FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 3 | 4 || 6 | 7 |   ...   | 20 |


-- [ Page 5 ] --

Third, we included a self-addressed, stamped return envelope and also gave respondents the option of faxing the completed survey. Fourth, we instituted a tracking system and mailed a reminder postcard to those departments we had not heard from after three weeks from the original survey mailing date. After we reasoned that the response rate from the postcards was saturated and survey responses had dwindled, we sent a second letter to the chief of police or sheriff. He, or she, was asked to check a box if they did not have a policy/protocol requiring officers to investigate if children were exposed to domestic violence and return the survey. If they require officers to ask if children were exposed to domestic violence, they were asked to complete the original survey or contact us for another survey if the original was lost. A total of 495 law enforcement departments were mailed surveys and 360 were returned. The response rate was high, 73 percent.


Policy and Laws Regarding Children Exposed to Domestic Violence The majority of departments (72%) indicated that they have a policy or protocol that requires officers to investigate whether any children were exposed to domestic violence. Under what circumstances would officers investigate to determine if children were exposed to domestic violence? Most respondents (62%) said they would investigate every time an officer responds to a domestic violence scene. A minority (19%) said officers would investigate only if children were present when the officer arrived. Another eight percent said officers would investigate whether children were exposed to domestic violence only if there was some evidence (e.g., toys, cribs, car seats, etc.) that children reside in the house. The remaining 11 percent said it would depend. On what? Some of the responses noted were: if the children were witnesses to the violence; if children were in harm’s way; if children were old enough to verbalize what happened; and if the officer observed something at the scene to trigger inquiring about children being exposed to domestic violence (Table 1).

We asked respondents if there is a law or written policy that requires officers to document that a child was exposed to domestic violence. Most often (40% of the time), it is required by written policy; less often (25% of the time), it is required by law; 11 percent of the time, it is required by both law and policy; and less than one-quarter (24%) said it is required neither by law nor policy (Table 1).

–  –  –

Ninety-one percent of the respondents reported that officers are required to write a narrative describing how children were exposed to domestic violence (e.g., they overheard it, witnessed it, were used as a shield, or intervened to stop it). Most often, 79 percent of the time, it is included in the incident report. The next most common place to narrate this information (52% of the time) is in the supplemental report (the supplemental report, like the incident report, is not subject to public scrutiny). Forty-six percent noted the narrative appears in the arrest report and the remaining 20 percent said it “depends” on things such as: if the child was a witness; if the child was at risk; if it was relevant to the facts of the case; if the child was injured; and/or on the child’s age (Table 1).

Nature of Response to Children Exposed to Domestic Violence

What do officers do when they learn that children were exposed to domestic violence? The most common response, given by 56 percent of the respondents, was that they notify child protective services. In descending order of frequency, other answers were that they make a referral to a social service agency (44%); 35 percent intervene in “another” way (such as refer the case to a detective; notify school counselors; call a child abuse hotline; arrest the offending parent); 24 percent call a helping agency on the phone; 16 percent call a helping agency to the scene; and 12 percent respond to the scene along with a helping agency (Table 2).

There are a variety of ways in which officers can enlist the help of agencies to assist children with the trauma that accompanies being exposed to domestic violence. Some ways are more proactive than others; thus, they are more time intensive and expensive. The least expensive intervention is to do nothing at all. Nearly one-quarter of our respondents reported that they do not even have a policy requiring officers to find out if children are exposed to domestic violence. If they do, officers may hand the non-offending parent a pamphlet, or card, that explains what services are available, or officers may contact a helping agency for the nonoffending parent so that they can explain the services available to the child.

–  –  –

Several police departments have programs designed to help children who have witnessed domestic and community violence. Often these programs are the result of a partnership between the police department and a service provider.

• Example. In one jurisdiction, a new intervention program had just started to assist children exposed to violence. Officers carry laminated cards instructing them on what to do when a child has been exposed to family or community violence. The card explains to the officer that police officers are often the first responders for these children and it is critical that the officer takes advantage of the intervention program. The card tells the officer how to explain that witnessing violence is very serious and that children may need help dealing with it. It instructs the officer to give out information on the impact of witnessing violence to the families and to encourage the family to participate in the program. If the family is receptive to participation in the program, then the officer calls the program and makes a referral. Officers are notified in writing when the program contacts families.

• Example. A program run by the local police department and the community services board has a brochure that officers give to parents whose child has witnessed violence. The brochure assists parents by giving tips on signs to look for after their child has witnessed violence, what to expect of their child after witnessing a violent incident, how to help the child, and how to take advantage of the services provided by the program. If parents are interested in receiving help, they complete an attached form and return it to the officer. Parents are informed that a child specialist will contact them within 24 to 48 hours. The child specialist will conduct an interview and assessment. Based upon this, they make appropriate referrals.

Parents are told the services provided by the program are confidential and are given a number to call if they would like to contact the program directly.

A more time-consuming, proactive approach is for the officers to call a counselor from a helping agency to the scene to provide assistance. This may require the officer to remain on the scene until the counselor arrives to ensure the counselor’s and family’s safety. The most costly approach is for counselors to be on-call to respond to the scene with the officer. This approach is costly for the agency and may take the officer off call for some period of time while awaiting the counselor’s arrival. We asked how often the latter happens (i.e., how often the officer is accompanied to the scene by a child-centered or domestic violence agency). The response categories for six different agencies were “always,” “often,” “sometimes,” “seldom,” and “never.” The results are displayed in Table 2.

Looking at the results, it is interesting to note that of the five agencies we directly asked about, in less than five percent of the time do these agencies “always” go to the scene with officers (although respondents told us that 17 percent of the time they “always” go with an “other” agency not named by us — more about this later). Combining the “often” and “sometimes” responses, 45 percent of the time child protective services workers accompany officers; 33 percent of the time non-profit victim advocates accompany; 29 percent of the time victimwitness staff from law enforcement or the prosecutor’s office accompany; eight percent of the time counselors from hospital-based programs accompany; and six percent of the time school counselors accompany (Table 2). Many respondents named “other” agencies that “always” (17%), “often” (10%), or “sometimes” (68%) accompany them to the scene. These included crisis center workers, shelter staff, mental health centers, clergy, and volunteers.

• Example. A jurisdiction surveyed had a policy specifically for children who witness a violent or traumatic incident. The purpose of the policy was to provide children (under 18 years) who witness violence (or traumatic incidents) with immediate counseling and follow-up treatment. Upon arriving at the scene, the officer first determines if the child (1) witnessed a violent incident and (2) is under 18 years of age. If so, the officer contacts a supervisor and the dispatch center is advised of the situation and relays that information to a response team.

The officer remains on the scene until the team arrives or, if necessary, removes the child to an appropriate place and meets the team there. Once the team arrives, the officer briefs the team on the situation and remains on the scene until appropriate action has been taken by the team. When time permits, the initial responding officer completes a form to notify a juvenile officer. Juvenile detectives follow-up with the response team to check on the condition of the child. The Juvenile Bureau maintains a confidential file on the incident and of the team’s initial involvement.

A less proactive outreach, but still a very important mechanism for helping children exposed to domestic violence, is for officers to refer the non-offending parent to agencies with programs for these types of children. Respondents more often reported that officers make referrals than that officers were accompanied to the scene by a helping agency. Among the five agencies we queried about, 34 percent of respondents reported that officers “always” and 54 percent “often” or “sometimes” make referrals to child protective services; 25 percent “always” refer to law enforcement or prosecutor’s victim witness staff and 48 percent “often” or “sometimes” do; 14 percent “always ” refer to non-profit victim advocates and 55 percent “often” or “sometimes” do; two percent “always” refer to school counselors and 26 percent “often” or “sometimes” do;

two percent “always” refer to counselors from a hospital-based program and 24 percent “often” or “sometimes” do (Table 2). Again, many respondents named “other” agencies they refer to not included in our list — 34 percent “always” refer to another agency and 63 percent “often” or “sometimes” do. These agencies included crisis units, religious groups, the YWCA, special units within the police department, mental health professionals, domestic violence shelters, and abuse hotlines.

• Example. In one county, a new process has been developed for domestic violence calls in which there are children under 16 years of age in the home. The officer encourages the parent to sign a parental consent form for domestic violence intervention. The consent form states the parent agrees that school personnel can offer support and education to his or her child regarding domestic violence. School personnel are defined as a guidance counselor, social worker, school psychologist, mental health counselor, nurse, and/or school resource officer. The form includes the parent’s name and signature, the child’s or children’s names, the name of the school, the officer’s name, and the date of the incident.

It is one thing to make referrals, it is another to follow-up and see if the children actually received any services. There are many reasons why non-offending parents may not reach out for help for their children. They may feel ashamed or guilty; be too upset with their victimization to pursue help for the children (or to even comprehend what the officer is saying just minutes after they were assaulted); fear reprisals from the abuser if they seek help for the children; think it is hopeless; not have the financial means to pay for services (even if services are free, transportation costs or taking time off from work can be serious inhibitors to getting help); and/or receive resistance from their children about going somewhere for help. If all the children who need help are to obtain it, follow-up by professionals is critical. We asked respondents if anyone follows up with the non-offending parent. Over one-third said follow-up happens (Table 2).

Funding Sources and Model Approaches The vast majority, (85%) of departments, receives no special funding to respond to children exposed to domestic violence (Table 3). Of the 15 percent who have (or had) special funding, the source was overwhelmingly the federal government through the Community Oriented Policing (COPS) Office and the Violence Against Women Office, although a few attributed the source to state or private funds. Most often the funding for children exposed to domestic violence was included in broader general funding for domestic violence. For example, the funding might be used for a victim advocate who is available to counsel the victim’s children in addition to the victim. Funding sizes ranged from a total of $20,000 to over $2,000,000 with some departments noting more than one source of funding. Funds were primarily used to staff special units (with victim advocates, investigators, specially trained officers, and so on) or for specialized response teams for domestic violence cases.

–  –  –

When asked if the respondent considered their department’s approach to children exposed to domestic violence to be a “model” for the country, 31 percent said it was (Table 3). We asked them to briefly describe what they perceived as innovative and helpful about their response. We received an impressive account of many different types of programs. We cannot include each one here, but provide four examples to illustrate the breadth and scope of what departments are doing with community partners to help children exposed to domestic violence.

• Case Example One. This case example comes from a sheriff’s department in the Northwest.

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 3 | 4 || 6 | 7 |   ...   | 20 |

Similar works:

«The Hope Speech Harvey Milk (1978) COMMENTARY The tolerance of society for variety of sexual practices and love within sexual identifications has varied through Western civilization. Generally, the culture in the United States has classified such variety as abnormal. The most common basis for such classification has been religious, citing the condemnation of homosexuality in the Bible. But, in addition, the culture has gone through times when normativity in all aspects of life was simply more...»

«Copyleft and the GNU General Public License: A Comprehensive Tutorial and Guide c Copyright 2003–2005, 2008, 2014–2015 Bradley M. Kuhn. c Copyright 2014–2015 Anthony K. Sebro, Jr. c Copyright 2014 Denver Gingerich. c Copyright 2003–2007, 2014 Free Software Foundation, Inc. c Copyright 2008, 2014 Software Freedom Law Center. The copyright holders grant the freedom to copy, modify, convey, adapt, and/or redistribute this work (except Appendices B–E) under the terms of the Creative...»

«TITLE 30MINERAL LANDS AND MINING CHAPTER 2MINERAL LANDS AND REGULATIONS IN GENERAL Sec. 22. Lands open to purchase by citizens Except as otherwise provided, all valuable mineral deposits in lands belonging to the United States, both surveyed and unsurveyed, shall be free and open to exploration and purchase, and the lands in which they are found to occupation and purchase, by citizens of the United States and those who have declared their intention to become such, under regulations prescribed...»

«Pursuant to Ind. Appellate Rule 65(D), this Memorandum Decision shall not be regarded as precedent or cited before any court except for the purpose of establishing the defense of res judicata, collateral estoppel, or the law of the case.ATTORNEY FOR APPELLANT ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLEE: MICHAEL R. FISHER GREGORY F. ZOELLER Marion County Public Defender Agency Attorney General of Indiana Indianapolis, Indiana KATHERINE MODESITT COOPER Deputy Attorney General Indianapolis, Indiana FILED Jan 31 2012,...»

«RFP-852 REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL Fiber Optic Network Asset Management Software Due Date: March 20, 2013, 2:00 P.M. City of Ann Arbor, Michigan 301 E. Huron St. Ann Arbor, MI 48107-8647 TABLE OF CONTENTS SECTION I: General Information..3 SECTION II: Background and General Description of Requirements.8 SECTION III: Scope of Work..12 SECTION IV: Information Required From All Proposal Respondents.20 SECTION V: Appendices..23 Appendix A – Legal Status of Respondent..24 Appendix B – Example of...»

«One Hundred Fifth Annual Commencement JUNE EXERCISES THE UNIVERSITY OF NOTRE DAME NOTRE DAME, INDIANA THE GRADUATE ScHooL THE CoLLEGE OF ARTS AND LETTERS THE,CoLLEGE OF SciENCE THE CoLLEGE OF ENGINEERING THE CoLLEGE OF LAw THE CoLLEGE OF CoMMERCE In the University Stadium At 2:00 p.m. (Central Daylight Time} June 4, 1950.r. ~. PROGRAM Processional Presentation of the Laetare Medal, to General Joseph Lawton Collins, U.S.A., Chief of Staff, United States Army The Conferring of Degrees, by the...»

«Planning Accessible Meetings and Events A TOOLKIT Overview Planning fully accessible meetings and events might at first glance seem overwhelming, but with proper planning can become second nature. An effective approach begins with raising planners’ awareness of disability diversity within the legal profession, as well as the barriers that limit or preclude participation by persons with disabilities. During a lifetime, most everyone is likely to experience a disability, whether due to aging, a...»

«Buying a Home in Scotland 45 Our objective is to improve the scope We aim to: and quality of housing information • identify and meet the needs of consumers and advice throughout Scotland.• improve the standard of housing information and advice provision. HomePoint has an advisory committee with members drawn from a variety of backgrounds, including housing and consumer information, local authorities, voluntary agencies, legal, technical and financial organisations Published by HomePoint...»

«ILC.100/IV/1 A International Labour Conference, 100th Session, 2011 Report IV(1) Decent work for domestic workers Fourth item on the agenda International Labour Office Geneva ISBN 978-92-2-123103-5 (print) ISBN 978-92-2-123104-2 (Web pdf) ISSN 0074-6681 First edition 2010 The designations employed in ILO publications, which are in conformity with United Nations practice, and the presentation of material therein do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the...»

«Searching for Balance – Balance in Searching The Law on Search Incidental to Arrest and Strip Searches   Beverley Lane ‐  Crown Counsel Surrey, BC  4/16/2012    8. Everyone has the right to be secure against unreasonable search or seizure Achieving an appropriate balance between the power of police to search and the rights of individual citizens to be free from unreasonable search is vital to our criminal justice system. Viewed more broadly this is an important facet of the...»

«Narrowing the “Justice Gap”: Roles for Nonlawyer Practitioners COMMITTEE ON PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY JUNE 2013 NEW YORK CITY BAR ASSOCIATION 42 WEST 44TH STREET, NEW YORK, NY 10036 Table of Contents Page Introduction.. 1 I. The Justice Gap.. 4 II. A. The Need Is Extreme B. Current Efforts By the Legal Profession Are Valuable and Deserve Support, But Much More Is Needed The private bar‟s pro bono efforts 1. 2. The civil legal aid bar 3. Court facilities 4. Law school developments 5....»

«Change and Decay in All Around I See The Decline of Western Capitalism is a Fascinating Spectacle. Make some popcorn and follow along here!Deep Background & Setup: A lot of the basis for the current Crisis was laid long ago, and there were many warning shots across the bow. If you're not a conneiseur of financial failure and treachery, you might not be aware of these things. I'll catch you up on the high points. Monday 3/28/94 Derivative Surprise! With exquisite timing, Matt starts at Hercules...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.