FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 37 | 38 || 40 | 41 |   ...   | 51 |

«A Thesis Submitted for the Degree of PhD at the University of Warwick This thesis is made available online and is ...»

-- [ Page 39 ] --

may be most efficaciously employed in the cause of virtue and decorum, by holding up to public notice, many offenders against both, who are not amenable to any other tribunal, and who, though they contemptuously defy all serious reproof, tremble at the thoughts of seeing their vices or follies attacked by the keen shafts of ridicule. 2o Pictorial descriptions of highly personal and usually sexual incidents could thus be seen to function as both deterrent and punishment. The alarm that they could (or, rather, that the satirists hoped that they could) create amongst the vitiated elite, is expressed in Maria Edgeworth's Belinda. Lady Delacour is concerned that her retreat from the world of dissipated fashion will be perceived as other than a conscious moral choice. She fears "witticism, epigrams, caricatures without end" and anticipates, "we should have 'Lord and Lady D--, or The Domestic Tete-a-Tete, or The Reformed Amazon,' stuck up in a print-shop window!"21 Imagery was also called on to support these authors' claims that they sought simply to reveal the 'truth,' to relay facts that had either been falsified or only partially conveyed by their competitors. One account of the lives of Lord and Lady Ligonier strongly drew on such rhetoric. It asserted that, whilst many similar publications were "repugnant to truth, decency, and sound morality," its own sources were "genuine and Rules for Drawing Caricaturas; with an Essay on Comic Painting (London. 1788). p.4. This was a traditional argument. See also. H. Fielding. 'The History of the Adventures of Joseph Andrews' (1742), in A. Humphreys. ed.. Henry Fielding: Joseph Andrews and Shamela (London. 1993), preface. pp.47-53 21 M. Edgeworth. Belinda (1801). ed. E. Ni Chuilleanain (London. 1994). p.276 authentic" and thus entirely laudable. 22 The authors of an article on the Duchess of Kingston, published in the British Magazine and Review, similarly claimed; "our business is only to relate facts, and to found our opinions upon incontrovertible truths," whilst The Life and Memoirs of Elizabeth Chudleigh was significantly subtitled Written from Authentic Information and Original Documents. The text reiterated the point made in the title, reassuring its readers that every detail of the case was related "with fairness and candour" and that nothing was either extenuated or told in malice. The result, it proudly claimed, was "a true tale... unbiassed by prejudice, unvarnished by partiality, and supported by the evidence of facts."23 Prints helped to consolidate this desired impression of authenticity, anticipating the still potent power of the photograph to imply an unbiased and unfalsified testimony. The Trial of Robert Feilding, published in 1776, contained an appendix which discussed the Duchess of Kingston's case and was supported by a remarkably detailed engraving (fig. 116). It describes the hall at Westminster where she was tried and depicts both the protagonists of the case and its audience. The scene is elucidated with the assistance of a large and complicated reference system. For The Generous Husband; or, the History of Lord Lelius and the Fair Emilia: containing likewise the genuine memoirs of Asmodei, the pretended Piedmontese count, from the time of his birth, to his late ignominious fall in Hyde Park (London, 1771), pp. v, vii. The author further claimed his intention to be "exposing vice, promoting virtue, innocently entertaining the reader, conveying instruction by example... " The British Magazine and Review, 1782, p.91; The Life and Memoirs of Elizabeth Chudleigh, p.5. Also, McGreery in 'Keeping up with the Bon Ton', pp.212-3 remarks that the editors of The Town and Country Magazine were often keen to deny that their accounts of illicit affairs were fabricated. To aid in this, they often complained that readers were submitting unsubstantiated or purely fictional articles for inclusion. She contends that they were only partially accurate, often exaggerated and sometimes completely falsified. H. Bleackley, on the other hand, in 'Tete-a-Tete Portraits in 'The Town and Country Magazine', Notes and Queries, Series 4 (23 September 1905), p.242, denied ](/h that they were either "spurious or inaccurate."

example, the viewer is informed that '4' designates the Lord High Steward's chair whilst '5' locates the "Lord High Steward removed from his chair, nearer the bar for conveniency of hearing." The textual accompaniment also informs the viewer of particulars of colour and material not easily conveyed through a graphic medium, noting, "all the seats are covered, and scaffolding hung with red baize."24 Such prints conveyed a sense of veracity, suggesting personal acquaintance with events that were, for most, both spatially and socially distant.

Despite these high-flown moral assertions, the real motives behind both literary and visual satire were probably far removed from the realm of social conscience. Rather, it was the entertaining and scandalous nature of the behaviour of these aristocrats that stimulated the avaricious public demand for informative

–  –  –

numerous satires of Lady Worsley taking her infamous bath, she ironically has her back turned to the official voyeur, Mr Bissett, in order to display her physical attractions to the viewer (figs. 117, 118 and 122). The highly revealing costume worn by Elizabeth Chudleigh to the Venetian Ambassadors ball in 1749, attending in the character of Iphigenia, was also remarkably popular with graphic artistS. 27 Occasionally, contemporaries did question the superficial moralising of the The Trial of Robert Feilding Esq., opening illustration 25 McGreery, 'Keeping up with the Bon Ton', p.223 P. Wagner, 'The Pornographer in the Court-room: Trial Reports about Cases of Sexual Crimes and Delinquencies as a Genre of Eighteenth-Century Erotica', in P. Bouce, ed., Sexuality in Eighteenth-Century Britain (Manchester, 1982), p.l24 27 See, for example, Anon., Miss CHUDLEIGH, in the CHARACTER of IPHIGENIA. at the Venetian Ambassador's Masquerade (c.1749) and F. Chesham, DUCHESS of KINGSTON as she appeared at the Venetian Ambassador's Ball in Somerset House (c. 1749), both in the National Portrait Gallery's engravings collection. An inscription on the latter claims, very dubiously, that the print is taken from a portrait by Thomas Gainsborough.

pamphleteers. A character in Reflections on Celibacy and Marriage, published in 1771, argued that such accounts of licentious behaviour were merely entertaining.

Indeed, rather than deterring their readers from similarly sinful activities, they were more likely to provide encouragement by acquainting them with the particulars of vice. 28 Public curiosity concerning the physical appearance of these notorious celebrities enhanced the popularity of such images. Satirists often drew on extant portraits of the protagonists in order to fulfil this demand. For example, in 1775, The Matrimonial Magazine published a satire on the Duchess of Kingston by W. Nicolls (fig.119). Entitled The Married Maid of Honour, or, The Widow's Wife and her two Husbands, it depicts Elizabeth Chudleigh in a head and shoulders oval, surmounting similar portraits of her two husbands in profile. 29 This representation of the Duchess was probably derived from an early portrait by Sir Joshua Reynolds, executed in the mid 1740s (fig.120). The pictures share the same tilt of the head, the same sideways glance, the same features, a similar costume and an identical hairstyle. 3o Thus, imagery from the more elevated genre of portraiture has been de-contextualised and F. Douglas, Reflections on Celibacy and Marriage; in Four Letters to a Friend; In which the ADVANTAGES and DISADVANTAGES of the two STATES are compared (London, 1771), p.60 Printed to accompany 'Memoirs of the Married Maid of Honour; or. The Widow'd Wife' in The Matrimonial Magazine; or, Monthly Anecdotes of love and Marriage for the Court, the City and the Country January 1775, pp.9-l3 A. Graves and W.V. Cronin, A History of the Works of Sir Joshua Reynolds PRA 4 Vols.

(London, 1899), I. pp.174-5 record this painting and date it to c.l747. I have only been able to trace the image in its mezzotinted form, a reproduction of which is in the Chudleigh file in the Heinz Archive at the National Portrait Gallery. London. It may be the portrait referred to by James Northcote in a letter to his brother. 18 April 1776. quoted in The Whitley Papers. Vol.IX. f.1098: "Sir Joshua has a head of her done by him more than thirty years since. at Saltram. before he went to Italy." McGreery in 'Keeping up with the Bon Ton', pp.21O, 213 has noted a similar use of portraits and miniatures by the creators of the Tete-a-Tetes.

redefined to suit the narrative wishes of the satirist. The print not only infers the duality of the Duchess's married life through the arrangement of its components, but also suggests the perversity of her activities through the perversion of several pictorial 'types.' The positioning of Captain Hervey and the Duke of Kingston in horizontally aligned, oval portraits, reproduced alongside a chronicle of their lives, instantly recalls the Tete-a-Tete engravings that were a popular feature of The Town and Country Magazine. These typically consisted of twin pictures of a (normally famous) man and a (less often famous) woman, preceding an account of the (usually illicit) affair between them (fig.121). By replacing the lovers with the two husbands of one woman, the familiar model is humorously ruptured and the narrative of a romantic union destroyed. The Married Maid of Honour similarly echoes and overthrows the format of the pendant tradition. The mutually complementary and harmonious concordia discors and division of marital relations into masculine and feminine spheres are denied in the eradication of the dualised format. Similarly, the supposed equality of the companionate marriage, expressed in the presentation of spouses in equally prominent pictorial and spatial terms, is here nullified by the Duchess's dominant position.

Thus, the likeness as painted by Reynolds has become subservient to the chronicle and the positive portrait, intended to flatter and enhance, is inverted and incorporated into the negative genre of printed satire, designed to criticise and lampoon. However, it can be argued that such portraits and satires functioned in similar ways, albeit to different ends. First, a central feature of the workings of both genres is what Richard Brilliant has referred to as the act of 'naming'. He emphasises that 'likeness' only comes into play once the subject has been identified, either through the provision of necessary information, or through the process of recognition.

This enables the viewer to compare subject and representation. 31 In portraits, such as that by Reynolds, the connection established by such identification enables the generic qualities of beauty, modesty and youth to be associated with the individual sitter and the flattering agenda of the genre to be fulfilled. In satires, such as that in The Matrimonial Magazine, naming enables the details of the image to be understood through recollection of the associated narrative (in this case, the bigamy trial). Indeed, the importance of this process helps to explain the eighteenth-century penchant for referring to subjects as 'L--y W --y' or 'L--y G-'. Far from obscuring identification, the quantity and popUlarity of texts and images relating to such characters' activities filled in the gaps as effectively as the printer, simultaneously preventing any repercussions in terms of prosecution for libel. Indeed, the application of externally gathered knowledge to the individual work under scrutiny must have enhanced its attractiveness as a consumer object, facilitating a sensation of knowledge, recognition and fulfilment of curiosity.3 2 Thus, 'naming' functioned in both negative and positive terms. As Jonathan

Richardson had argued early in the century:

Upon the sight of a portrait, the character, and master-strokes of the history of the person it represents are apt to flow in upon the mind, and to be the subject of conversation: so that to sit for one's picture, is to have an abstract 31 R. Brilliant, Portraiture (London, 1991), p.30 32 McGreery, 'Keeping up with the Bon Ton', p.214 of one's life written, and published, and ourselves thus consigned over to honour or infamy.33 The idea of the portrait as more than a record of an individual's features, as also conveying character and history, was central to Richardson's thought and was subsequently adopted and developed by Reynolds. In his Discourses, the President of the Royal Academy denigrated detailed physical description and recommended that his students reduce sitters to "classes and general descriptions." Whilst this argument may have read as an apologia for his own problems in capturing an accurate likeness, it did suggest that portraiture was more elevated than permitted by traditional academic precept, and let him claim; "there are therefore large ideas to be found even in this contracted subject."34 However, Reynolds's theoretical attempts to distil character were ironically parallel to the satirical process. The largely anonymous artists of the prints under discussion similarly reduced individuals to generalised types, categorising them as aristocratic whores or as profligate and amoral noblemen.

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 37 | 38 || 40 | 41 |   ...   | 51 |

Similar works:

«Click here to order the book or the accompanying PowerPoint (http://www.sundayschoolcourses.com/monastic/monastic.htm) A Brief History of Western Monasticism Written by Robert Jones Acworth, Georgia  2000, 2009 Robert C. Jones Christian Theology and History Adult Sunday School Courses Robert Jones www.sundayschoolcourses.com I’ve always been a strong believer in adult Sunday School classes and Bible studies in our churches. And many churches have quality, Biblically-based adult-focused...»

«Tyndale Bulletin 20 (1969) 95-104. HEBREW TOPONYMS By M. E. J. RICHARDSON A. PLACE NAMES AND PERSONAL NAMES The study of Hebrew toponomy has recently been set on its feet by Professor Yohanan Aharoni in the English edition of his survey of Biblical geography.1 The subject, to which he devotes a whole chapter, has usually been examined in comprehensive studies of Hebrew proper names and invariably personal names have then stolen the limelight. But with the increasing pace of Palestinian...»

«A Bibliography of Canadian Religious History Une bibliographie d’histoire religieuse du Canada 1964 2005 BiCRH / BiHRC : 1 Brian F. Hogan Version 01 : May 2006 © Hogan Historical Services and the Canadian Catholic Historical Association HHS & CCHA PREFATORY MATERIALS: An Introduction to BiCRH / BiHRC : 1 P1 p. 03 P2 Notes and Tips for Using the Bibliography p. 05 P3 Tasks Remaining for the Bibliography as of May 2006 p. 09 Table of Contents / Table des matières p. 11 2 *P1 : An Introduction...»

«SARAJEVO A STUD Y IN THE ORIGINS OF THE GREA Τ WAR By R. W. SETON-WATSON D.Litt. (Oxon), Hon. Ph.D. (Prague and Zagreb); Masaryk Professor of Central European History in the University of London; Hon. Member of the Roumanian Academy LONDON: HUTCHINSON & CO. (Publishers), LTD. PATERNOSTER ROW, E.C. Made and Printed in Great Britain by The Camelot Press Limited, London and Southampton TO MY WIFE AS A MEMORY OF FOUR JUGOSLAV JOURNEYS TOGETHER (1912, 1913, 1920, 1925.) SARAJEVO (A SERB FOLKSONG)...»

«Educational materials developed through the Baltimore County History Labs Program, a partnership between Baltimore County Public Schools and the UMBC Center for History Education. Should the Colonies Have Revolted Against Great Britain? Author: Lauren Catts, Hawthorne Elementary School; Elizabeth Getsinger, Westowne Elementary School; Corjie Tarlton, Sparks Elementary School, Baltimore County Public Schools Grade Level: Upper Elementary Duration: 6 Days Overview: At the time of the...»

«THE GROUND OF EMPOWERMENT W. E. B. Du Bois and the Vision of Africa’s Past by Tracey Lynn Thompson A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of History University of Toronto © Copyright by Tracey Lynn Thompson 2011 The Ground of Empowerment W. E. B. Du Bois and the Vision of Africa’s Past Tracey Lynn Thompson Doctor of Philosophy Department of History University of Toronto 2011 Abstract Scholars have examined many aspects of W....»

«Supporting Transition-Aged Foster Youth Background A Vulnerable Population. Each year, roughly 4,000 foster youth ages 18-21 leave California’s foster care system, and strive to achieve self-sufficiency. Foster youth leave home on average eight years earlier than non-foster youth, yet receive only one-fifth the financial support. 1 Unsurprisingly, most struggle to secure and maintain housing, transportation, employment, and health care. Trauma and Mental Health. All foster youth share a...»

«Papers, 2010, 95/2 321-339 Nationalism, Territoriality and National Territorial Belonging John Etherington Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona Departament de Ciència Política i Dret Públic john.etherington@uab.es Received: 15-05-2006 Accepted: 01-07-2009 Abstract Most studies of nationalism are based on an understanding of the nation as a cultural collectivity that can be located in historical terms in the passage from the pre-modern to the modern era. Rather less attention is paid to spatial...»

«The Global Exploration Strategy: The Framework for Coordination Page 1 of 25 The Global Exploration Strategy The Framework for Coordination The Global Exploration Strategy Framework: Executive Summary Space exploration enriches and strengthens humanity’s future. Searching for answers to fundamental questions such as: ‘Where did we come from?’ ‘What is our place in the universe?’ and ‘What is our destiny?’ can bring nations together in a common cause, reveal new knowledge, inspire...»

«History of Psychoanalysis in Cleveland Norman A. Clemens, M.D. This account is a manuscript submitted for publication in a History of Psychiatry in Cleveland edited by Kathleen H. Stoll. It is posted on the web site of the Cleveland Psychoanalytic Center by permission of the author. The Beginnings After a decade of developing the “talking cure,” Sigmund Freud1 introduced psychoanalysis to the world in 1900 with the courageous publication of “The Interpretation of Dreams.” The discovery...»

«European Review of Latin American and Caribbean Studies 91, October 2011 | 15-30 Roberto d’Aubuisson vs Schafik Handal: Militancy, Memory Work and Human Rights Ralph Sprenkels ‘Si hemos de mirar al pasado, que sea sólo para extraer de él firmeza, reafirmación de nuestro carácter revolucionario’ Schafik Handal Abstract: This article examines the memory work that former parties to the Salvadoran conflict engage in with regard to two key historical leaders: Roberto d’Aubuisson, on the...»

«From: International Environmental Law and World Order: A Problem-Oriented Casebook, Third Edition, by Jonathan C. Carlson, Sir Geoffrey W.R. Palmer and Burns H. Weston (West Publishing, 2012). Chapter 14 THE FUTURE OF INTERNATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL LAW: A LAW OF THE ECOLOGICAL COMMONS? Humankind’s modern history is tragically marked by the squandering of nonrenewable resources, the wanton killing of precious life species, and the overall contamination and degradation of delicate ecosystems. So...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.