FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 13 | 14 || 16 | 17 |   ...   | 49 |

«JOURNAL OF LAW, ECONOMICS & POLICY VOLUME 10 SPRING 2014 NUMBER 2 EDITORIAL BOARD 2013-2014 Steve Dunn Editor-in-Chief Crystal Yi Meagan Dziura Sarah ...»

-- [ Page 15 ] --

The Recitals of Chula Vista Ordinance No. 3080 delineate in general terms the underlying concerns of the councilmembers. These concerns included: neighborhood decline, attractive public nuisance, lower property values, and reluctant purchasers, all of which were alleged to be the result of abandoned residences.124 At a city council meeting, city building officials and the Code Enforcement Manager emphasized defaults and foreclosures that led to bank-owned homes, a lack of maintenance, and a difficulty in identifying such homes.125 Such concerns led the director of planning and building to recommend to the city council that it adopt an “Abandoned Residential Property Registration Program as a means of ensuring that residential neighborhoods are spared the negative impacts associated with abandoned residential properties.”126 The “Discussion” portion of the recommendation points to events that occurred in Chula Vista that must have reinforced the focus on lenders and trustees, but does not provide supportive data. According to the Planning and Building Department, new homes constructed during 2001 to 2005 were purchased with “risky financing arrangements offered by lenders specializing in sub-prime loans.”127 In the effort to control the perceived future threat, the city council was convinced that lenders, not borrowers, should register and maintain the vulnerable properties, and voted on August 7, 2007, to enact Ordinance No. 3080, the CVAPO.128 Significantly, the CVAPO Recitals do not cite or reference, and it appears that the council did not review, adopt, or incorporate, economic or 124 CHULA VISTA, CAL., ORD. 3080 § 1 (2007).

125 See generally BD. OF APPEALS AND ADVISORS OF CHULA VISTA, CAL., MINUTES OF A REGULAR MEETING (June 11, 2007); see also note 140 (regarding the number of bank-owned homes during the years 2006 to 2008).

126 CITY OF CHULA VISTA, CITY COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT 15-1 (July 17, 2007) (emphasis added). The phrase suggests the negative impacts had not yet occurred.

127 Id. at 15-2. As discussed in Part II of this article, lenders created “risky financing arrangements” to satisfy the pressure to meet quotas of loans for low-income and minority borrowers imposed by the federal government, the Federal Reserve Bank, Fannie Mae, and community organizations.

MORGENSON & ROSNER, supra note 2, at 115–17; SOWELL, supra note 1, at 42–44; see also, Zywicki & Adamson, supra note 39, at 12, 25 (“But subprime lending has placed many people on the road to homeownership, and only a minority of subprime loans could be considered ‘predatory’.... But foreclosure and delinquency do not necessarily indicate the presence of unaffordable loans, predatory loans, rising interest rates, or borrowers under duress.”).

128 See CHULA VISTA, CAL., ORD. 3080 § 1 (2007). The CVAPO went into effect sixty days later and was amended in 2010.

–  –  –

crime data to support their concerns about blight. In addition, the Recitals, meeting minutes, and the city council agenda statement do not supply empirical data to support the findings and conclusions made by the city councilmembers. Without data, the councilmembers’ conclusions were based primarily on general observations.129 The testimony of city staff connected “risky financing arrangements” and foreclosures with the potential for blight in general terms, which is an insufficient basis for an ordinance that seeks to prevent blight.130 When faced with a high volume of foreclosures that might lead to blight, a city ordinance ought to adhere to the same standard as an ordinance that adopts a redevelopment plan to eradicate blight because it is imperative that local governing bodies not enact legislation based on speculation. This speculative regulation significantly impacts contractual obligations and private property interests, just as condemnation impacts the landowners of the area targeted for redevelopment. When local authorities act on speculation, a community is worse off because such decision making ultimately diminishes the importance of legitimate private agreements and private property interests. The scrutiny of such speculative regulation is justifiably heightened so that the local governing body must first make the factual finding. Reliance upon speculation turns the regulation into an illegitimate governmental function.

If blight conditions did exist, they were not as severe as that spoken of in the state statute.131 There may have been particular lots and parcels that were in decline, but the 2008 written testimony of Doug Leeper, Code Enforcement Manager for City of Chula Vista, before a Congressional Subcommittee estimated that about 2100 homes were vacant in May 2008132 in the second largest municipality in San Diego County with a current population of nearly 250,000133 and a population of 173,556 in 2000.134 Other than 129 See infra notes 132, 135–37. It is one thing if the City Council were to rely on a comprehensive study of the existence and consequences of “risky financing arrangements” that actually led to foreclosures and blight, but it is altogether different to rely solely upon observations made by city code enforcement officers who make their rounds but do not inquire into the details of the homeowners’ purchase financing.

130 Beach-Courchesne v. City of Diamond Bar, 80 Cal. App. 4th 388, 398–400 (2000); see also Zywicki & Adamson, supra note 39, at 12–35.

131 See supra notes 115–17 and accompanying text.

[T]rue blight is expressed by the kind of dire inner-city slum conditions described in the Bunker Hill case: unacceptable living conditions of 82 percent; unacceptable building conditions of 76 percent; crime rate of double the city’s average; arrest rate of eight times the city’s average; fire rate of nine times the city’s average; and the cost of city services more than seven times the cost of tax revenues.

Beach-Courchesne, 80 Cal. App. 4th at 407 n.11 (emphasis in original).

132 Testimony of D. Leeper, supra note 15, at 104.

133 See ABOUT THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA, CITY OF CHULA VISTA, http://www.chulavistaca.gov/About/ (last visited Sept. 14, 2013).


available at


2014] NATURE ABHORS A VACUUM AND SO DO LOCAL GOVERNMENTS 369 one specific instance,135 Mr. Leeper spoke about blight only in general terms136 and he acknowledged an improvement in the negative impacts.137 Newspaper accounts during the relevant time period do not indicate there being widespread decline or that blight actually existed.138 If blight did not exist in the municipality, it is an illegitimate use of police power to enact regulation that interferes with private property rights such as security lien interests. Under the appearance of preventing blight, the CVAPO forces private parties to undertake certain action contrary to private agreements in a way the parties would not otherwise consider.139 Such a regulation would prematurely alter property interests today in the hope that blight does not occur in the future. If preemptive regulation that seeks to prevent blight before it starts were permitted, then constitutional validity is reduced to any language that merely provides a tenuous relationship between the controlling mandate and any problem that could possibly occur. Local government would not need to carry the burden of compiling and presenting the empirical data to support new regulations. Such a standard expands police power at the expense of the landowner’s or lender’s legitimate private property rights. The nature of government officials is to expand their power and control in order to lower the standard, justifying even earlier and more premature governmental intervention in other private contractual relationships to achieve other desired goals. But history proves such goals usually conflict with private property rights.

The city would undoubtedly contend that its police power permits it to prevent blight before it is created. In other words, the CVAPO is justifiable because it either prohibits conduct that could lead to blight or mandates conduct to prevent blight. But such an argument assumes that blight necessarily follows from “risky financial arrangements” and foreclosures. Foreclosures did increase in the lead up to the passage of the CVAPO in 2007 and over the next year,140 but did blight actually occur? Property values did http://www.dof.ca.gov/research/demographic/state_census_data_center/productsservices/documents/table1.xls.

135 Testimony of D. Leeper, supra note 15, at 97.

136 Id. at 100, 102–03. Mr. Leeper did not cite any studies or statistics compiled by his department (other than those mentioned in his testimony and supra text accompanying note 132) or the local police department.

137 Id. at 105.

138 See Emmet Pierce, Blight-prevention law emerges as a national model; Chula Vista forces lenders to maintain foreclosures, SAN DIEGO UNION-TRIB. (Oct. 12, 2008), http://legacy.utsandiego.com/news/metro/20081012-9999-1n12blight.html (the article makes no reference to actual blight, but does refer to the ordinance as “blight-prevention”); see also Lori Weisberg, Homeowners associations countywide are hit by foreclosure fallout and feeling the pinch of... Unpaid dues, SAN DIEGO UNION-TRIB. (Nov. 1, 2007), http://www.utsandiego.com/uniontrib/20071101/news_1n1dues.html.

139 See infra discussion at notes 172–73.

140 RealtyTrac is an entity that compiles data regarding the number of notices of default, notices of trustee sale, and lenders’ “real estate owned” (REO) properties. REALTYTRAC, INC., FORECLOSURE

–  –  –

decrease,141 but were the physical and economic conditions “so prevalent and so substantial” that “a serious physical and economic burden on the community” was created?142 No, the city would likely respond, because the enactment and enforcement of the CVAPO prevented such consequences.

But this begs the question whether such preemptive measures by local government are permissible in the first place.143 Without the empirical data, we do not know if blight existed at the time the CVAPO was enacted.

“[F]indings of blight must be supported by substantial evidence in the administrative record,”144 otherwise the enactment is not a legitimate governmental function.145 In this instance, the record is inadequate.

Consequently, the CVAPO does not satisfy the requirement that it be based on a finding that statutory blight exists within the city. Thus, if the CVAPO were classified as one that concerns blight, it would be invalidated if challenged on this ground. Moreover, the rule of law is undermined because the local government has expanded its police power to control private contracts and interfere with property rights without the justification of findings based on substantial empirical data that blight actually exists.

3. The Validity of the CVAPO as a Public Nuisance Regulation

The CVAPO can be classified as a public nuisance regulation because of its emphasis on the eradication of nuisances that negatively impact the property and its value, as well as that of the surrounding neighborhood. As a charter city, Chula Vista has some latitude in promulgating regulations so long as the regulations reasonably relate to a legitimate objective that protects the public health, safety, morals, and welfare within its jurisdiction.146 In the context of nuisances, a court will determine whether the regulation is ACTIVITY REPORT FOR SAN DIEGO COUNTY 2005 (2ND QTR.)–2009 (1ST QTR.) (electronic spreadsheet compiled by RealtyTrac and licensed to author in August 2012) (on file with author). For 2006, its data states there were 1262 notices of default in the City of Chula Vista and of those, 33 (or 2.6%) became REO properties. Id. At the end of 2007—after the CVAPO was enacted in July 2007—there were 3,704 notices of default, of which 599 (or 16%) became REO properties. Id. In 2008, there were 4,381 notices of default and 2,598 (or 59.3%) became REO properties. Id.

141 SOWELL, supra note 1, at 58–60.

142 CAL. HEALTH & SAFETY CODE § 33030(b)(1) (West 2011).

143 Such an argument is analogous to the contention that government costs have been reduced because there are no more auto accidents after government regulation made private ownership of autos illegal and confiscated all autos. It is still necessary to ask if such a regulation is constitutional. The means by which government seeks to achieve its intended objective is not justified merely by the achievement itself.

144 Beach–Courchesne v. City of Diamond Bar, 80 Cal. App. 4th 388, 400 (2000).

145 E E. Bay Mun. Util. Dist. v. Richmond Redevelopment Agency, 93 Cal. App. 3d 346, 356 (1979).

146 Graham v. Kingwell, 218 Cal. 658, 659 (1933); Thain v. City of Palo Alto, 207 Cal. App. 2d

–  –  –

an appropriate expression of a local government’s police power as it asks “(1) whether the object of the ordinance is one for which the police power may be properly invoked and, if so, (2) whether the ordinance bears a reasonable and substantial relation to the object sought to be attained.”147 The courts recognize a presumption in favor of an ordinance’s validity “if any rational ground exists for its enactment.”148 However, an ordinance will be held invalid if it is “palpably unreasonable, arbitrary or capricious, having no tendency to promote the public welfare, safety, morals, or general welfare.”149 When the findings of a local legislative body are fairly debatable, courts will not attack the findings and the ordinance will be upheld.150 However, where “the physical facts show that there has been an unreasonable, oppressive, or unwarranted interference with property rights in the exercise of the police power,” the courts will set aside a legislative body’s decisions “as to matters of opinion and policy.”151

a. A Public Nuisance Hybrid Regulation

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 13 | 14 || 16 | 17 |   ...   | 49 |

Similar works:

«Liminalities: A Journal of Performance Studies Vol. 5, No. 5, November 2009 Moving Relations: On the Limits of Belonging Aimee Carrillo Rowe When the windshield became the only border between us, things became strange. And the girl with the hair became outrageous. I was trapped in the passenger seat, unable to move, the spotlight of her gaze fixed me into stillness. We’d come to this late night sweet shop to get a dessert. We were on our way back from a party to my friend Sheena’s house out...»

«13 MYANMAR’S COURTS AND THE SOUNDS MONEY MAKES Nick Cheesman In 2007, Deputy Township Judge U Sein Lwin lost his job and went to jail. His alleged crime was to have solicited bribes so that three women would not become co-accused in a case before him. A prosecutor charged the judge under the 1948 Prevention of Corruption Act, and a court in Taunggyi promptly sentenced him to seven years in prison. The Supreme Court dismissed him from office immediately (Supreme Court 2007a). If the facts of...»

«CHAPTER 33 THE BEST CONTROL FOR VERTEBRATES The July/August 1998 issue of Sierra Magazine noted: “On average, legislators who voted against protecting wildlife snared twice as much money as their pro-wildlife counterparts. And a high-profile legislator can easily beat the average: In the Senate the top recipients of anti-endangered species act contributors were Larry Craig (R-Idaho) $525,659, Kay Bailey Hutchinson (R-Texas) $462,104 and Phil Gramm (R-Texas) $444,000. In the House, the fattest...»

«Federal, State, and Local Governments: Evaluating their Separate Roles in US Growth ∗ Matthew J. Higgins College of Management, Georgia Institute of Technology Andrew T. Young** Department of Economics, University of Mississippi Daniel Levy Department of Economics, Bar-Ilan University, Department of Economics, Emory University, and Rimini Center for Economic Analysis Last Revision: October 2008 Abstract: We use US county level data (3,058 observations) from 1970 to 1998 to explore the...»

«Future Finance – Discussion Paper No. 1, 07/2015 The monetary system in crisis Monetary reform proposals, and a simple suggestion for a more effective monetary policy Dr. Matthias Kroll 1 Contents Introduction 3 1. Fundamental problems of current monetary policies 4 2. The money reformers’ proposals 6 2.1. The Chicago Plan and 100% Money 7 2.2. From 100% Money to Vollgeld 8 2.3. The Benes/Kumhof IMF Working Paper 9 2.4. Narrow Banking 10 2.5. The monetary reform proposal of Stephen Zarlenga...»

«Vijay Mehrotra Department of Finance and Quantitative Analytics School of Business and Professional Studies University of San Francisco 415-422-2257 / vmehrotra@usfca.edu EDUCATION Stanford University, Stanford, CA • PhD, Operations Research, 1992 Advisor: Professor Frederick S. Hillier Dissertation: “An Approximation Procedure for General Closed Multiclass Queueing Networks” • MS, Operations Research, 1989 Focus on Optimization, Stochastic Methods, Policy, and Applications Key Papers:...»

«ijcrb.webs.com DECEMBER 2011 INTERDISCIPLINARY JOURNAL OF CONTEMPORARY RESEARCH IN BUSINESS VOL 3, NO 8 How Do Workplace Spirituality and Organizational Citizenship Behavior influence Sales Performance of FMCG Sales Force?   Prof. Dr. Muhammad Ehsan Malik Dean, Faculty of Economics and Management Sciences/Director, Institute of Business Administration (IBA)/Director General, Gujranwala Campus, University of the Punjab, Lahore (Pakistan) Basharat Naeem Lecturer at IBA, University of the Punjab,...»

«The implications of Behavioral Finance Nathalie Abi Saleh Dargham –Chargée d’enseignement à FGM Abstract The debate in theoretical finance between the efficient market hypothesis and the field of the behavioral finance is of great interest. Since its emergence, the efficient market hypothesis has been the most important theory that explains the behavior of the various agents in the financial markets and neglects almost any potential impact of human behavior in the investment process....»

«ISSN (Print): 2279-0020 International Association of Scientific Innovation and Research (IASIR) ISSN (Online): 2279-0039 (An Association Unifying the Sciences, Engineering, and Applied Research) International Journal of Engineering, Business and Enterprise Applications (IJEBEA) www.iasir.net NYMBLE: Protecting the Privacy of Users in Anonymous Networks and Blacklisting Misbehaving Users R.Anto Arockia Rosaline Assistant Professor Department of Information Technology Rajalakshmi Engineering...»

«CLOUD COMPUTING IN BUSINESS PROCESSES. A CAR PARTS SUPPLYING COMPANY CASE Kinga Bednarzewska Maria Curie Skłodowska University, Poland kbednarzewska@o2.pl Zbigniew Pastuszak Maria Curie Skłodowska University, Poland z.pastuszak@umcs.pl Abstract: In order to survive in times of crisis and a volatile environment the contemporary organisations have to be quick on their feet i.e. capable of taking decisions swiftly. To this extent, new applications, based on Information Systems and Information...»

«FIRSTLY JUST A FEW ANDALUSIA DETOUR BITS Andalusia Detours Blog FIRSTLY JUST A FEW ANDALUSIA DETOUR BITS Posted on Nov 07, Posted by Ray Category Miscellaneous Firstly, a welcome to this our first Andalusia Detours News letter, quite separate from the regular Desert Detours News Letter. We plan to continue with our established format of offering just a short piece about ourselves whilst concentrating on what this wonderful region of Spain has to offer.   Being familiar with the region, passing...»

«Banknotes and Coins September 2016 1. Under what authority does the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP) issue currency? The BSP is the sole government institution mandated by law to issue notes and coins for circulation in the Philippines. In particular, Section 50 of Republic Act (R.A.) No. 7653, otherwise known as The New Central Bank Act, stipulates that the BSP shall have the sole power and authority to issue currency within the territory of the Philippines. It also issues legal tender...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.