FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 28 | 29 || 31 | 32 |   ...   | 47 |

«ABSTRACT Title of Dissertation: TYRANT! TIPU SULTAN AND THE RECONCEPTION OF BRITISH IMPERIAL IDENTITY, 1780-1800 Michael Soracoe, Doctor of ...»

-- [ Page 30 ] --

105-06, 140-147 As far back as 1621, Thomas Mun had written A Discourse of Trade from England unto the East Indies to defend the Company from print culture attacks, insisting that the India trade enriched the nation rather than causing its poverty due to a drain of specie.35 In the late seventeenth century, East India Company Director Josiah Child frequently wrote pamphlets under the pseudonym of Philopatris to defend the Company and its trade, arguing that the India trade was more valuable to the English nation than any other trade, that the Company was deserving of its official monopoly status, and so on.36 As an influential Director who determined much of the Company’s policy in this period, Child’s engagement with print culture reinforced the notion that the Company’s leaders believed in the importance of creating a positive public image. These authors and others like them were successful in maintaining political support for the Company’s status quo, although skepticism about the accumulation of wealth and political influence amongst Company shareholders remained a longstanding criticism.

Old fears and anxieties associated with the Company received new life in the middle of the eighteenth century with the advent of the nabobs, and the widespread perception that the Company’s acquisition of territory was leading to tyrannical and despotic rule in India. Fears and pessimism about the future of Britain’s empire overseas were still commonplace during this period, prior to the military successes of the 1790s, and this pessimism was reflected in many of the writings from the period. The belief that the British Empire was on its last legs, and that the overseas colonial project was doomed to end in failure, was a widespread sentiment in the British metropole in the late Thomas Mun. A Discourse of Trade from England unto the East Indies (London: Printed by Nicholas Oakes, 1621)

See for example Josiah Child [Philopatris]. A Treatise Concerning the East India Trade. (London:

Printed by J.R. for the Honorable East India Company, 1681) eighteenth century. Robert Orme, the official historiographer of the East India Company, chose to conclude his meticulous account of the trading corporation's history with the events transpiring in 1762, despite possessing copious materials with which to extend the narrative further in time.37 Orme had serious misgivings about the level of corruption that existed in the Company’s rule over Bengal, and had witnessed firsthand the graft and self-aggrandizement of Company servants during his own visit to Madras. Orme predicted in 1767, “Parliament in less than two years will ring with declamation against the Plunderers of the East… It is these cursed presents which stop my History. Why should I be doomed to commemorate the ignominy of my countrymen… which has accompanied every event since the first of April 1757 [since Plassey].”38 Instead of continuing the history of the Company after its acquisition of the diwani for Bengal, Orme chose instead to write a history of the Mughal Empire in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, seeing no future in the current exploits of his countrymen.

Nor was Orme alone in his beliefs, as Alexander Dow and William Bolts, both disaffected Company servants, went on to write critical histories of the East India Company during the 1770s, singling out Robert Clive in particular for vilification.39 These historical accounts provide a sharp contrast to the celebratory accounts of the Company’s rise to power which would emerge in the early nineteenth century, penned by enthusiastic empire-builders such as John Malcolm and Mark Wilks.40 Orme and Dow Robert Orme. A History of Military Transactions of the British Nation in Indostan, from the Year 1745 (London: Printed for John Nourse, 1763, 1773, 1775, 1780, 1803) Robert Orme. Quoted in Nicholas Dirks. The Scandal of Empire: India and the Creation of Imperial Britain (2006): 247

Alexander Dow. The History of Hindostan: Translated from the Persian, 3rd Edition, Vol. 1 (London:

Printed by John Murray, 1792, 1770, 1768). See Chapter 3 for further discussion of Dow.

John Malcolm. Sketch of the Political History of India from the Introduction of Mr. Pitt's Bill, A.D. 1784, to the Present Date (London: W. Miller, 1811); Mark Wilks. Historical Sketches of the South of India, in an Attempt to Trace the History of Mysoor (London: Longman, Hurst, Rees, and Orme, 1810-1817) believed that the Company’s overseas empire was on the verge of disintegrating, not on the cusp of massive military and economic expansion. As referenced above, Samuel Foote's contemporary play The Nabob echoed the same ephemeral sentiments about the future, with the main character Mathew Mite told near the end of the play how "possessions arising from plunder very rarely are permanent; we every day see what has been treacherously and rapaciously gained, as profusely and full as rapidly squandered."41 This advice could have applied equally to the ill-gotten gains of the nabobs, or the stability of their overseas territorial conquests in India.

One of the best ways to demonstrate the skepticism of this period about the future of Britain’s overseas holdings comes in the form of an extraordinary cartoon from 1783 by W.P. Carey. The satirical engraving, entitled "So fickle is the mind of Royalty!", depicts Charles Fox, Lord North, and Edmund Burke falling from a pedestal on which King George III sits; in other words, a literal falling from favor [Figure 4].42 Its nominal purpose was a commentary on the party politics of the day, with Carey suggesting that Fox would likely return to power again soon. However, the cartoon also drew a striking contrast between the reign of George II (pre-1760) on the left side of the image, with the reign of George III on the right side. Underneath a dignified bust of the previous king, crowned with a laurel wreath to signify victory, the text on George II’s pedestal reads “The Father of his People. British Meridian A.D. 1760. Just & necessary wars with natural & perfidious enemies; crownd with victory & success… Great Britain look’d up to as the Arbitress of Europe; fear’d by all the world; Sovereign of the Sea and possessed

Samuel Foote. The Nabob (1773). Quoted in Philip Lawson and Jim Phillips. “‘Our Execrable Banditti’:

Perceptions of Nabobs in Mid-Eighteenth Century Britain” in Albion XVI (1984): 237-38 W. P. Carey. “To day disliked, and yet perhaps tomorrow again in favour. So fickle is the mind of R_y_l_ty!” [royalty] Published shortly after 18 December 1783. Image #6291 in Mary Dorothy George.

Catalogue of Political and Personal Satires (1978) of a greater extent of Territory than Rome in the zenith of her glory!!!”43 On the right side of the cartoon, George III cavalierly tips over the pedestal upon which Fox, North, and Burke had been standing, with a far less flattering inscription characterizing his


The Father of his – Children! British Sunset 1783… Stamp Act. Boston Port Bill.

American Remonstrance disregarded… Cornwallis taken. Drawn Battles at sea, in the East & West Indies, Europe & Am. Lose the Empire of the Sea… Hyder Ally defeats Col. Baily. Anarchy, Confusion & Destruction in East In[dies]. War concludes with an exhausted Treasury, distracted Councils, divided Senate decay’d Fleet, Enfeebled Army, discontented People & America not only for ever, ever lost to England, but thrown into the arms of our natural enemies!!! Oh!!!

Oh!!! unhappy ___!!!44 As if these obvious contrasts were not enough, Carey added a winged picture of Fame, who blows a trumpet with the word “Good” on it towards George II, and one proclaiming “disgrace!! How lost!!! How fallen!!” towards George III.

While Carey’s cartoon was of course satirical and not intended to be taken completely seriously, it nonetheless demonstrated how this was a period in which pessimism about the future of the British presence overseas was a very real phenomenon.

The contrast between the reigns of the two monarchs suggested that many Britons had lost an earlier sense of cultural confidence, and believed that their role in the world was in decline. Indeed, many eighteenth century intellectuals remained doubtful about their country’s achievements, and skeptical of the European political and social order in general; it was not until the developments of the early nineteenth century (industrialization, the ending of the slave trade, the extension of the franchise, etc.) that Carey, “So fickle is the mind of Royalty!” Carey, “So fickle is the mind of Royalty!” British thinkers would begin to feel confident that their political culture was superior to the rest of the world.45 When Carey produced this cartoon in 1783, there was no way to know that the future would bring unparalleled successes for the Company, resulting in his gloomy depiction of imperial decay and the belief (sounding strange in retrospect) that Britain’s empire had fallen past its “meridian” and had reached its “sunset”. The mention of Haider Ali and the disastrous defeat of Colonel Baillie in Carey’s cartoon anticipated the role that the Mysore Wars would later play in reshaping popular opinion of the East India Company’s role overseas. The figure of Tipu Sultan was enormously important in shifting British attitudes about their empire; it was increasingly argued during the last two decades of the 18th century that the true tyrants were Indian princes like Tipu, and not the servants of the East India Company. British victories in the Mysore Wars replaced the cultural pessimism regarding empire with a newly strident celebration of imperial grandeur, one which the public was happy to embrace. The triumphs over Tipu opened up a path for the former nabobs to be reintegrated into the British nation, popularly embraced as heroic figures who embodied the finest qualities of humanity and virtue.

This was a gradual process that took place over the course of the Mysore Wars, and even within the Company itself opinion was not always universal with regards to Tipu, but in the end it had a transformative effect on British perceptions of their empire, and established itself as the historical memory for future generations.

Sankar Muthu. Enlightenment Against Empire. (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2003); Jennifer Pitts. A Turn to Empire: The Rise of Imperial Liberalism in Britain and France (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2005): 14-15 Tipu's Role within Company Politics Over the course of the last two decades of the eighteenth century, popular attitudes about the Company's overseas servants began to change. Increasingly there was less mention of the despotic actions of the nabobs, and more focus upon the supposed Oriental despotism of Indian rulers such as Tipu Sultan. This debate played out within the East India Company's own ranks, as well as amongst the broader British public. The competing tug of war between different elements within the Company, and their disagreements over how to view Tipu Sultan, indicated the shifting opinion about the role of the East India Company in these decades.

–  –  –

means a monolithic entity. There existed real disagreements between individuals and between the different presidencies over how to approach the 1784 Treaty of Mangalore, and how to view Tipu Sultan. In particular, the Governor General and Council in Bengal disagreed sharply with the conduct of the Second Mysore War carried out by the Madras Presidency, leading to a fascinating series of exchanges between the two groups which played out over the course of 1783 and 1784. The Bengal Council criticized the early peace feelers sent out by the Madras government to Tipu Sultan, stating in official correspondences, "It would be very painful to our feelings to give you our real Sentiments on the Propriety as well as Policy of the Steps you have taken to solicit Peace with Tippoo."46 The Bengal Council found it unseemly that representatives of the Company sent to Tipu "should be directed to beg [their] Commiseration to our People who are Prisoners in his Hands."47 The Madras Council shot back their own response, Bengal Council to Madras Council 11 March 1783 (p.811-22) IOR/H/179 p. 817 Ibid, 817 defending their actions on the grounds that their negotiations had been necessary to separate Tipu from his French allies.48 The Madras Presidency had been coming under criticism for their handling of the war effort, due to the poor military record of the Company forces in southern India during the conflict. In the process of defending their own position, the Madras council would advocate a very different view of Tipu than that promoted by the Governor General in Bengal, one which reflected divergent strands of popular opinion within the East India Company’s ranks.

General Norman Macleod wrote to the Bombay Council to argue against what he saw as an unseemly rush to make peace, believing that Tipu was hard pressed by the Marathas and would agree to handsome terms, if the Company was firm in its demands.

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 28 | 29 || 31 | 32 |   ...   | 47 |

Similar works:

«Staff Misconduct Policy and Guidelines Guidelines on the handling of suspected breaches of the Australian Public Service Code of Conduct Table of Contents Revision History Introduction These Guidelines _ 3 Employee Responsibility _ 3 The APS code of conduct and you The Code of Conduct 4 APS Values and APS Employment Principles _ 4 Possible breaches of the Code of Conduct _ 6 Principles Informal 8 Allegations of misconduct will be considered by an independent and unbiased authority 8...»

«Mr Arwel Owen Our Ref: APP/Y0435/A/14/2224004 David Lock Associates Ltd Your Ref: FLA002 50 North Thirteenth Street Milton Keynes MK9 3BP 1 October 2015 Dear Sir, TOWN AND COUNTRY PLANNING ACT 1990 – SECTION 78 APPEAL BY FROSTS FAMILY LLP AT WAIN CLOSE, NEWPORT ROAD, WOBURN SANDS, MILTON KEYNES, MK17 8UZ APPLICATION: REF 14/00703/OUT 1. I am directed by the Secretary of State to say that consideration has been given to the report of the Inspector, Roisin M Barrett, BSc (Hons) Dip UD Dip Hist...»

«HISTORY OF WEATHER OBSERVATIONS Shreveport, Louisiana 1867 – 1957 November 2006 Prepared by: Gary K. Grice Information Manufacturing Corporation Rocket Center, West Virginia This report was prepared for the Midwestern Regional Climate Center under the auspices of the Climate Database Modernization Program, NOAA’s National Climatic Data Center, Asheville, North Carolina TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ii LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS iii INTRODUCTION Historical Overview 1 Goal of the Study 4...»

«Clio’s Psyche Understanding the “Why” of Culture, Current Events, History, and Society Marilyn Charles Symposium: Are Women the Dark Continent? Joan Wallach Scott: Featured Feminist Scholar Interview Special Issue on Psychology and the Holocaust: Part II Meeting Report Volume 21 Number 2 September 2014 Clio’s Psyche Vol. 21 No. 2 September 2014 ISSN 1080-2622 Published Quarterly by the Psychohistory Forum 627 Dakota Trail, Franklin Lakes, NJ 07417 Telephone: (201) 891-7486 E-mail:...»

«REVISTA BRASILEIRA DE GEOGRAFIA SUMARIO DO NUMERO DE JANEIRO DE 1939 APRESENTAÇÃO por JosÉ CARLos DE MAcEDO SoARES, Presidente do Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística.............. •........................... 3 RESOLUÇÃO N.o 18, de 12 de Julho de 1938 da Assembléia Geral do Conselho Nacional êle Geografia, que provê à publicação da Revista Brasileira de Geografia.................... 7 ARTIGOS HISTORICO DA...»

«PERMACULTURE DESIGN PLAN FOR ALDERLEAF FARM Alderleaf Farm 18715 299th Ave SE Monroe, WA 98272 Prepared by: Alderleaf Wilderness College www.WildernessCollege.com 360-793-8709 info@wildernesscollege.com January 19, 2011 TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION 1 What is Permaculture? 1 Vision for Alderleaf Farm 1 Site Description 2 History of the Alderleaf Property 3 Natural Features 4 SITE ELEMENTS: (Current Features, Future Plans, & Care) 5 Zone 0 5 Residences 5 Barn 6 Indoor Classroom & Office 6 Zone...»

«Harriet Beecher Stowe and Uncle Tom’s Cabin By most accounts, there have been few, if any, literary works that have had more influence on American culture and history than Harriet Beecher Stowe’s Uncle Tom’s Cabin (1851-1852). The apocryphal account of her meeting Abraham Lincoln in 1862 during the Civil War captures this influence. According to the legend, Lincoln supposedly greeted Stowe by saying “So you’re the little woman who wrote the book that made this great war.” Whether...»

«Selected Bibliography of Completed Theses and Dissertations Related to North Carolina Subjects COMPILED BY ANNE MILLER AND ELIZABETH CROWDER This compilation continues the “Selected Bibliography of Completed Theses and Dissertations Related to North Carolina Subjects, 1974–1978” published in the January 1979 issue of the North Carolina Historical Review and the supplements published annually in January since 1979. Titles included in this bibliography were derived from ProQuest Digital...»

«BANK-LENDING CHANNEL AND NON-FINANCIAL FIRMS: EVIDENCE FOR SPAIN Santiago Carbó Valverde♣ (Universidad de Granada and Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago) Departamento de Teoría e Historia Económica. Facultad de Ciencias Económicas y Empresariales. Universidad de Granada. Campus Universitario de Cartuja s/n. E-18071 Granada Tel: +34 958243717 E-mail: scarbo@ugr.es Rafael López del Paso Departamento de Teoría e Historia Económica. Facultad de Ciencias Económicas y Empresariales....»

«CONTEMPORARY HISTORY TEXTBOOKS IN THE SOUTH CAUCASUS ed. Luboš Veselý PRAGUE 2008 CONTEMPORARY HISTORY TEXTBOOKS IN THE SOUTH CAUCASUS ed. Luboš Veselý CONTEMPORARY HISTORY TEXTBOOKS IN THE SOUTH CAUCASUS Edited by Luboš Veselý Authors Ilham Abbasov, Nino Chikovani, Ketevan Kakitelashvili, Sergey Rumyantsev, Tigran Zakaryan, Mikayel Zolyan Translation Tamriko Bakuradze Proofreading Lydia Gawa Technical Assistance Marek Dvořák, Lucie Pávková Designed by Side2 Printed by BCS, s. r. o....»

«ThE Papers 05/05 Departamento de Teoría e Historia Económica Universidad de Granada Tejiendo Redes Empresariales en Andalucía Oriental: Vida y Obra de Alfredo Velasco y Sotillos (18721936). Gregorio Núñeza Universidad de Granada & GEHEb a Corresponding author: Gregorio Núñez, Departamento de Teoría e Historia Económica, Universidad de Granada. Campus Cartuja s/n, E-18071, GRANADA (SPAIN); Phone: +34 958 249918; Fax : +34 958 249995 ; e-mail: gnromero@ugr.es b “Grupo de Estudios...»

«Interrail Pass Guide 2016 Look inside to t ou get the most of your Pass Download the Interrail Rail Planner App. It’s free and works offline! Create your own Story Dear Interrail Traveler You have chosen the perfect way to explore Europe – by train! With the Interrail Pass you will be able to travel in the most exciting way imaginable, offering you the chance to fully appreciate Europe’s spectacular landscapes as well as its cultural and historical heritage. This booklet is designed to...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.