faculty of Agriculture, and Faculty of Animal Husbandry respectively. Prof. Dr. Sajjad-ur-Rehman has assumed the charge as Director, Institute of Microbiology whereas Prof. Dr. Hafeez Ahmad Sadaqat took the reins as Chairman, Department of...»

«European Treaty Series No. 93 European Convention on the Legal Status of Migrant Workers Strasbourg, 24.XI.1977 The member States of the Council of Europe, signatory hereto, Considering that the aim of the Council of Europe is to achieve a greater unity between its members for the purpose of safeguarding and realising the ideals and principles which are their common heritage and facilitating their economic and social progress while respecting human rights and fundamental freedoms; Considering...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.