FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 42 | 43 || 45 | 46 |   ...   | 52 |

«Combat, Memory and Remembrance in Confederation Era Canada: The Hidden History of the Battle of Ridgeway, June 2, 1866 Peter Wronski (Peter Vronsky) ...»

-- [ Page 44 ] --

The only combat took place at Pigeon Hill on June 9 when Crown forces and artillery pulled up in front of approximately 200 Fenians still lingering in Canada. When the Fenians opened fire, a troop of cavalry—the Royal Guides ―Governor General Body Guard of Lower Canada‖—elite members of the Montreal Hunt Club—charged the barricades and smacked the Fenians with the flat of their swords, herding them across the border into the arms of the awaiting U.S. Army who seized and disarmed them. It was probably Canada‘s first and last cavalry charge and there were no casualties.7 “What did that coward, that poltrooney scoundrel Dennis say...” On June 15 Macdonald wrote to the Executive Council, ―As all apprehensions of a recurrence of Fenian Raids seem to have passed away for the time being, and as the gallant volunteers on active service are suffering from their absence from their homes and vocations – the force can without hazard to the safety of the province be greatly reduced.‖8 On the same day, the Toronto Globe began advertising ―cheap excursions‖ to Fort Erie by the City of Toronto and Erie-Niagara Railway so that many may ―avail themselves of this opportunity to visit a place historic before, but having a peculiar attraction now.‖9 After debating through most of July and early August about what went wrong at Ridgeway and dragging Booker and Peacocke through a maelstrom of blame and criticism, by mid-August the newspapers were turning to other stories. As Canadians settled down into the Senior, The Last Invasion, pp. 123-126 Senior, The Last Invasion, p. 126 Globe, June 15, 1866 last dog-days of summer, it appeared as if Lt. Colonel John Stoughton Dennis had not only escaped the Fenians on the night of June 2 in Fort Erie, but as well any public scrutiny and censure of his conduct during the battle. No accusations or rumours bubbled up about Dennis in the Canadian press throughout the summer while Booker‘s and Peacocke‘s errors and misdeeds were enthusiastically raked over by the press and public.

In the days after the battle at Fort Erie, Dennis had been distinguished by an appointment as ‗brigade major‘ (chief of staff) to the Colonel Lowry, the British commander of forces on the Niagara frontier. Dennis was further mentioned in despatches by Lowry who wrote on June 18, that he had ―proved himself admirable in matter of detail and has been most active and useful to me here. He has special talent for the performance of staff duties and as there has been a force of about 3,000 volunteers on this Frontier, his capacity in that respect has been well tested.‖10 McMicken‘s confidential June 23 memo to Macdonald describing Dennis‘s ―poltroonery and cowardice‖ was filed away and not acted upon by Macdonald. On June 24-25, Dennis survived what must have been the most dangerous moment for his reputation. Newspapers in Canada published a series of official reports released by the government from commanders in the field during the operation. Included among them was Dennis‘s own account of how he drew up his ―little command‖ in Fort Erie and made a courageous stand with his men but outnumbered by the Fenians was forced to order them to retreat and concealed himself to avoid capture until he could fight another day.

Running near the end of the reports was a short statement from the Robb‘s Captain Lachlan McCallum. It had been written at Dennis‘s request and addressed to him. In it McCallum refrained from describing the ground combat and only reported on the movement of Lowry to MacDougall, June 18, 1866, United Canada Subject Files, Frontier Service Reports, RG9 IC8, Vol. 9.

LAC the Robb, referring to Dennis only once, ―On Saturday last, 2nd June between the hours of 2 and 4 p.m.11 after your departure, I retreated down the river under a galling fire...‖12 [my emphasis] The term ―after your departure‖ had not caught anybody‘s attention and when the reports ran without much comment in the newspapers on the events in Fort Erie, Dennis must have felt tremendously relieved that the press did not catch his scent of disgrace. McMicken and Macdonald, however, knew precisely how pointed that phrase was and its entire subtext as did all the men who were under Dennis‘s command that day.

Three days later, in military parlance, ―the stuff hit the fan.‖ Adjutant General of Militia Patrick L. MacDougall in Ottawa received a letter from Captain Lachlan McCallum. The Captain was outraged by what he had read in Dennis‘s published report. In his letter McCallum accused Dennis of ordering his men ashore ―against the judgments of all the Officers under his command‖ resulting in four brave men being ―cripples for life besides exposing the lives of all his command to no effect except the shooting of a few Fenians.‖ Furthermore, McCallum wrote, Dennis halted his command at a point where they were exposed to fire from both Fenian flanks, and despite having time to retreat to the Robb he recklessly did not. Dennis countermanded orders that McCallum had given to open fire on the enemy and then ―departed from his command before a gun was fired leaving us in that painful position...‖13 On July 4, the New York Times reprinted a story from the Detroit Advertiser, ―Heroism of an English Colonel‖ that alleged Dennis had stripped-off his uniform and hid naked in a hayloft McCallum errs in his time of the battle, which occurred closer to between 4 and 6 p.m.

McCallum, Official Report McCallum to McDougall, June 28, 1866: Adjutant General‘s Correspondence; Correspondence relating to complaints, courts martial and inquiries, RG9-I-C-8, Volume 7 LAC.

and nervously cut himself twice while shaving off his whiskers to disguise himself.14 Dennis must have felt the sharks circling him but the press in Canada did not bite on the story.

On July 17, Dennis sent Colonel William Smith Durie, the Assistant Adjutant-General of Militia in Canada West, an eight-page letter refuting McCallum‘s accusations with five appended witness statements from Fort Erie citizens attesting to Dennis‘s version of events.15 It apparently would have done the trick. On August 16, General Sir John Michel the commanderin-chief of British troops in Canada wrote MacDougall, he saw no reason for further investigation into Dennis‘s conduct and added ―I think that Cap. McCallum might be desired to be more careful in making charges such as these he had advanced.‖16 There must have been a collective sigh of relief that McCallum‘s allegations could now be put away quietly, especially since criticism of the government‘s performance during the Fenian crisis was dying down in the press. Nobody wanted to stir up any new revelations or scandals.

It was not going to be that easy. By then Artillery Captain Dr. Richard King had recovered from the amputation of his leg sufficiently well enough to depart Buffalo for his home in Port Robinson. Nothing would make for a better mid-Victorian summer picnic and festival in Welland County than to loudly and proudly welcome home a hero. On August 9 thousands of citizens and dignitaries flocked to King‘s homecoming on foot, in carriages, on horseback and by train. The Welland Railway ran special trains and charged half-price for the tickets. Flags and bunting were hung everywhere. So many communities wanted to participate along the canal that a route was organized for a flotilla of yachts that would take King down the system stopping at New York Times, July 4, 1866 Dennis to Durie, July 17, 1866: Adjutant General‘s Correspondence; Correspondence relating to complaints, courts martial and inquiries, RG9-I-C-8, Volume 7 LAC.

[Michel] to MacDougal, August 16, 1866, Adjutant General‘s Correspondence; Correspondence relating to complaints, courts martial and inquiries, RG9-I-C-8, Volume 7 LAC various points for people to view him on the deck. He was surrounded by a military guard of honour while a brass band played ―Home Again.‖ A gun battery fired a salute as he passed.17 Prepared for once to write a ‗good news‘ story on a hero‘s homecoming, instead of the usual litany of incompetence that had dominated the news in Canada since the invasion in the beginning of June, newspaper reporters poured into the towns. Along the way at the various stops, dignitaries, civil officials, MPPs, and even Toronto‘s mayor Francis Medcalf assembled to greet Captain King. Everywhere King went there stood huge arches across the span of which was written, ―Welcome to our brave captain.‖ 18 As the yacht arrived at its final destination of Port Robinson, King was borne off the deck to a waiting carriage in which sat MPP T.C. Street. From the carriage King was to review and address his brave men of the Welland Field Artillery Battery assembled in their ranks before him. One version of what happened next, according to the Globe, was that King said

–  –  –

Without naming Dennis, the Globe reported only a single discordant note, ―Dr. King complained bitterly of the management of the commander... He said they could have done better than they did but for the way in which they were commanded.‖20 The other version was contained in a less circumspect report from a different newspaper, a clipping of which was attached to a letter Durie received from Dennis four days later complaining, ―Capt. King is there stated to have applied the following language to me – ‗We Globe, August 11, 1866 Globe, August 11, 1866 Globe, August 11, 1866 Globe, August 11, 1866 were commanded by a coward. I allude to Colonel Dennis who is a coward and a paltry one‘ and again, further on, ‗What did that coward, that poltrooney scoundrel Dennis say... etc.‘‖21 Dennis now demanded a Court of Inquiry just like Booker‘s and that Captain King be ordered to retract his comments or be charged with conduct unbecoming an officer for making such remarks in public about a superior officer while addressing a military force. In the wake of the cries of ‗whitewash‘ in the press earlier in August following the publication of the findings of the Booker Inquiry, this new development was not at all welcomed. There was no way that Dennis could now be given a similar cleansing that had been offered Booker. Durie forwarded the letter to MacDougall in Ottawa, noting on it ―that an error of judgement which maybe be attributed to Lt. Col Dennis – is one thing – cowardice – another.‖22 Durie was convinced that ―Capt. King was not warranted in making use of the language alluded to from all the information I can learn. Beg to suggest that Captain King be called upon to substantiate or at once withdraw and apologize for the... language.‖23 ‗Beg‘ was a good choice of words—the chances of Durie and MacDougall dragging the one-legged hero Captain King before a court-martial for his choice of language without raising a stink in the press were slim to none. MacDougall‘s letter to Captain King was no doubt diplomatic and full of hope and suggestion that perhaps the press had exaggerated King‘s remarks and that the captain might be predisposed to assure everyone that as upset as he was with losing his leg, surely he did not go as far as accusing Lt. Colonel Dennis of cowardice.

Perhaps he misspoke in the excitement of his return home at Port Robinson, and the press was exaggerating the extent of his remarks.

Dennis to Durie, August 15, 1866: Adjutant General‘s Correspondence; Correspondence relating to complaints, courts martial and inquiries, RG9-I-C-8, Volume 7, LAC Dennis to Durie, August 15, 1866 Dennis to Durie, August 15, 1866 Captain King‘s defiant response to MacDougall‘s letter dashed all such hopes

–  –  –

Michel was clearly frustrated. There must have been a marshalling of opinion as to how to silence King, including a proposal to court-martial him. On September 6 on the back of King‘s reply Michel penned

–  –  –

Everything humanly and bureaucratically possible to avoid another Court of Inquiry into yet another officer‘s command was being done.

King to MacDougall, August 22, 1866, Adjutant General‘s Correspondence; Correspondence relating to complaints, courts martial and inquiries, RG9-I-C-8, Volume 7, LAC King to MacDougall, August 22, 1866 Dennis in the meantime had gotten wind that Denison was to publish in August his history of the Fenian invasion. He invited Denison to visit him in his Toronto offices to discuss the contents of his upcoming book. Dennis and Denison had a long history. Denison had known Dennis since childhood—Dennis was his senior by nineteen years. Dennis had been a junior officer in Denison‘s father‘s cavalry troop and artillery, where according to Denison he did not distinguish himself. He would later describe Dennis as ―useless as a soldier. He was an ambitious man, carefully anxious not to let any opportunities pass him.‖26 While serving under Peacocke, Denison upon hearing from him of how Dennis and Akers took off on their own mission, impetuously burst out that they both should be arrested.

According to Denison, Peacocke replied, ―Dennis is not a soldier and did not know any better, and he is a volunteer officer and it would look as if I was trying to make a scapegoat of him to save myself.‖27 Denison felt that as a result of Peacocke‘s discretion, the British officer had now himself become a scapegoat for the Fenian escape from Fort Erie.

Now Dennis begged Denison to defend his reputation in his upcoming book. Dennis reminded him that they were old friends and brother volunteer officers and should stand by one another. Denison claims he replied that he must ―write an honest, true book or not write one at all.‖ According to Denison‘s 1901 memoir, he was later visited by an unnamed emissary who likewise urged him to defend Dennis‘s conduct at Fort Erie. Denison in his memoir, framed the dilemma as a question of defending Peacocke‘s reputation, rather than necessarily condemning that of Dennis and indeed his history includes a chapter defending Peacocke.28 By the time Denison‘s The Fenian Raid on Fort Erie was published in August, it was only mildly critical of Dennis compared to the accusations coming from McCallum and King.

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 42 | 43 || 45 | 46 |   ...   | 52 |

Similar works:

«Ministering to the people of Northern and Western Alaska Diocese of Fairbanks May 2016 Volume 21 Number 5 Featured Stories Pope Francis’ Apostolic Exhortation Clergy Summer Assignments Alaska Catholic Youth Conference Profile of Fr. John Hinsvark Safe Environment Discerment House to Open Young Adults Retreat Y-K Region Resources Bulletin Resources Diocesan Calendar A Sense of History Rosalie L’Ecuyer ~1~ Bishop & Diocesan Diocesan Mission Statement Calendar We are people of God in the Roman...»

«Studia Judaica 18 (2015), nr 1 (35), s. 85–104 doi: 10.4467/24500100STJ.15.005.3888 Ela Bauer “We Call Him Mister (Pan) Editor”:* Nahum Sokolow and Modern Hebrew Literature Abstract: This paper presents the tasks and aims that Nahum Sokolow believed Hebrew literature should have in Jewish life and in the Jewish national movement. Before his official joining the Zionist movement, Sokolow believed that the contribution of Hebrew literature to the formation of Jewish nationalism was more...»

«IV. Accounting and Auditing Standards T his chapter describes the accounting and auditing standards that govern the preparation of external financial reports and the audit of those reports. It is structured as follows: Part One: Accounting Standards 1 – Introduction – reviews the historical development of Indonesian accounting standards. 2 – Financial Accounting Standards Board (DSAK) – outlines the role and composition of DSAK, the primary accounting standardsetting body. 3 –...»

«Chapter 4 Monsters in the Closet: Biopolitics and Intersexuality Nadia Guidotto Introduction Hermaphrodites, Amazons, and lascivious cannibals beckon from the edges of the world, the most distant planets of the galaxy. (Cohen, 1996, p. 19) Science fiction is replete with freakish creatures designed to haunt, intrigue and forewarn. Each night, parents console their children after a grim bedtime story or scary movie, assuring them that “monsters aren’t real.” The truth is, however, that...»

«Animal Adaptations There is a tremendous diversity among the world’s animals, and they live nearly everywhere, from high above the tree line to hydrothermal vents at the bottom of the sea. There are approximately 1.3 million named species of animals, but we don’t really know how many are yet to be discovered. One estimate is that we may have as many as 30 million animal species, leaving the vast majority of the earth’s biodiversity still to be discovered. An animal’s shape, size, and...»

«Overmountain Men: The Militia Leaders that Defeated Patrick Ferguson At King's Mountain Michael Whitton/ 31415 Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the requirements for the Bachelor of Arts Degree major in History October 5tn 2006 Overmountain Men: The Militia Leaders that Defeated Patrick Ferguson At King's Mountain Michael Whitton Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the requirements for the Bachelor of Arts Degree major in History October 5th 2006 Abstract: The Battle of King's Mountain has...»

«Emmanuel Dumont Rapport Cindyniques Julien Tressol Etude de cas : Risques Naturels LES CRUES DU TARN LA CRUE DE 1930 Le Tarn à Montauban Tuteur : M. Lucien Coste. Tuteur école : Eric Piatyszek 1/35 Emmanuel Dumont Rapport Cindyniques Julien Tressol Etude de cas : Risques Naturels Sommaire INTRODUCTION I. Historique des crues du Tarn I.1. Définitions : généralités sur les crues I.1.1. Généralités I.1.2. Les grands types de crues I.2. Caractéristiques du Tarn I.2.1. Conditions...»

«Guide to Processed Collections in the University Archives Introduction The Brigham Young University Archives preserves records documenting the history of the university and its people as well as their impact on the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and society. This guide describes the processed collections housed by the University Archives. A processed collection is one that has been rehoused and carefully described with either a catalog record or a finding aid or, in many cases,...»

«EBSCOhost http://web.ebscohost.com.ezproxy.lib.uts.edu.au/ehost/delivery?vid=7&h. Back 7 page(s) will be printed. Record: 1 Melbourne: In and out of my class.Title: Lack, John Authors: Australian Historical Studies; Oct97, Vol. 28 Issue 109, p158, 8p, 1bw Source: Article Document Type: CITY & town life Subject Terms: FAMILY VICTORIA Geographic Terms: MELBOURNE (Vic.) Reflects on an individual's life growing up in Melbourne, Victoria during the Abstract: 1950s. Description of the town where the...»

«Murder Trial of a Sex Psychopath: The Construction of Homosexuality in Mid-Twentieth Century America By Ari Worthman Submitted to Professors Lisa Jane Graham, Paul Jefferson, and Bethel Saler in partial fulfillment of the requirements for History 400: Senior Thesis Seminar. April 22, 2002 Contents Acknowledgements Introduction, 1 Chapter 1 The American Landscape in 1949, 9 Chapter 2 The Trial Begins, 17 Chapter 3 Seymour’s Story, 30 Chapter 4 The Emergence of the Sexual Psychopath in...»

«The Crime Thriller in Context Kate Watson As this book collection attests, the thriller is a wide-ranging category. As this chapter will show (and summarize), the subgenre of the crime thriller has a large corpus and different national traditions, and, consequently, it does not have a singular literary or national history. Crime thriller narratives can be found across many mediums, including literature, television, graphic novels, and film. Added to this, there are many sub-genres of the...»


<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.