WWW.DISSERTATION.XLIBX.INFO
FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials
 
<< HOME
CONTACTS



Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 13 | 14 || 16 | 17 |   ...   | 35 |

«Andrés Gregor Zelman The University of Amsterdam 2002 ii Mediated Communication and the Evolving Science System: Mapping the Network Architecture of ...»

-- [ Page 15 ] --

From the analysis of the four query words: Firms, Organization, Project, and Task, additional information concerning their distribution over the dataset was gained. The keyword Firms is shown to occur with a high frequency in both the second and final time periods, and this distribution is mirrored when measured for its standardized mean (every 1000 words). The distribution of the other three keywords selected for the analysis differs slightly. Organization, for example, occurred with a similar frequency across the first three documents sets and increased in the fourth, while when compared for standardized distribution across the four documents the terms appear more central to the first and third document sets. By contrast, the keywords Project and Task were shown to have varying distributions across the document sets while the standardized mean shows a different distribution. Project appears to be a central term in the first and final documents, but when standardized it is shown to be used more in the first and third document sets. Likewise, the keyword Task appears to be central to the first and final documents, but when standardized the distribution suggested that it was particularly central to the first and third time periods. These distributions give an immediate sense of the cognitive priorities of each time period.

In what follows, a contextualization of these words using their central neighbourhood collocates will serve to isolate the ways that each of these terms were used. As argued 10 The visual comparison between the four query words can be viewed in Appendix A.6 65 in the Research Questions & Expectations section of this chapter, textual analysis computing tools alone cannot locate associate words (words which are linked to keywords by cognitive association), but it is possible to use such tools to locate neighbourhood keywords. Here the isolation of keywords and their central collocates aimed to locate the ‘sub-symbolic’ meaning of words which remains contingent on the association between them. The key collocates of each Query word were isolated using the WordSmith program. From these occurrences, ten to twelve words were selected for display below. Once isolated, a further selection was made of two key collocates to identify which words are associated with the query words.11 Again, the full results can be viewed in Appendix A.6. The selected collocates for each keyword, and its successive co-collocates are shown below in four figures: Figure 4.1: ‘Firms’

Collocate Analysis, Figure 4.2: ‘Organization’ Collocate Analysis, Figure 4.3:

‘Project’ Collocate Analysis, and Figure 4.4: ‘Task’ Collocate Analysis.

This collocate analysis isolated an interesting set of neighbourhood keywords for the word Firms, including: Institutions, and Network(s). When the keyword and these collocate words were used together as the search terms, an additional level of specification was achieved. Here, when Firms and Institutions were used as the query words, only the words Network and Networks were identified. When Firms, Network, and Networks were searched together, only the words Small and Institutions were found. This approach gives us a clear sense of the structure of the discourse surrounding the use of the term Firms in print communication of the SOEIS project.

When the keyword Organization was examined for its neighbourhood collocates, a self evident grouping of words was identified. From these collocates, the words 11 The words in italics are the keywords selected from each collocate list for the deeper analysis 66 Project and Task were selected for the deeper analysis. Not surprisingly, when Organization and Project were queried together the words Self, Information, and Society were identified. These words were central to the project and are indeed, title words of the research project itself. When Organization and Task were queried together, the words Self and Modeling arose. The word Self is to be expected given its link with the word Organization. The word Modeling, while not exhibiting a high frequency as a collocate to the search terms Organization and Task, was identified as key suggesting that the word played a particular role in the print communications of the SOEIS project. Modeling is understood here to represent a link between the words Organization and Task that might otherwise escape unnoticed. All three words connote a processual concern with the carrying out of the project tasks.

When the keyword Project was analyzed for its collocates a wide range of neighbourhood words were identified. From these, the words Results and SOEIS were selected for the deeper analysis, as they concern the SOIES project and its motivation.

When a search was performed on the keyword Project and the word Results in tandem, the words Entire, Research and Dissemination were identified as the central neighbourhood collocates. While the significance of the word Entire in this distribution remains conjectural, the words Research and Dissemination are clearly cognitively connected with the keyword Project and this analysis thereby reveals the importance of these terms to each other – to the operation of the SOEIS project, and to the composition of the print communication dataset itself. When Project and SOEIS were sought together the words Organization, Task, and HTTP arose. The relationship between these words and the keyword Project is clear – here the orientation of these words to each other reveals a collective cognitive orientation of the SOEIS members to the function words: Task and Organization.





67 Finally, the fourth collocate query performed in this analysis used Task as the query keyword. Of the resulting neighbourhood collocates the words Project and Policy were selected for further analysis. When Task and Project where used as the query terms the words SOEIS, work, and deliverable arose. The relationship between these types of words is clear – each are oriented toward the processual aspect of the carrying on of the research project. Similarly, when Task and Policy where queried together the words Implications, Research and European were revealed. These latter words are also processually, rather than conceptually, oriented.

The collocate analysis of the four keywords: Firms, Organization, Project and Task has revealed a networked interconnectivity between keywords and their neighbourhood collocates. Interestingly, the words isolated as important to the SOEIS project (Firms and Organization) tend to have conceptual words as their collocates, whereas the words selected on the basis of importance for the functioning of the SOEIS project tend to have process oriented words as their collocates.

Combined these analyses reveal a unity across the sets in that most words occur in the final document set providing another indicator of an ‘aggregating text’. The emergent text is shown to accumulate over the time periods. The network dimensions of the SOEIS research group and their collective print output can thereby be understood to serve an archival function. With respect to the theoretical triad, the architecture of the print communications has been sketched in with a complex network of interrelations.

By observing the fluctuations of keyword use, when compared as a time series, discernable networks of keyword usage were revealed. Similarly, and in light of Actor Network Theory, the collocate analysis revealed interrelationships between networked keywords. The analysis of the SOEIS print communication has revealed networked keyword use over the document set, but whether these are properties particular to the print medium will be more easily discernable once compared with the electronic communication database.

System The analysis of the systemic properties of the SOEIS print communication is described below and provides an interesting juxtaposition to the network analysis in that the print behaviour of the SOEIS participants is conceptualized differently. Here the communications are viewed collectively as an overall system. Both the linear and non-linear relationships between the wordlists for each time period are compared.

The examination of the dataset for system transformation entails an assessment of the texts for critical transitions or path dependencies over the four datasets.12 Here we measure the expected information content of each time period, as each related to the previous period or state of the communication. The analysis was performed on two levels. The first made the comparison on the shared occurrence of all words present the full reference corpus – Print All: 7627 words. The print document set was first checked for linear transitions between P1-P2, P2-P3, and P3-P4, and was then 12 Callon 1986 – Path dependency is interpreted as ‘obligatory passage points’ (Leydesdorff, 1995:100). An obligatory passage point from A through B to C is found if: AB+BCAC; in contrast, no path dependency is found if AB+BCAC.

68 compared for non-linear associations; namely, P1-P3, P1-P4, and P2-P4. The results are presented below in Figure 4.5: Four Time Periods Compared Linearly (7627 words) and Figure 4.6: Four Time Periods Compared Non-Linearly (7627 words).

–  –  –

.614.355 (1355) (1070)

–  –  –

The linear and non-linear relationships are compared in the following way. Linearly, between the first and second periods.509 bits of information was shared, and between the second and third time periods.453 bits of information was shared. To determine if the pathway between period one and period three involved a critical revision of the information (via period two), we look to the bits of information shared non-linearly between periods one and three (.355 bits of information). If the total bits of information shared between periods one and two, and between two and three is less that the bits of information shared non-linearly between periods one and three then period two can be understood to have entailed a critical revision of the information, and was thereby critical for the development of the shared information (by boosting the previous signal). When compared for the degree of continuity between the time periods no significant difference was found between the linear relationships (P1-P2, P2-P3, P3-P4), and the non-linear relationships (P1-P3, P1-P4, P2-P4). However, note that since the time periods do not contain the same amount of words shared between the time periods (for example, 1828 words were shared between periods one and two, and 1214 words between periods two and three) the calculation is presented with a division by zero.13 The solution to this problematic is found by comparing only the shared words between the four time periods. Using this additional level of specification, the word lists were compared on the basis of the words that were shared by all four texts – Print Shared: 1009 words. The results are presented below in

Figure 4.7: Four Time Periods Compared Linearly (1009 words) and Figure 4.8:

Four Time Periods Compared Non-Linearly (1009 words).

13 Zero creates a problem because it doesn’t occur as a predictor. Leydesdorff argues that given the formula for the expected information value (I = Σ qi 2log (qi / pi)), we are “confronted with the division by zero in the case of the emergence of a ‘new’ occurrence in the a posteriori text” (1995:94). For Information Theory this means that the ‘appearance of something which was predicted with certainty not to occur (p = 0) comes as a total surprise, so that this message has infinite expected information value.’ (ibid:94).

–  –  –

Again, when compared for the degree of continuity between time periods no significant difference was found between the linear and non-linear relationships.

Thus, contrary to the original expectation, the results do not show any evidence of critical revision or transition in the collective word use of the authors. This suggests that there was no fundamental reorganization of the word usage during the course of the research project.14 However, this may also be interpreted to reflect a fundamental quality of collaborative research projects: that they are well organized and codified into particular discourses. As isolated by the standardized ratio of the percentage of unique words as isolated in the architecture analysis, the SOEIS print communications appear to have a lot of continuity.

Since no critical transitions were found in this analysis, a more detailed examination of the four respective wordlists for overall word distribution was performed in order to further test the expectation that self-organizational properties could be discerned.

Where the previous analysis concerned the overall distribution of collective (and thereby systemic) patterns of word use, here we look again to the architectural parameters of information flow present in this mode of communication to aid the interpretation of the systemic analysis. The analysis measures for both Specificity and Transmission. Specificity is understood as the specificity of total word distribution, or more accurately: the ratio of the expected information content of the distribution relative to the maximum information content. Specificity is therefore a measure of the degree to which some words occur differently across the print dataset along the time dimension. By contrast, Transmission is the coupling of word distribution and the time dimension; it is the mutual information between word distributions over the time periods and is understood to reflect a reduction of the uncertainty (specificity): it is

thereby a measure of the flow of mutual information across the dataset. Table 4.6:

Print System Dynamics, below, shows the overall word Occurrence, Unique Words, Specificity, and Transmission of the print dataset.15 14 The path dependencies tested within the print database do differ from the electronic; in the next chapter we compare the print and electronic databases for relative similarities and differences.

15 The occurrence and unique word counts shown in Table 4.6: Print System Dynamics are different than the occurrence and unique word rates found in the architecture analysis above; this difference is because for this analysis the texts were pre-filtered using the stop-list.



Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 13 | 14 || 16 | 17 |   ...   | 35 |


Similar works:

«International Medieval Congress 2015 – Academic Programme 6-9 July 2015 Last updated: 04 July 2015, 11:00 MONDAY 06 JULY 2015: 09.00-10.30 Session: 1 KEYNOTE ONLY Great Hall Title: KEYNOTE LECTURES 2015: BEYOND NATIONAL NARRATIVES: CULTURE, STATES, AND REFRAMING ‘GREGORIAN’ REFORM (LANGUAGE: ENGLISH) SPACES OF REFORM?: URBAN RENEWAL AND THE SHAPING OF CITIES IN MEDIEVAL EUROPE (LANGUAGE: ENGLISH) Purpose: Beyond National Narratives: Culture, States, and Reframing ‘Gregorian’ Reform...»

«P.A.N.D.A. Prevent Abuse and Neglect through Dental Awareness “PANDA” is an acronym for “Prevent Abuse and Neglect Through Dental Awareness”. P.A.N.D.A. Recognition and Reporting of Child Abuse and Neglect It is a program that has been developed to help dentists and dental staff members recognize some of the signs and symptoms of child abuse and neglect. It also addresses the reporting process involved when cases of child abuse and neglect are detected. Mission Statement To create an...»

«Minutes of Commission Meeting University of California at San Diego Scripps Seaside Forum, 8610 Kennel Way La Jolla, California May 12, 2016 Members Present Members Absent Timothy Strack, Chairman Anthony Cannella Tracy Johnson, Vice Chair Ken Cooley Greg Beroza Randall Goodwin Michael Gardner Kit Miyamoto Ryan Arba (for Mark Ghilarducci) Ian Parkinson Peggy Hellweg Chet Widom Helen Knudson Mia Miravelli Staff Present David Rabbitt Fuad Sweiss Richard McCarthy, Executive Director Mark Wheetley...»

«Presentation of the funded projects in 2010 for the ARPEGE Programme Page AEOLUS – Managing the complexity of the cloud 3 ARMS – A multi arms robotic system for muscle separation 4 BMOS – Biometric matching on smartcard 5 CERCLES2 – Compositional certification of critical and safe embedded 6 software COROUSSO – Modelling and control of robots for machining operations of 7 large composite parts and friction stir welding EMAISECI – Electro-magnetic analysis and injection of secure...»

«MBIA Annual Report 2003 Capital Strength Triple-A Performance Pat Abt, Connie Accordino, Neil Ackerman, Joseph Adelizzi, Seth Albert, Angelique Allen, James Allen, Keith Allman, Mike Alter, Eric Anderson, Peter Andreou, Hector Angulo, John Antonazzo, Gina Antonelli, Brian Arcese, Ana Areal, John Ariola, Craig Armstrong, Errol Arne, Suresh Arumilli, Greer Avery, Dan Avitabile, Harold Bailey, Judy Baiocco, Michael Ballinger, Frances Banuelos, Ann Barbara, Mary Barbara, Lorraine Barg, Steve...»

«Guidance note: Statutory Residence Test (SRT) Published August 2016 RDR3 Table of Contents Introduction How to navigate between links in this document RDR3 updates August 2016 1. Statutory residence test the basic rule Automatic overseas tests First automatic overseas test Second automatic overseas test Third automatic overseas test Do you work full-time overseas? Gaps between employments What other days can reduce the reference period? Annual leave and parenting leave What are reasonable...»

«The University of Birmingham Automated joining of cuneiform tablet fragments Gehlken, Erlend; Woolley, Sandra; Collins, Timothy; Ch'ng, Eugene Document Version Publisher's PDF, also known as Version of record Citation for published version (Harvard): Gehlken, E, Woolley, S, Collins, T & Ch'ng, E 2014, 'Automated joining of cuneiform tablet fragments' NABU Nouvelles Assyriologiques Breves et Utilitaires, vol 2014, no. 4, 73, pp. 119-120. Link to publication on Research at Birmingham portal...»

«PETROLEUM GEOPOLITICS : A FRAMEWORK OF ANALYSIS Rupert Herbert-Burns A Thesis Submitted for the Degree of PhD at the University of St Andrews 2012 Full metadata for this item is available in Research@StAndrews:FullText at: http://research-repository.st-andrews.ac.uk/ Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://hdl.handle.net/10023/4035 This item is protected by original copyright Petroleum Geopolitics: A Framework of Analysis Rupert Herbert-Burns A Thesis Submitted for the...»

«MINIMALITY AND FIBER SUM DECOMPOSITIONS OF LEFSCHETZ FIBRATIONS ˙ R. INANC BAYKUR ¸ Abstract. We give a short proof of a conjecture of Stipsicz on the minimality of fiber sums of Lefschetz fibrations, which was proved earlier by Usher. We then construct the first examples of genus g ≥ 2 Lefschetz fibrations on minimal symplectic 4-manifolds which, up to diffeomorphisms of the summands, admit unique decompositions as fiber sums. 1. Introduction Despite the spectacular advancement in...»

«SERIES IZA DP No. 6843 PAPER Does Emigration Benefit the Stayers? Evidence from EU Enlargement Benjamin Elsner DISCUSSION September 2012 Forschungsinstitut zur Zukunft der Arbeit Institute for the Study of Labor Does Emigration Benefit the Stayers? Evidence from EU Enlargement Benjamin Elsner IZA and IIIS Discussion Paper No. 6843 September 2012 IZA P.O. Box 7240 53072 Bonn Germany Phone: +49-228-3894-0 Fax: +49-228-3894-180 E-mail: iza@iza.org Any opinions expressed here are those of the...»

«IN 2000, 189 COUNTRIES OF THE WORLD CAME TOGETHER TO FACE THE FUTURE. And what they saw was daunting. Famines. Drought. Wars. Plagues. Poverty. The perennial problems of the world. Not just in some faraway place, but in their own cities and towns and villages. They knew things didn’t have to be this way. They knew we had enough food to feed the world, but that it wasn’t getting shared. They knew there were medicines for HIV and other diseases, but that they cost a lot. They knew that...»

«ARENBERG DOCTORAL SCHOOL FACULTY OF ENGINEERING Towards a Secure Web: Critical Vulnerabilities and Client-Side Countermeasures Nikolaos Nikiforakis Dissertation presented in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor in Engineering August 2013 Towards a Secure Web: Critical Vulnerabilities and Client-Side Countermeasures Nikolaos NIKIFORAKIS Supervisory Committee: Dissertation presented in partial Prof. Dr. ir. A. Bultheel, chair fulfillment of the requirements for Prof....»





 
<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.