FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 22 | 23 || 25 | 26 |   ...   | 47 |

«ABSTRACT Title of Dissertation: TYRANT! TIPU SULTAN AND THE RECONCEPTION OF BRITISH IMPERIAL IDENTITY, 1780-1800 Michael Soracoe, Doctor of ...»

-- [ Page 24 ] --

Calcutta Chronicle and General Advertiser (Calcutta, India) 30 April 1789, Issue 171 Minute of Mr. Farmer 27 May 1792 "Account Current of the Vettate Naddo Country" (p. 43-55) IOR/H/585 p. 46-47 Lieutenant Roderick Mackenzie. A Sketch of the War with Tippoo Sultaun Vol. 2 (Calcutta: Unknown printer, 1793; London: Imported and sold by J. Sewell, 1799): 203-04 These stories provided an implicit justification for the war against Tipu, to remove the tyrant from power, and also for the annexation of territory afterwards, with the Company providing a superior and enlightened mode of governance. They expanded the cruel treatment of the British prisoners from the previous war, and applied the same kind of horrific description to an entire people under Tipu’s rule. The Public Advertiser stated this explicitly in an article from 1791, writing how the amongst the high-caste Hindu Nairs of the Malabar Coast, “the most intelligent and best informed people think there can be no doubt of their continuing firm to their alliance [with Cornwallis] against the tyrant.”93 The Oriental Repertory took up the same argument, linking together persecution of the Nairs by Tipu with an extension of Company rule in India. The journal wrote that when Tipu took possession of the Malabar Coast, he ruled the area “with a Rod of Iron”, the inhabitants finding themselves so oppressed that they fled into the jungle; the most unwarrantable act of tyranny was “forcing the Nairs and Tiers to embrace the Mahometan Religion, which exasperated them beyond every thing.” However, since Company soldiers forced out Tipu and gained control of the region, “the Country has improved astonishingly, and, I make no doubt, in a few years, will turn out a most valuable acquisition to our Honourable Masters.”94 Roderick Mackenzie further linked together accusations of Tipu’s religious cruelty with the expansion of Company territory by writing in his history of the war how the Hindu rajahs were “the original, genuine and true princes of Hindostan,” which now looked to the British nation “for protection against the oppressive power of the Mysorean Prince.”95 These accounts representing Tipu as an Islamic fanatic were no accident, but a deliberate attempt to Public Advertiser (London, England) 31 December 1791, Issue 17937 Oriental Repertory (London, England) Vol. 2, (1793) p. 167 Lieutenant Roderick Mackenzie. A Sketch of the War with Tippoo Sultaun Vol. 1 (1793): 8-10 provide further justification for the ongoing war, and pave the way for annexation of Company territory afterwards.

Due to this portrayal of Tipu as a tyrannical Oriental despot, many British writers who sympathized with the East India Company argued that the people of Mysore would be eager to throw off Tipu’s barbaric rule. These accounts supported the belief that the Third Mysore War would be a war of liberation to overthrow an unpopular monarch, and presumably pave the way for a smooth Company takeover thereafter. The Calcutta Gazette surmised as far back as 1786 that “the people on the Malabar Coast feel more than ever the oppressive tyranny that mark their government, and groan under the yoke with impatience to throw it off; they will certainly embrace the first favourable opportunity to effect this purpose.”96 The Calcutta Chronicle confidently predicted in 1790 that the war would be speedily won for the same reason, as Tipu’s populace rose up against his rule: "It is well known that Tippoo is obeyed more through fear, than personal attachment, even by those near his person... many of his Mysorean subjects will shake off his yoke as soon as the British army approaches to his capital, and throw themselves on a power from whom they have every reason to expect lenity, protection, and justice."97 This was another variation on the war of liberation ideal, with the Company soldiers enthusiastically welcomed by the people of Mysore, and Tipu’s army disintegrating before them because he enforced his rule solely through fear. With the London newspapers carrying reports from India detailing how Tipu mutilated his subjects by cutting off their arms and legs, this did not appear to be an unreasonable conjecture.98 Calcutta Gazette or Oriental Advertiser (Calcutta, India) 8 June 1786, Issue 119 Calcutta Chronicle and General Advertiser (Calcutta, India) 16 December 1790, Issue 256 London Chronicle (London, England) 24 December 1789, Issue 5210 Another London newspaper editorialized in 1790 that it hoped Cornwallis "will not enter into any treaty or compromise with Tippoo Saib. The total extermination of this barbarous Usurper of the Throne of Mysore can alone secure permanent peace to the Carnatic." Afterwards, it continued, the restoration of the pre-Haider ruling family of Mysore would ensure the goodwill of the "oppressed and deluded people" towards the British.99 This was one of the first appearances of Cornwallis' liberation rhetoric in metropolitan newspapers, used as a justification for the Company's decision to enter another Indian war.

The theme of Tipu as an usurper had rarely been used during the previous conflict, but it appeared more and more often during the Third Mysore War. These motifs of usurpation and restoration managed to turn the removal of Tipu into a defensive act carried out purely for the benefit of the native people. Kate Brittlebank has argued that British expansion in India was frequently justified by portraying Indian rulers as illegitimate and tyrannical usurpers of earlier dynasties. This characterization reached its apogee under Tipu Sultan.100 The use of such language allowed the Company and its defenders to cast the extension of British rule as a benevolent act of protection, rather than a naked power grab. These representation of Tipu's rule had been noticeably lacking a decade earlier during the Second Mysore War, when the Company had been hard pressed merely to defend its own territory instead of making territorial annexations.

Previous criticisms of the Sultan had focused on his treatment of British prisoners, and not been concerned with the governance of the natives of Mysore. The expanded focus of British public discourse on the territory of Mysore and its people indicated the greater English Chronicle or Universal Evening Post (London, England) 23 September 1790, Issue 1808 Kate Brittlebank. Tipu Sultan's Search for Legitimacy: Islam and Kingship in a Hindu Domain (New York: Oxford University Press, 1997): 5-6 optimism regarding empire overseas, and Company's growing territorial ambitions in southern India.

When Company forces entered into Tipu's domains during the military campaigns, the soldiers found no rebellious sentiment directed against the Sultan by the populace.

Instead, the Company servants were surprised to find a high degree of loyalty exhibited towards Tipu, and no small measure of resistance directed against the invading armies.

The Morning Chronicle printed a letter from India dated 12 July 1791, which was shocked to find “This Tyrant (as he was supposed) Tippoo Sultan, to our amazement is beloved by all his subjects; our army has learned, to their astonishment, that he had kept up the best government in his countries the people ever experienced; the inhabitants were free, protected, and affluent, speaking of him as their father – they wished not for a change; and not a real inhabitant would quit or desert him. These are undeniable facts, and not a trace of the smallest oppression seemed to exist.”101 The author went on to state that none of Tipu’s military officers had deserted his cause, and only a small handful of the rank and file had fled.

Roderick Mackenzie confirmed the same sentiments in his history, noting in passing “Whither the cruel treatment of inferiors attributed to the Sultaun, be real, or exaggerated, or altogether imaginary, it is certain that his subjects in this quarter yielded to a change of Government with a degree of reluctance, seldom exhibited by the inhabitants of Eastern countries.”102 Mackenzie would go on to write that “however bigoted the tenets of the Koran,” there were a vast number of decorated Hindu temples throughout Mysore which had not been plundered or torn down, and that the people Morning Chronicle (London, England) 6 December 1791, Issue 7018 Lieutenant Roderick Mackenzie. A Sketch of the War with Tippoo Sultaun Vol. 1 (1793): 79 willingly laid waste their own domains and fled away rather than support the Company forces.103 These unexpected accounts were particularly important, as one of the fundamental rationales for the war in India was the belief that Tipu oppressed his subjects, providing the justification for Tipu’s removal by the morally superior Company. If Tipu happened to be a just ruler, or merely an ordinary one without the monstrous vices that had been charged, then much of the Company’s rhetoric justifying the conflict stood on shaky ground. Firsthand accounts suggested that Tipu was not a horrific ruler to his people, and that the overwhelming majority of the populace had no desire to be "liberated" by Cornwallis.

After the Third Mysore War was over, the Company's annexation of territory was justified on the grounds that the British would provide superior administration and more humane rule compared to that of Tipu Sultan. The Public Advertiser was highly enthusiastic in explaining the benefits of the 1792 treaty, claiming that so much was never acquired by any peace in the history of British India. Not only was Tipu thoroughly humbled, so much that "it will be impossible for him ever to take the field again with any prospect of success," the Company would gain so much revenue from the new territory (and the savings on being able to reduce its own forces), that "the profits of the peace are equal to six times the expences of the war." This promised great benefits for the new subjects newly introduced to British rule: "The natives who have experienced the blessings of the British Government, prefer it to every old system of their own, and pay their taxes with promptness, in return for the benefits of protection against their ancient tyrants."104 This was another deployment of Cornwallis' rhetoric interpreting the Third Ibid, 72-73 Public Advertiser (London, England) 10 July 1792, Issue 18100 Mysore War as one fought for the liberation of the people of Tipu's kingdom. Much like the coverage of the hostage princes, opinion pieces that supported the Company's peace contended that Indians in the annexed territories would prefer British rule to that of the tyrant Tipu. Victory over the Sultan was argued as means to spread the virtues of British administration; this was a much more attractive justification for expansion than the previous self-aggrandizing exploits of the past.

Similar lines of argumentation appeared after the conclusion of the Fourth Mysore War in 1799. Although there were few mentions of Tipu's supposed religious fanaticism, attention having shifted instead to his connections with France, the British popular press returned to the liberation rhetoric of the Third Mysore War as a justification for the invasion of Tipu's kingdom. Lloyd's Evening Post wrote that the future of the conquered territories was quickly settled in a manner "at the same time honourable to our political character, and advantageous to our interests", with the Company receiving ample compensation for the expenses incurred "in the War into which it was so unjustly forced to enter."105 The restoration of the pre-Haider Wodeyar dynasty to power, through the placing of a child rajah on the throne of Mysore, was seen as a particularly shrewd move in Britain, forcing the puppet ruler into a state of complete dependence on the Company while avoiding the appearance of territorial aggrandizement through outright annexation.

It also allowed much of the literature written on the war to portray Tipu Sultan as an unlawful "usurper", with Wellesley restoring the proper pre-Haider Hindu dynasty to the throne.106 Lloyd’s Evening Post (London, England) 9 December 1799, Issue 6598 See for example: Officer in the East India Service. Authentic Memoirs of Tippoo Sultan (1799): 1-3 The General Evening Post wrote enthusiastically on how Wellesley's peace settlement demonstrated the greatness of the British character, that it demonstrated "the honour, the liberality, the wisdom, and the humanity" of the nation. The treaty was carried into effect "with the utmost tranquility, to the entire satisfaction of the native inhabitants; and by it our possessions in that part of the globe are secured against every contingency."107 Much as Cornwallis had argued in the previous war, the conflict was interpreted as a war of liberation to free the people of Mysore from the tyrannous rule of Tipu. Seen from this perspective, the Fourth Mysore War became a morality play, in which the superior virtues of the British had defeated the vileness of an Asiatic despot, leading to the spread of the Company's beneficent and paternalistic rule across southern India. It was an attractive vision of the future which anticipated the nineteenth century British Raj.

James Salmond wrote one of the earliest histories of the Fourth Mysore War, published shortly after its conclusion in 1800. He wrote to contemporaries that the Fourth Mysore War was just and necessary, if ever there was a just and necessary war.108 The restoration of the child rajah to rule in the aftermath of Tipu's defeat was spun as a family "rescued by our arms from the fury of relentless bigotry, insult, danger, and poverty", with the Company reserving the right to interfere in the administration of Mysore at any time, in order to preserve "the happiness of the people for whom we were now to legislate."109 The invasion was therefore justified by Salmond on the grounds of protecting the people of Mysore from Tipu, which had been a common line of General Evening Post (London, England) 12 December 1799, Issue 10485 James Salmond. A Review of the Origin, Progress, and Result of the Decisive War with the Late Tippoo Sultaun, in Mysore (London: Printed by Luke Hansard, 1800): 27 Ibid, 29 argumentation in the previous war under Cornwallis, but was rarely employed by Richard Wellesley. It was an after-the-fact justification for going to war, and not something that the Company's Indian servants and administrators considered at the time. Nevertheless, it too was incorporated into the larger fabric of the Tipu Legend, and would become part of the later historical memory for how and why the Mysore Wars had taken place. This was another way in which the wars against Tipu helped to form the basis of an imperial culture in the British metropole, providing an understanding and justification of empire that could exist in concert with British liberty.

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 22 | 23 || 25 | 26 |   ...   | 47 |

Similar works:

«CRISIS, SHELL-SHOCK, AND THE TEMPORALITY OF TRAUMA: CULTURAL MEMORY AND THE GREAT WAR COMBATANT EXPERIENCE IN OWEN, GRAVES, AND BARKER by DYLAN KELLY A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Honors in the Major Program in English in the College of Arts and Humanities and in The Burnett Honors College at the University of Central Florida Orlando, Florida Spring Term 2014 Thesis Chair: Dr. Anthony Grajeda, Ph.D ABSTRACT The year 2014 will mark the centennial of the...»

«NACIENTES AÑOS VIVIDOS Y SUEÑOS COMPARTIDOS HISTORIA del pueblo de CAÑADA DE LUQUE COMISIÓN MUNICIPAL DE CULTURA Municipalidad de Cañada de Luque PRESENTACIÓN Es una intima satisfacción y un honor escribir el prólogo de una obra anhelada: la historia de nuestro pueblo. No podíamos continuar la marcha sin conocer nuestros orígenes, esa historia que hace a nuestra identidad y que la construyeron con sus vivencias y experiencias nuestros antepasados. Este desafío nació en el marco del...»

«OFFICE OF THE PROVOST AND VICE CHANCELLOR FOR ACADEMIC AFFAIRS CAMPUS BUDGET ADVISORY TASK FORCE (CBATF) FINAL REPORT 24 June 2016 TABLE OF CONTENTS Report of the Campus Budget Advisory Task Force (CBATF) I. Committee Charge II. Committee Membership III. Introduction/Executive Summary IV. Brief Survey of the Current Budget V. Recent History of Budgeting at Illinois VI. Current Budget Model and Practices VII. Some Problems with the Current Budget Model VIII. Survey of Existing Budget Models IX....»

«Sophia Centre for the Study of Cosmology in Culture, University of Wales Trinity  1  Saint David  School of Archaeology, History and Anthropology Faculty of Humanities Sophia Centre for the Study of Cosmology in Culture MA in Cultural Astronomy and Astrology Distance-Learning, On-Line http://www.uwtsd.ac.uk/ma-cultural-astronomy-astrology/ http://www.uwtsd.ac.uk/sophia/ n.campion@uwtsd.ac.uk http://www.uwtsd.ac.uk/staff/nicholas-campion/ http://www.sophia-project.net/...»

«Report to the Computer History Museum on the Information Technology Corporate Histories Project PC Systems, Tools and Utilities Software Sector  Ashton-Tate Company Details Name: Ashton-Tate PC Systems, Tools and Utilities Software Sector: Description One of the early highly successful PC Software companies, Ashton-Tate became famous for a relational data base known as dBASE and an integrated application that did text, spreadsheet and data base known at Framework. They expanded the...»


«Sapieżyńska 10a 00-215 Warszawa tel. |48 22| 5360200 fax |48 22| 5360220 batory@batory.org.pl www.batory.org.pl Poles and Ukrainians, Poland and Ukraine The Paradoxes of Neighbourly Relations Joanna Konieczna Institute of Sociology, Warsaw University Warsaw 2003 Poles and Ukrainians, Poland and Ukraine. The Paradoxes of Neighbourly Relations In searching for a context within which the present image of Ukraine and of Ukrainians in the eyes of Poles may be considered, recourse must be had to...»

«NASA/CR-2001-208928 Eyes on the Red Planet: Human Mars Mission Planning, 1952-1970 Annie Platoff Lyndon B. Johnson Space Center Houston, Texas 77058-3696 July 2001 ©1999 The NASA STI Program Office. in Profile Since its founding, NASA has been dedicated to * CONFERENCE PUBLICATION. the advancement of aeronautics and space Collected papers from scientific and technical science. The NASA Scientific and Technical conferences, symposia, seminars, or other Information (STI) Program Office plays a...»

«Meta-effectiveness Excerpts from Cognitive Productivity: Using Knowledge to Become Profoundly Effective Luc P. Beaudoin, Ph.D. (Cognitive Science) Adjunct Professor of Education Adjunct Professor of Cognitive Science Simon Fraser University EDB 7505, 8888 University Drive Burnaby, BC V5A 1S6 Canada LPB@sfu.ca Skype: LPB2ha http://sfu.ca/~lpb/ Last Revised: 2015–05–31 (See revision history) I recently wrote a blog post containing some importants concepts for understanding adult development...»

«1 CORVUS The Journal of the Carleton University Classics Society Published by the Carleton University Classics Society President: Matthew Robertson Coordinator: Fawn Leslie Treasurer: Andrew Beatson Volume IV 2013-2014 TABLE OF CONTENTS Editors Contributors Message From The President ARTICLES To Pierce or Transfix: The Story of the Bone, the Περόνη and the Fibula. Direct and Indirect Bias in Tacitus’ Histories A Legacy of Greatness: The Portrayal of Alexander in Abrahamic Traditions The...»

«BIOSKETCH Dr. Manish Manoria Employment History Tenure Position Held _ Jul. 2010 to Present Director & Professor in Computer Science & Engineering, TRUBA Institute of Engineering & Information Technology, Karond Gandhinagar Bypass Road, Bhopal – 462038, Madhya Pradesh, India. Dec. 2006 to Jun. 2010 Professor & Head, Computer Science & Engineering, TRUBA Institute of Engineering & Information Technology, Karond Gandhinagar Bypass Road, Bhopal 462038, Madhya Pradesh, India. Mar. 2002 to Dec....»

«Panos Voulgaris Machiavelli: The Enduring Enigma Niccolò Machiavelli is one of the most controversial figures in political history. For nearly five hundred years historians and political scientists have examined countless documents and interpretations of Machiavelli; however, the debate over his true beliefs continues. His abstruseness has increased because of a drastic shift in the analysis of his works through the years. History has often bastardized Machiavelli but recent scholars have dug...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.