FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:   || 2 |

«HARMOLODICS: thoughts this way and that Andrew Poppy Revised introduction for the School of Harmolodics as part of Ornette Coleman’s Meltdown ...»

-- [ Page 1 ] --



thoughts this way and that

Andrew Poppy

Revised introduction for the School of Harmolodics as part of Ornette Coleman’s

Meltdown Festival, South Bank Centre London 14-20 June 2009

It’s a privilege to be invited by Meltdown Festival 2009 to

help run The School of Harmolodics week of workshops.

I am some kind of contemporary composer rather than an

improviser. And what improvising I do, does not instantly

connect to the bop, post bop tradition that is the starting point of Ornette Coleman’s music. But probably that’s why I’ve been invited to be here; to be the wild card in a team of artistic leaders with Chris Batchelor and Julian Seigel who are such wonderful improvisers and whose music has more of a family connection to Ornette’s work. And the team also includes Alice Tatge’s making a dance and movement response to the Harmolodic idea.

What I want to contribute here is a sense of context. To see Harmolodics as connected to ideas in other areas of music and performance, both historically and personally.

Harmolodics: how does it work? Looking at various explanations by Ornette Coleman himself and members of his various bands it would seem to be a spirit or attitude as much as it a method.

There are some innovative technical inventions for sure, such as the Harmolodic clef. This is an interesting strategy. It’s a way of instantly building chromatically inflected harmonic fields within a predominately melodically articulated style.

Perhaps Harmolodics is an example of an approach to creativity which organises one parameter while trying to be un-mindful of another to which it is intimately connected. The relationship of harmony to melody and harmony to melody is particular in Ornettte Colemans style. The later is articulated whist the former is implied.

As Wilfred Mellers says in his still resonant book ‘Music In A New Found Land’(1964) “…. the first musician who has carried further some of the implication of Parker’s line and rhythm….

Ornette Coleman achieved this stylistic development by paring harmonic texture to a minimum: by discarding the piano as a harmony instrument and exporing, more radically than Sonny Rollins, melodic variation on line, not on chord sequence” Melody and melodic form are what dominate. And melodies have always been the more rigorous agents of control in any musical context. They survive almost infinite fragmentation and transformation. A harmony or a texture is much more fragile by comparison and more specifically located in a particular moment.

We can all sing The Beatles ‘Hard Days Night’ and, if we have the skill, we can riff and play on the intervals and shapes of the tune. But the opening chord on the electric guitar is a unique identity even if we own that particular Rickenbacker guitar and can voice it correctly. It’s a unique identity made up of interval structure, chord voicing, articulation, amplification and recording technology. Transpose it up a few intervals on the sampler and its identity is lost.

We can find that fragility in other places. ‘Durations’ by Morton Feldman where each ‘harmony colour’ is a stated thing in itself. Melodies are, where you find them, implied.

Harmolodics could be seen as a poetic strategy. Because trying to explore technical questions further sometimes dissolves into the mystification and magic of ‘a chord which cannot be inverted’! But perhaps that’s how it should be. Strong ideas are often simple and stand alone.

They don’t always need some vast tome to explain them like Wagner’s ‘Gesamkuntswerk’.E=MC2 is a good example of a big idea expressed with economy.

Harmolodics in some ways is more useful to think of as a an attitude. Ornette is ambitious for his idea to be more

then just a musical technique. He says:

"Harmolodics can be used in almost any kind of expression. You can think harmolodically. You can write fiction and poetry in harmolodic. Harmolodic allows a person to use a multiplicity of elements to express more than one direction at a time."

This is a way in for me as a composer whose own work is formed and influenced by American experimental and minimal contemporary classical music of the 1950-60s.

Who was he thinking of when he said “You can write fiction and poetry in harmolodic”. Certainly listening to ‘Little Symphony’, ‘Peace Warrior’,‘Enfant’, ‘Feet Music’, all sort of connections present themselves.

The novels of Jack Kerouac, where the words rush like ‘Big Sur’ in endless sentences where the full stop gets pushed further and further into the future. Or the poetry of Allan Ginsberg on ‘Howl’, the shaman, where the mesmeric flow of images tumble over each other suspending the readers desire to understand what he’s talking about. An invitation to trance dance in the metaphorical.

And could Harmolodics be in the painting of Jackson Pollack with its beguiling suggestion of freedom within an exquisitely choreographed painting action. He dances while he paints. The painting the memory of that dance.

All these guys put the sense, the image, the experience of spontaneity as the most importance thing to be communicated to the audience.

Perhap it’s worth noting at this point that, for the listener, high modernism, the most rigorously organised total serial music of Boulez and Stockhausen, also projects an image of spontaneity if not arbitrariness for the listener, I’ll come back to this later No doubt Kerouac, Ginsberg and Pollack all listened to Ornette Coleman back then. And given the 6 degrees of separation rule and the ‘small world‘ cliché of any artistic scene in any city, you can bet he knew a few of those guys.

Even before I heard the story that Ornette and Yoko Ono had been an item I sensed an aesthetic connection in their approach to performance. Ideas that were new, sometimes confrontational, but definitely floating free in the air of 1960s New York.

Fluxus was a movement that originated at that time. A loose association of artists which embraced may different modes and players from the proto minimalism of La Mont Young to the confrontational performance strategies of Dick Higgins and Yoko One. They developed the instruction score. Often a single paragraph, sometimes only a sentence, the score set the frame of a performance idea.

–  –  –

That’s it. The score doesn’t say how many performers, how they should be co-ordinated, how it starts, how it stops. What kind of duration there is between each ‘Scream’ event. All these things are decided either by negotiation OR NOT and if not these things are decided by WHAT HAPPENS by the particular quality of the moment and the thought of the people in the room.

Yoko Ono’s Laundry Piece 1963 In entertaining your guests bring out your laundry of the day and explain to them about each item. How and when it became dirty and why etc’ But getting back to Harmolodics. Harmolodics is a new word, and as a coinage it says almost all we need to know. It brings together the word ‘harmony’ and ‘melody’, the vertical and the horizontal, your space and myspace.

The individual and the group are incoded in the idea.

Perhap it’s what composer John Cage and choreographer Merc Cunningham explored as their co-existance of forms.

‘Music’ and ‘dance’ or ‘sound’ and movement brought together, outside of any kind of deterministic framework.

So I think all we need to know is the word, to contemplate the word and things will fall into place.

Lets talk about school. Perhaps an unfortunate word in this context. Perhap Harmolodics Lab would be more useful! This School of Harmolodics could be a number of things. We may start from Ornette’s tunes but we wont strive to ape the style in some of a kind of hall of mirrors.

We should aim to be true to the spirit and ourselves and make something that will be about this particular moment in 2009. We should continue the spirit and translate the ideas. As the man said ‘it not about style its an idea’ There is a song lyric by Nick Cave which is interesting to mention here. It’s called ‘We call upon the author to explain.’ ‘What we once thought we had, we didn't, and what we have now, will never be that way again So we call upon the author to explain’ ‘Rosary clutched in his hand, he died with tubes up his nose And a cabal of angels with finger cymbals chanted his name in code We shook our fists at the punishing rain And we call upon the author to explain’ ‘He said everything is messed up around here, everything is banal and jejune There is a planetary conspiracy against the likes of you and me in this idiot constituency of the moon Well, he knew exactly who to blame And we call upon the author to explain’ Nick Cave sends up of the idea of God in a meaningless world. But more than this, what Cave satirizes is the desire for ‘knowledge’, to know; the desire for there to be a complete method and plan. As we know these things are always provisional if they exist at all.

We encounter meaninglessness and mystery everyday and we wonder why we are here and what we are doing and somehow we get on and do stuff. And in moments of insecurity and doubt that continually surface we ‘call upon the author to explain’.

The author has been much theorised since the 1960s. And the author idea is, in part, a naming game. The word is great promoter of identity. A herald of something. Or a wall for the academy to breach.

George Russel has the Lydian Chromatic concept.

Gunter Shuller has Third Stream Schoenberg had the Method of Composing with 12 tones.

Steve Reich had Music as a Gradual Process.

Cage had Silence. The musical work and title of a book which made him even more in-famous and was anything but silent.

Arvo Part has Tintinnabulation.

Lars Von Tria the Scandinavian film maker has Dogma a set of rules for the liberation of film making from postproduction.

Although some authors don’t need any encouragement to explain, it’s useful to remember that Debussy was against the idea of being labelled an impressionism. But try going to a concert of his music or reading a book or record sleeve without encountering that word One last stab at the theory.

The idea is that Ornette’s ‘harmony is not something predetermined, but emerges from the interaction of the improvised lines in the ensemble’. And in this situation the intervallic structure of a line, a melody, is the essential element.

It’s an idea that echo’s Schoenberg’s serialism. The 12 tone method starts with the organisation of intervals. It has been trailed in the press as the heroic ‘liberation of dissonance’. This tells us more about the ideology of the style. Because most important to Schoeberg’s is his ‘prohibition’ of intervals which suggest triads. Intervals which have harmonic gravity. Ornette doesn’t have this agenda but perhaps does feel that melody needs to be less restricted by a fixed and stated harmonic frame.

John Cage - who with Alan Kaprow invented ‘Happenings’ in the early 1950s influencing the Fluxus movement in the 60s - studied with Schoenberg in his youth. Cage seems to have understood some of the irony implicit in the serial method.

The rigorous and mechanical control of one element, the melodic, tended to have implications for other parameters. The unforeseen or unintended consequences were fascinating, more fascinating that what was worked by the composer. In Schoenberg’s music the rigorous control of intervallic structure and the resulting lack of tonal centre left the rhythmic character in a time warp. An empty shell without any harmonic motivation.

In Ornette’s approach the idea is that harmony is not something pre-determined, but arrived at thought the soloist’s exploration of possibilities in the moment. So the specifics of the harmony are self determined by the free playing associations in the band.

Harmony emerges from the interaction of the improvised lines in the ensemble, but the specifics of the harmonic results are indeterminate. The melodic is articulated but the harmony is implied and always moving towards ambiguity. This is the idea.

Ornette’s harmelodic clef or the strategy of transposing instrument all reading from the same clef goes quite along way to making some kind of consistent harmonic world. It can quickly established a harmonic identity.

Some composers in the middle of the 20th Century were quick to take Schoenberg’s melodic ideas further by applying rigorous control to all parameters. Rhythm, Dynamics and Timbre. However the more the parameters of composition where rigorously ordered the more the surface of the work projected some kind of free play. This seems particularly true of Stockhausen’s music.

Cage on the other hand wanted to play what was controlled off against what wasn’t. He asked: why not devote composition and performance energy (control) to making an experience in which all the sonic events are unforeseen (uncontrolled) by the composer.

The final stage of this approach, in which both composers and performer seem redundant, Cage asks: why not just listen to the sonic events that naturally occur in the world.

To consider for aesthetic experience those things which are not controlled by us and the specifics of which are unforeseen. The continuing irony is that to do this Cage still has to have a score and, in the classic version of 4’33, a pianist.

Even if it’s a one word instruction score:

‘Tacet’, to ‘not play’.

Perhaps this relationship of the controlled element to the uncontrolled elements is the theme of what I’ve been talking about.

At the centre of Ornette Coleman’s practise and thought is the idea that everything is connected to everything else. C major might be connected to Db somehow. And a musical interval may be connected to love or the smell of the earth. Ornette plays with Moroccan musicians at one moment and that European invention the symphony orchestra the next.

Both LaMont Young and Terry Riley played some kind of bop before they became the founding fathers of Minimalism. The heterophonic textures of Riley’s ‘In C’ look both ways towards the textural micro polyphony of Ligeti’s ‘Chamber Concerto’ and back to Parker. And a more recent work like Andressen ‘Hout’ has the memory of those bop lines imprinted in its DNA.

Pages:   || 2 |

Similar works:

«THE TROTTER Teignbridge Trotters Newsletter Number 1 August 2014 Nigel Penwarden Totnes 10K: Sun Gets Them Out! At long last, a dry, sunny race day, something we haven’t had for the last three years, and what a difference it made. All sorts of records were set, some good and some not so good! We had 631 enter the 10K and 141 enter the fun run (both new records), compared to 496 and 114 respectfully in the previous year. We had 167 enter the 10K on the day, a new record. This year we took pre...»

«LETTER Communicated by Shimon Edelman Learning to Recognize Three-Dimensional Objects Dan Roth danr@uiuc.edu Ming-Hsuan Yang myang1@uiuc.edu Narendra Ahuja n-ahuja@uiuc.edu Department of Computer Science and the Beckman Institute Urbana, IL 61801, U.S.A. A learning account for the problem of object recognition is developed within the probably approximately correct (PAC) model of learnability. The key assumption underlying this work is that objects can be recognized (or discriminated) using...»

«Aidê Ai ai Aidê Joga bonito que eu quero ver Ai ai Aidê Joga bonito que eu quero aprender Ai ai Aidê Eu venci a batalha do Camujerê Ai ai Aidê. Cara de gato, nariz de sarigue São Bento me Chama Ai, ai, ai, ai São Bento me chama Ai, ai, ai, ai São Bento me chamou Ai, ai, ai, ai Sinhó São Bento Ai, ai, ai, ai. Camugerê Camugerê como tá? como tá? Camugerê Como vai voismicê? Camugerê Tu tá bem de saude Camugerê Para mim é um prazer Camugerê. Dona Maria do Camboatá Dona Maria...»

«Oral Tradition, 10/1 (1995): 27-53 What’s in a Frame? The Medieval Textualization of Traditional Storytelling Bonnie D. Irwin But morning overtook Shahrazad, and she lapsed into silence. Then Dinarzad said, “What a strange and entertaining story!” Shahrazad replied, “What is this compared with what I shall tell you tomorrow night if the king spares me and lets me live!” The following night Shahrazad said.... (Haddawy 1990:18 and passim)1 Thus nature interrupts the storyteller, in...»

«Lauri Astala SPACE, PLACE, AND PRESENCE I’m walking – probably not for the first time – along the busy streets of Chicago. The skyscrapers rise around me, and shade the bustle of pedestrians below. Sun and the shade of high-rise buildings create an atmosphere of razor-sharp light, contrasting wide streets and dark alleys. Colorful neon lights and advertisements compete for attention, and innumerable glass facades reflect and twist their surfaces into an endless and infinite kaleidoscopic...»

«SPA BROCHURE LC1003.v1 ESPA EXPRESS Personalised Express Facial 30 minutes Your therapist will select the most suitable facial for your skin. Every ESPA personalised facial includes a consultation, SkinVisionTM analysis, cleanse, exfoliation, personalised facial mask and finishes with an application of a booster serum to suit your skin. Head & Scalp Massage 30 minutes Based on the ayurvedic system of healing, this massage will release the stress that has accumulated in the tissues, muscles and...»

«Does Disclosure affect CEO Pay Setting? Evidence from the Passage of the 1934 Securities and Exchange Act * Alexandre Mas Princeton University and NBER March 2016 Abstract Using newly digitized data from the Federal Trade Commission, I examine the evolution of executive compensation during the Great Depression, before and after mandated pay disclosure in 1934. I find that disclosure did not achieve the intended effect of broadly lowering CEO compensation. If anything, and in spite of popular...»

«The People v. Ossian Sweet, Gladys Sweet, et. al. (1925) The People v. Henry Sweet (1926) Michael Hannon (April 2010) Detroit The Sweet trials were the direct result of the racial tensions prevalent in Detroit and other northern cities during the 1920s. During WWI and up until the 1920s, all the major cities in the northern part of the United States experienced a very large demographic shift. Large numbers of blacks moved from the South seeking work and escape from institutionalized Jim Crow...»

«British Birds Established 1907; incorporating 'The Zoologist', established 1843 Grey-cheeked and Bicknell's Thrushes: taxonomy., identification and the British and Irish records Alan Knox The BOU Records Committee has recently accepted ABSTRACT the taxonomic split of the mainly Nearctic Grey-cheeked Thrush Catharus minimus into two species: a restricted Grey-cheeked Thrush comprising the races minimus and aliciae and the monotypic Bicknell's Thrush C. bicknelli. Identification and ageing of the...»

«Studies in Gothic Fiction Volume 2 Issue 1 Zittaw Press Studies in Gothic Fiction ISSN: 2156-2407 © 2011 Zittaw Press Editor: Franz J. Potter, National University Associate Editor: Colin Marlaire, National University Editorial Board Curt Herr, Kutztown University Melissa Bradshaw, Loyola University Chicago Katherine D. Harris, San Jose State University Dale Townshend, University of Stirling Jamieson Ridenhour, University of Mary Roy Bearden-White, Southern Illinois University Margarita...»

«Curriculum Vitae Yogendra Singh, Ph.D., Aff.M.ASCE, MEERI, MACI, MIE, MISTE, MISET Designation : Professor Postal Address : Deptt. of Earthquake Engg. Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee – 247 667, INDIA Ph. No.: +91-1332 –285534 (Off.)/285042 (Res.) Fax No.: +91-1332-276899/273560 Email: yogenfeq@iitr.ernet.in/ yogendra.eq@gmail.com Web: http://www.iitr.ernet.in/~EQ/yogenfeq Date of Birth: 18th April 1968 UNIVERSITY EDUCATION B.E. (1989) in Civil Engg. from IIT Roorkee (then University...»

«Tramps and Bluegrass: A Letter from the Czech Republic THE NEW LEADER August 2005 BRNO, CZECH REPUBLIC The music that I have listened most to over the past year is by a Czech group called Druha Trava. I don't speak Czech, but the gritty passion of singer/songwriter Robert Krestan's vocals, combined with the resonance of the sung Czech language, melds with the band's virtuoso instrumentals in a way I find quite thrilling. I have played their CDs over and over and new technology has even...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.