FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 2 | 3 || 5 | 6 |   ...   | 43 |

«      Boffo, Marco (2013) Interrogating the knowledge‐based economy: from  ...»

-- [ Page 4 ] --

Yet, and in response to the potential contradiction raised above, two sets of reasons leading to privilege the present form for this thesis can be offered. First, it must be stressed how a critical historical narrative demystifying the Knowledge-Based Economy concept already exists. This is readily found in the work recently carried out by Philip Mirowski, on the one hand, and Benjamin Coriat, on the other hand, together with their respective associates (Mirowski, Van Horn, 2005; Mirowski, Sent, 2008; Mirowski, 2008, 2011; Coriat, 2002a, 2002b; Coriat, Orsi, 2002; Coriat et al., 2003; Coriat, Weinstein, 2012; Orsi, 2002; Orsi, Moatti, 2001; Orsi, Coriat, 2005, 2006). As discussed in greater length and detail in the conclusion of this thesis, this body of work stands out for its ability to highlight the shallowness of the foundations for the concept of Knowledge-Based Economy, not least by emphasising the historical (co)evolution of the socio-economic institutions, structures, dynamics and processes underpinning the use, production, reproduction and accumulation of knowledge (together with science and technology) in advanced capitalist economies.

Nonetheless, and however much I agree with Mirowski’s and Coriat’s recent work and historical understanding of the incorporation of knowledge within capitalist dynamics, to use their account as a base for an alternative narrative could have been itself contradictory (at least for the purposes of the present thesis, but see the conclusion for considerations on the possibility of integrating and extending their more recent work). Indeed, Mirowski (1989) rejects Marx’s value theory (but see Caffentzis, 2007 for an attempt to refute Mirowski’s reading), and Coriat originally hails from workerist labour process theory (1976) only to shift soon thereafter to regulation theory (1979, 1990) – of which he is one of the forefathers – and, ultimately, to accept and praise post-fordist Japanese methods of production (1991) (although his more recent contributions, commended above, can be seen as marking a phase of reradicalisation in his work). In light of all of this, to base a rebuttal of Italian post-workerism as the one proposed in this thesis on a narrative borrowing from Mirowski and Coriat could have been seen as deeply contradictory, and probably more so than the potential contradiction suggested in the previous paragraph. Thus, while this thesis does not intend to replicate (or, at least for the time being, extend) Mirowski’s and Coriat’s recent work, it seeks to complement it in two ways: by providing an understanding of the mainstream version of the KnowledgeBased Economy together with its points of contact with the broader rhetoric attached to the latter concept outside of the discipline of economics, not least in light of economics imperialism and the contemporary state of economics; and by paying close attention on how radicalism and left-leaning scholarship have reacted to the concept of Knowledge-Based Economy and its scholarship. The first theme is explored in the first chapter, not least by offering a close reading of those contributions more directly seeking to derive a characterisation of contemporary capitalism from the classical characterisation of knowledge offered within mainstream economic theory. The second theme is explored in the second and third chapters in relation to, respectively, Italian post-workerism and its internal dissent (together with the issues of whether knowledge workers constitute a new class, and whether prosumption is an appropriate category for the study of contemporary capitalism). Albeit related, these are self-enclosed issues that commanded separate treatment.

A second set of reasons inducing to structure the thesis in its present form derives from what I have found to be problematic aspects of narrative itself with respect to the Knowledge-Based Economy concept and its relation to the economy. This is not to appeal to the cynical rejection of, and suspicious scepticism towards, narrative as bestowed upon academia by the postmodern proclamation of the “end of master narratives” (Lyotard, 1979b). If anything, and quite to the contrary, it is to denounce how such postmodern hubris (if not a narrative in itself?) has instead resulted in (and masked?) what can be likened to a veritable explosion of narratives. Indeed, the original intentions and motivation in preparing this thesis were exactly those of providing an alternative critical account of the Knowledge-Based Economy, not least by studying the socio-economic dynamics attached to software and computers as a specific case study of the former conceptualisation of contemporary capitalism. Yet, in reviewing and making sense of the existing literature, both mainstream and critical, it soon became clear to me that, as already stated at the beginning of this Introduction, the Knowledge-Based Economy is but one amongst many competing portrayals of society and/or the economy, where the latter are (mis)construed as post-industrial, post-Fordist, informational, learning, weightless, or simply “new” (Huws, 2003; Kenway et al., 2006; Carlaw et al., 2006). In addition to this, and more to the point, the literature on the Knowledge-Based Economy has characteristically focused on asserting what is its nature, how it is distinctive, and how and why this is significant. But, given that there can be as many conceptions of the Knowledge-Based Economy as there are conceptions of knowledge, the economy, and of their interaction, this has resulted in a proliferation of narratives, where particular and select aspects of reality (sometimes having relative purchase, sometimes merely contextual or altogether imaginary) are generalised and magnified into descriptions of contemporary capitalism as a whole.

Further, not only has this happened at the expense of sound theoretical conceptualisation and pushing the analysis in the wrong directions and beyond what is justifiable, but it has often had the effect of distracting from (if not outrightly masking, although in complex ways) the real nature and dynamics of contemporary capitalism, undeniably rooted in finance (as painfully evident in light of the current crisis). But, having reached these conclusions, to propose yet another version of the Knowledge-Based Economy, even if critical, inevitably appears as a complicit participation in the proliferation, if not cacophony, of competing and incommensurable narratives discussed above. It then seemed more fruitful to take part in a more fine-grained exercise of debunking, such as the one offered in the chapters of this thesis.

However, all of the above raises the issue of the methodological stance adopted in each chapter. Having chosen to structure the thesis as a set of related yet self-contained contributions, it has seemed appropriate to let the issues addressed in each chapter dictate the methodological stance best suited to address them. In the first chapter, my main motivation is to caution those positioned outside the mainstream of economics (be they economists or not) against welcoming the elaboration of a mainstream version of (and vision for) the Knowledge-Based Economy as a move of the mainstream towards greater pluralism and increased realism (along the lines proposed by Foray, 2006 and David, Foray, 2002, 2003, for example). An equally powerful motivation is easily found in the intent to caution the same constituency against the use of concepts and conceptualisations drawn from economics and which have come to permeate the broader rhetoric conventionally attached to the KnowledgeBased Economy outside of the discipline (e.g. the conceptualisation of knowledge as a public good), since these are inappropriate to understand the social character of knowledge and to defend the latter from commercialisation. Given these motivations, it has seemed adequate to adopt a broad pluralistic heterodox approach, in the intent of convincing those otherwise attracted by the Knowledge-Based Economy concept of its lack of foundations and of the necessity to build broad alliances against the mainstream. Otherwise, the second and third chapters address issues directly related to the Marxian research programme (such as exploitation and class, for example), as well as scholarship and interpretations of particular phenomena which, in various ways, are increasingly coming to be seen as improving on, if not ultimately sanctioning the obsolescence of Marxian and Marxist political economy. Thus, these two chapters adopt a methodological stance distinctly and firmly located within Marxist political economy and which takes Marx and his own work seriously, for the main motivation behind these chapters is to sound a warning against abandoning Marx’s value theory when interpreting the workings of capitalism.

In summary, this thesis does not have the pretension (nor the presumptuousness) of addressing all of what has been said (or that could possibly be said) about the KnowledgeBased Economy. Rather, it provides a reading of the latter that is relevant to some of the concerns that the Knowledge-Based Economy concept raises, together with the socioeconomic dynamics and processes usually associated to it, as judged from the perspective of economic analysis and theory. This is done from a general point of view in the first chapter, and with a specific focus on Marxian economic theory in the second and third chapters.

Nonetheless, the thesis also addresses broader themes and concerns than those strictly related to the Knowledge-Based Economy, for which the latter provides an interesting example and a useful case study. Indeed, and first, this thesis is animated by the aim of investigating the conditions and methods for the appropriate conceptualisation of the dynamic interaction and (co)evolution of the economic, the material, the social, the political, the ideal, and the cultural.

In tight connection to this, a second major thrust of this thesis lies in the aim to investigate the appropriate conditions and method for the rigorous dialogue between and across disciplines.

This is extremely important, for, while concepts from mainstream economics (such as knowledge as a public good or externalities) are increasingly borrowed from outside of the discipline (and even by radical critics, as demonstrated in the first and second chapters of this thesis), this happens in a context in which economics itself has not been shy in expanding beyond its traditional boundaries and “colonising” the subject matter of other disciplines (Fine, Milonakis, 2009). Further, this has recently been complemented and paralleled by the ambitions of sociologist who, hailing from the sociology of scientific knowledge, have moved to provide their own reading of economic phenomena, dynamics and processes (see, for an introduction, Barry, Slater, 2002a, 2002b). Yet, as will be shown in the following chapters, the picture that emerges from the discussions on the Knowledge-Based Economy (and cognitive capitalism) is one of both opportunistic and naive borrowing of concepts, rather than one of rigorous interdisciplinary dialogue. Thirdly, the material and subject matter covered in the thesis offer insights about the issues of change and continuity between and within different socio-economic systems, as well as the role played in these dynamic processes by technology and (its embedding in) historically-given social relations. While the intellectual route followed in this thesis is not the only one that could have been taken, the path of my research led me to assess these literatures, scholarship and authors in their own right, not least because they are influential (or increasingly so) irrespective of whether or not they shed light on the KnowledgeBased Economy. In essence, this thesis remains agnostic about what the Knowledge-Based Economy is (if not altogether sceptical about the existence of such a thing). To reiterate, it would be natural to expect anyone embarking on research on the latter, even from a critical perspective, to assert what is its nature, how it is distinctive, and how and why this is significant. Indeed, this is characteristic of the research addressed in this thesis. However, while this thesis refrains from such endeavour, what it demonstrates is that the answers provided to research questions along these lines have been unsatisfactory. This raises the issue of whether we need better answers or better questions. On the ground of what this thesis demonstrates and the doubts that it raises, however tentatively, speculatively and to be confirmed by future research, it seems appropriate to suggest that we are in strong need of better questions.

Chapter 1 – Debunking the Knowledge-Based Economy and the Economics of Knowledge 1.1) Introduction The notion that we are “now” living in a Knowledge-Based Economy has been circulating in various guises, with the portrayal of the economy as post-industrial at first, then informational, or simply “new”, since at least the 1960s. Furthermore, this has been accepted in the mainstream of many social sciences, to the point of having become a cliché. However, such conceptualisation of the economy has come to the fore only recently within economics itself.

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 2 | 3 || 5 | 6 |   ...   | 43 |

Similar works:

«Newsletter Hagley Tramping Club Published by Hagley Tramping Club P.O Box 852, Christchurch 8140, NZ www.hagleytrampingclub.net.nz Affiliated to the Federated Mountain Clubs of NZ Inc. JUNE, JULY, AUGUST, SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER 2014 Welcome to the Hagley Tramping Club Newsletter. The Hagley Tramping Club was originally established as the Hospital Tramping Club in 1974 with the aim of making the back country experience more accessible to the average person and to foster a respect for the wilderness....»

«Academic Journal of Modern Szymon Napierała Philology Adam Mickiewicz University, Poznań A Hypothesis on the Catastrophic Emergence of Syntax e-ISSN 2353-3218 ISSN 2299-7164 and Phonetics Vol. 3 (2014) 55–65 Abstract There are two major theories about the origin of human syntax: evolutionary and catastrophic, the latter appears more probable on theoretical and empirical grounds, the most serious reason being the problem with imagining the intermediate stages between protosyntax and...»

«2014 BRITTON L. T. PLOURDE 201 Physics Building email: bplourde@syr.edu Syracuse University phone (office): (315) 443-8967 Syracuse, NY 13244 phone (lab): (315) 443-4719 http://physics.syr.edu/~bplourde/ fax: (315) 443-9103 ACADEMIC POSITIONS •Associate Professor, Physics Department – Syracuse University August 2011-present •Assistant Professor, Physics Department – Syracuse University Jan. 2005-Aug. 2011 •Postdoctoral Research Associate –University of California, Berkeley 2000 2004...»

«AUTHOR’S SUMMARY OF PHD DISSERTATION ZRÍNYI MIKLÓS NATIONAL DEFENCE UNIVERSITY Doctorate Council ATTILA BLEIER Modernization of the fixed communication system of the Hungarian Army Author’s summary and official reviews Budapest 2010 ZRÍNYI MIKLÓS NATIONAL DEFENCE UNIVERSITY ATTILA BLEIER Modernization of the fixed communication system of the Hungarian Army Author’s summary and official reviews Scientific Leader: Prof. Dr. Rajnai Zoltán eng. colonel, university professor Budapest 2010...»

«Guidance for Electoral Registration Officers Part 4 – Maintaining the register throughout the year Originally published September 2013 (last updated July 2016) Updates to this document Updated Description of change September 2013 Original publication May 2015 Updated for the 2015 canvass and the period leading up to the May 2016 polls July 2015 Revised for Scotland to reflect The Scottish Elections (Reduction of Voting Age) Act 2015. This change applies to any elections in Scotland that use...»

«RECLAMATION Managing Water in the West SECURE Water Act Section 9503(c)-Reclamation Climate Change and Water 2016 Chapter 7: Rio Grande Basin \ _i ~-U.S. Department of th e Interior March 20 16 Bureau of Reclamation Mission Statements The U.S. Department of the Interior protects America’s natural resources and heritage, honors our cultures and tribal communities, and supplies the energy to power our future. The mission of the Bureau of Reclamation is to manage, develop, and protect water and...»

«LUTHERAN QUARTERLY 156 Dates of Katharina von Bora's Life 1499 January 29: Birth in Lippendorf. 1505 Admission into the Brehna Cloister. 1509 Admission into the Marienthron Cloister in Nimbschen near Grimma. 1514 Beginning of her novitiate. 1515 October 8: Consecration as a nun. 1523 April 6/7: Flight from the Nimbschen Cloister with eleven other nuns with the aid of the merchant, Leonard Koppe, from Torgau. Nine nuns come through Torgau to Wittenberg. 1525 June 13: Marriage to Martin Luther in...»

«0 Welcome to Católica Lisbon’s Career Forum ‘16! At Career Forum ’16 you are able to meet representatives from national and international companies whom have interest to recruit Católica Lisbon students. We strongly recommend you to take the most of the event by interacting with the participating companies. Remember, recruiters are looking for motivated candidates who stand out from the crowd. The Forum Book is designed to compile more detailed information about the profile of the...»


«Liminalities: A Journal of Performance Studies Vol. 6, No. 2, October 2010 “Linguistic Fandom”: Performing Liminal Identities in the Spaces of Transgression Karolina Agata Kazimierczak ‘[F]andom is not simply a “thing” that can be picked over analytically. It is [.] always performative [.] it is an identity which is (dis-)claimed, and which performs cultural work’, declares Matt Hills, as he critically summarises over a decade of media and cultural studies’ attempts at approaching...»

«A83 Trunk Road Route Study Part A A83 Rest and Be Thankful Summary February 2013 Document Control Sheet BPP 04 F8 Version 14 July 2012 Project: A83 Trunk Road Route Study Project No: B1557610 Client: Transport Scotland Document Title: Part A – A83 Rest and Be Thankful Ref. No: Originated by Checked by Reviewed by Approved by NAME NAME NAME NAME ORIGINAL (Draft) Charles Macklin Graeme Herd Stuart Turnbull Helen Bradley DATE INITIALS INITIALS INITIALS INITIALS 07/12/2012 Published Draft for...»

«MUSEUM Poems like dreams ONE Museum This museum with its bright red walls open all day and all night. No charge, if you can find it. This first picture, framed in black and gold, is a thousand rocks at the water’s bottom, as old as the museum. Glinting water covers the rocks with white lace that disappears in a moment. In the picture, massive black rocks jut up out to sea; the blues go out to the horizon and up into the sky where a few small puffs of white cannot wait and glide along as if...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.