FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:     | 1 ||

«Tyndale Bulletin 51.2 (2000) 295-304. HAGGAI: MASTER RHETORICIAN M.J. Boda Summary Although the prophet among the Book of the Twelve with the fewest ...»

-- [ Page 2 ] --

Cf. R.W. Pierce, ‘Literary Connectors and a Haggai-Zechariah-Malachi Corpus’, JETS 27 (1984), 277-89; K.M. Craig, Jr., ‘Interrogatives in Haggai-Zechariah: A Literary Thread?’, in P.R. House and J.W. Watts, eds., Forming Prophetic Literature: Essays on Isaiah and the Twelve in Honor of John D.W. Watts (Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press, 1996), pp. 224-44.

10 Cf. T.W. Overholt, ‘Jeremiah 2 and the Problem of Audience Reaction’, CBQ 41 (1979), 262-73.

11 Although a portion of it is found in Jb. 1:8 and Is. 41:22.

12 Following Whedbee (‘Question-Answer Schemata’) who correctly sees the word ‘ways’ in 1:5, 7 as referring to past activity not future activity. This view is bolstered by noticing that when the phrase ‘consider’ (‫ )שִׂימו ּ לְבַבְכֶם עַל‬is used in Haggai (2:15and takes into account past and future, the word ‘ways’ is dropped. The view taken

here stands in contrast to P.L. Redditt, Haggai, Zechariah, Malachi (Grand Rapids:

Eerdmans, 1995), p. 20; Petersen, Haggai, p. 51; H.G. Mitchell, Haggai and Zechariah (ICC; Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark, 1912), p. 47, who see the second appearance as introducing the imperatives in 1:8 (future action). This second judgement is based on the view that the clause: ‘This is what the Lord Almighty says’ is an introductory phrase not a concluding one. But this view fails to take into account that 1:7a is introducing a declaration: ‘Give careful thought to your ways.’ BODA: Haggai 301 The second strategy unique to Haggai is one often mistakenly identified as evidence of disunity in the book. In Haggai 1 the prophet begins by identifying two different issues relevant to his community. The first issue is expressed through two of the previously discussed rhetorical strategies: quotation and interrogative. Playing off the leitmotif of ‘time’, Haggai is told to express God’s concern over the priorities of the people (1:2-4). Without a smooth transition, Haggai then introduces a second issue by employing his unique reflection idiom: ‫.שִׂימו ּ לְבַבְכֶם עַל‬This issue focuses the people’s attention on the hardships they have experienced in recent times (1:5-7). To this point these two issues are not related in any direct way. It is not until the audience passes over the three crucial commands in 1:8 (‫ )בנה  ,בוא  ,עלה‬with supporting causal phrases (‫ )כבד ,רצה‬that the two issues are linked. This is done in 1:9by picking up the second issue introduced (hardships; 1:5-7) and then asking the crucial question ‫.יַעַן  מֶה‬This question is used to link the issue of hardship with the initial issue of priorities. What appeared to many scholars as roughness reflecting various layers in the text, actually is evidence of powerful rhetorical technique.13 By not directly linking the two issues, Haggai allows the two to sink in more deeply. It also allows him to tell them what the required response is (1:8) before the final blow is administered in this judgement section.

Haggai employs another technique in his second major speech in 2:1Facing an audience discouraged and possibly also disgruntled by slow progress in the early stages of the project, the prophet begins his positive message with a series of questions (2:3). The first question begins on an objective level, asking who remained of those who saw the former temple. The second question subtly moves the discussion from the objective to the subjective level, sensitively probing the deeply seated attitudes of the people towards the project. The third question takes this a final step and reveals that the prophet understands their subjective reaction, justifying such discouragement. This technique grants the prophet an audience with the people and sets the tone for this crucial message of hope.

Haggai continues this trend of sensitively accommodating his message to his particular audience in the following pericope utilising a fourth rhetorical technique. In 2:10-14, the prophet engages the priests by employing a familiar speech form (the torah ruling) and 13 See n. 2 above.

302 Tyndale Bulletin 51.2 (2000) then using that form as the foundation for his main message.14 Although an odd form for the modern reader to understand, it is designed to draw the priests into dialogue and build a foundation for the following speech to the people as a whole. This torah ruling form also reflects another tendency of Haggai’s rhetoric: that is, to question his audience and thus force them to consider deeply his thrust.

A final technique can be discerned in 2:15-19. This section already contains one of Haggai’s unique strategies in the threefold repetition of the phrase ‫ 51.)81,51:2( שִׂימו ּ  לְבַבְכֶם‬But Haggai strengthens the rhetoric even further by employing another phrase three times:  ‫מִן־הַיוֹ ם‬ ּ ‫.)91,81,51:2( הַז ֶּה‬The first two occurrences attach the Hebrew word ‫ מַעְלָה‬to the end and have been translated in various ways due to what has been perceived as the awkward flow of this section. The usual translation of this Hebrew construction would be ‘from this day on’ (see 1 Sa. 16:13; 30:25) which many have rejected for this context in Haggai, because the occurrences in this passage are followed immediately by a reflection on the past. To resolve this apparent tension, some have translated this as ‘from this day backward’, representing a unique gloss in the Hebrew Bible.16 A more recent suggestion has been to link  ‫מִן־הַיוֹ ם‬ ּ ‫ הַז ֶּה‬with the verbal phrase ‫,שִׂימו ּ לְבַבְכֶם‬with the result that the people are to reflect deeply from this day on.17 However, this would not apply to the third occurrence of ‘from this day’ which is not linked with ‘give careful thought’ (2:19).

The answer to this dilemma may lie in accepting this passage as a rhetorical masterpiece in which Haggai forces deeper thinking 14 The foundation of this form is seen in Lv. 10:10, 11; Dt. 17:8-13; 21:5; Ezk. 44:23a responsibility demanded of the tribe of Levi in the Torah (cf. R. de Vaux, Ancient Israel: Religious Institutions [New York: McGraw-Hill, 1961], pp. 154, 354). Abuse of this responsibility is cited by the prophets: Mi. 3:11; Je. 18:18; Ezk. 7:26; 22:26; Zp.

3:4. See E.M. Meyers, ‘The Use of tôrâh in Haggai 2:11 and the Role of the Prophet in the Restoration Community’, in C.L. Meyers; M. O’Connor, eds., The Word of the Lord Shall Go Forth: Essays in Honor of David Noel Freedman in Celebration of His Sixtieth Birthday (Winona Lake: Eisenbrauns, 1983), pp. 69-76; also M. Fishbane, Biblical Interpretation in Ancient Israel (Oxford: Clarendon, 1985), p. 297.

15 Notice here the additional phrase ‫( עַל־דרְ כֵיכֶם‬found in 1:5, 7) is left out for it ַּ restricts reflection to the past while in this pericope the reflection is to be past, present and future (see n. 12 above).

16 Cf. E.H. Merrill, An Exegetical Commentary: Haggai, Zechariah, Malachi (Chicago: Moody Press, 1994), pp. 49, 51, for this argument and Mitchell (Haggai, pp.

73-74) for arguments against.

17 D.J. Clark, ‘Problems in Haggai 2:15-19’, Bible Translator 34 (1983), 432.

BODA: Haggai 303 through introducing multiple thoughts at the same time.18 We have seen this technique in his first speech in which two ideas were presented but left unconnected until the second phase of the speech. Here in 2:15-19, the prophet begins a speech about the future three times, but each time interrupts himself by drawing attention to the past.

The result of this creative rhetoric is that the people are forced to think of the past, present and future simultaneously. It places great emphasis on the present with the repeated reference to ‫‘( הַיוֹ ם‬the day’) which is ּ identified as the day of the foundation laying (five times; 2:15, 18, 19).

At the same time, however, the people are to consider the future  ‫מִן־הַיוֹ ם‬ ּ ‫‘( הַז ֶּה‬from this day on’; 2:15, 18) and the past   ‫מִטֶּרֶ ם  ש ׂו ּם־אֶבֶן‬ ‫‘( אֶל־אֶבֶן‬before one stone was laid on another’; 2:15). Although more words are linked to the description of the frustrating past, greater emphasis is placed on the anticipated future by beginning and ending with a future time reference and constantly interrupting the full declaration of the future dimension. Most emphasis, however, is placed on the significance of the present day which functions as a linchpin between a past of curse and a future of blessing and calls the people to reflect deeply upon this thought.19 As has been highlighted throughout this article, Haggai is a masterful rhetorician. He consistently expresses his words in ways accommodating to his audience. One consistent value for Haggai, 18 This is similar to but not identical to the view that we have here a parenthetical remark. Cf. D.R. Hildebrand, ‘Temple Ritual: A Paradigm for Moral Holiness in Haggai II 10-19’, VT 39 (1989), 164.

19 The significance of that day is that it is the day of the foundation laying. See the foundational research of R.S. Ellis, Foundation Deposits in Ancient Mesopotamia (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1968) which has been mined brilliantly by E.

‘Recherches sur le livre de Zacharie’, VT 20 (1970), 25-55; D.L. Petersen, ‘Zerubbabel and Jerusalem Temple Reconstruction’, CBQ 36 (1974), 366-72; Petersen, Haggai, pp.

89-90; B. Halpern, ‘The Ritual Background of Zechariah’s Temple Song’, CBQ 40 (1978), 171-72; R.E. Averbeck, ‘Biblical Temple Building Accounts in Light of Ritual and Structure in the Gudea Cylinders’, Society of Biblical Literature 1991 Seminar Papers (Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1991), 1-15; and A. Laato, ‘Zachariah 4,6b-10a and the Akkadian Royal Building Inscriptions’, ZAW 106 (1994), 53-69. Prior to publication of Ellis’ 1965 dissertation, which does not make connections between Mesopotamian and Hebrew practices, Bewer, Galling and Petitjean had noted preliminary links between them. Cf. J.A. Bewer, ‘Ancient Babylonian Parallels to the Prophecies of Haggai,’ AJSLL 35 (1919), 128-33; K. Galling, ‘Serubbabel und der Hohepriester beim Wiederaufbau des Tempels in Jerusalem’, in Studien zur Geschichte Israels im Persischen Zeitalter (Tübingen: Mohr, 1964), pp. 127-48; A.

Petitjean, ‘La Mission de Zorobbabel et la Reconstruction du Temple’, Ephemerides Theologicae Lovanienses 42 (1966), 40-71.

304 Tyndale Bulletin 51.2 (2000) displayed in many of the techniques he employs, is that of not allowing the audience from the outset to know where his message is going until it is absolutely necessary. This successfully creates a greater impact on them when the message is clarified.

Although the prophet among the Book of the Twelve with the fewest words, save Jonah, Haggai takes his place among the prophetic tradition as one of their greatest rhetoricians. Among a generation questioning the validity and future of the prophetic voice, Haggai bore witness for the

Pages:     | 1 ||

Similar works:

«Regional Oral History Office University of California The Bancroft Library Berkeley, California The Wine Spectator California Wine Oral History Series Arthur A. Ciocca ARTHUR A. CIOCCA AND THE WINE GROUP, INC.: INSIGHTS INTO THE WINE INDUSTRY FROM A MARKETING PERSPECTIVE Interviews Conducted by Carole Hicke in 1999 Copyright 2000 by The Regents of the University of California @ Since 1954 the Regional Oral History Office has been interviewing leading participants in or well-placed witnesses to...»

 [music] SID: My guest not only teaches on the glory, but shows you how to walk in God's glory 24/7. This will activate every one of God's promises in your life. Is there a supernatural dimension, a world beyond the one we know? Is there life after death? Do angels exist? Can our dreams contain messages from Heaven? Can we tap into ancient secrets of the supernatural? Are healing miracles real? Sid Roth has spent over 35 years researching the strange world of the supernatural. Join Sid...»

«Mitra, Tapas, Mitra, Sheuli Growth symbiosis of Kolkata region RSA Conference, 2015 Region, Periphery and the City Core: Transformations in Morphology and Growth Symbiosis: A Case of Kolkata City and Region First Author: Tapas Mitra, Associate Professor, Department of Architecture, School of Planning and Architecture, Bhopal, India. Co-author: Sheuli Mitra, Associate Professor, Department of Planning, School of Planning and Architecture, Bhopal, India. _ Abstract: The urbanization and growth of...»

«Imperial Federation: Continuity and Change in British Imperial Ideas, 1869-1871 r^gzsgzzgzsgzzf&gzsezxzzgzxz&zzgzzgz^zzgzsgz^ of imperial federation in Great Britain during the midT H E SUBJECT Victorian years has received relatively little attention from historians of empire. Most of the recent literature on the mid-Victorian age has been pre-occupied with the controversy surrounding Robinson and Gallagher and their critics, and the continuing debate over C. A. Bodelsen and his notions of...»

«Papers, 2010, 95/2 321-339 Nationalism, Territoriality and National Territorial Belonging John Etherington Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona Departament de Ciència Política i Dret Públic john.etherington@uab.es Received: 15-05-2006 Accepted: 01-07-2009 Abstract Most studies of nationalism are based on an understanding of the nation as a cultural collectivity that can be located in historical terms in the passage from the pre-modern to the modern era. Rather less attention is paid to spatial...»

«Journal of Religion in Africa 40 (2010) 163-191 brill.nl/jra “Maybe Freedom Will Come from You”: Christian Prophecies and Rumors in the Development of Rural Resistance in South Africa, 1948-1961* Sean Redding Department of History, Amherst College, Amherst, MA 01002, USA sredding@amherst.edu Abstract In South Africa Christian teachings and texts informed African political activity in the 1950s and 1960s particularly in the rural areas, and rumors predicting both real revolts and fantastic...»

«Light From the Cage: 25 Years in a Prison Classroom Judy Wenzel (www.judypattersonwenzel.com) May 17, 2015 Prisons do a very good job of punishing, of keeping “bad” people in and the rest of us away from them, which makes the people inside prison walls essentially invisible and covered with layers of stereotypes and prejudice. Whether intended or not, the number of people we have incarcerated has become a form of racial control, and 2.3 million people behind bars is defining a big part of...»

«                                                                                                                                                                HISTORY OF THE TEXAS STATE SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON, D.C. 1904-1920 Texans’ traditional way of seeking out one another’s company in far places in which they find themselves let to...»

«ELON UNIVERSITY Department of History Inside this issue: Bissett 2 Recognized and Geography News Students 2 Recognized Ellis‟ Essay 2 Nominated Volume 1, Issue 1 Spring 2009 Crowe‟s The 3 Holocaust: Roots, Students Mentored by HST/GEO Faculty Secure 4 Lumen Prizes History, and Aftermath Selected Of the 2009 Lumen Prizes, 4 of 13 or 30.769 percent of Lumen Prizes awarded campus wide went to our department! Beck‟s book 3 Selected Elizabeth Leman, History/International Studies will work with...»

«A culture of sports, activity and well-being among BC First Nations. Active Spirit, Active History A culture of sports, activity and well-being among BC First Nations. 1205-100 Park Royal South, West Vancouver, BC, V7T 1A2 © Copyright by First Nations Health Council, 2010. First Edition. Produced by CopperMoon Research by Rosalin Hanna All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, in any form or by any means, without permission from the Publisher. Chris & Andrew Taylor...»

«BOOK REVIEWS META: RESEARCH IN HERMENEUTICS, PHENOMENOLOGY, AND PRACTICAL PHILOSOPHY VOL. VI, NO. 1 / JUNE 2014: 417-424 ISSN 2067-3655, www.metajournal.org The Sophistic Effect Eduardo Mendieta Stony Brook University Peter Carravetta, The Elusive Hermes: Method Discourse Interpreting, Aurora, Colorado: The Davies Group Publishers, 2012, 504 p. Keywords: hermeneutics, semiotics, philosophy of language, sophist, rhetoric Peter Carravetta’s The Elusive Hermes is an immensely erudite book. It...»

«New York State Student Information Repository System (SIRS) Manual Reporting Data for the 2014–15 School Year October 21, 2014 Version 10.0 The University of the State of New York THE STATE EDUCATION DEPARTMENT Information and Reporting Services Albany, New York 12234 Student Information Repository System Manual Version 10.0 Revision History Version Date Revisions Initial Release. Updates for 2014–15 highlighted in yellow:  Assignment, Employment Separation Reason, PMF Assignment, Staff...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.