WWW.DISSERTATION.XLIBX.INFO
FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials
 
<< HOME
CONTACTS



Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 25 | 26 || 28 | 29 |   ...   | 30 |

«The Ethics of Representation in the Fiction of Amitav Ghosh The Ethics of Representation in the Fiction of Amitav Ghosh by Tuomas Huttunen Anglicana ...»

-- [ Page 27 ] --

I have already referred to Black and her excellent analysis of Ghosh‘s novels (see section II.5. and the beginning of section III.1.). Black discerns in Ghosh‘s fiction ―inceasingly radical textual sacrifices‖ (2010, 16) that appear necessary for imaginative border crossing. This foregrounds the ethical problem of representing linguistic difference. It is necessary to find a solution to the problem of ethically narrating the translingual, multilingual and (certainly in the case of Ghosh) even extra- or antilingual experiences in the English language. In Black‘s view, Ghosh‘s treatment of English in The Glass Palace makes the language ―renounce elements of its own aesthetic privilege‖ (17) in an attempt to accommodate different forms of expression.13 Renouncing obvious markers of linguistic variation, such as dialect and style (still carefully crafted and pointed out in The Calcutta Chromosome) this novel ―flattens the sonic dimension of English to create a tone that different readers are meant to hear differently‖ (17). I agree with Black on this point, and I am also on the same lines with her on The Hungry Tide, as can be inferred from my article on it. I therefore share Black‘s contention that ―the radicalism of this approach deepens in The Hungry Tide, which produces expansive crowded selves and styles to embrace the significant linguistic otherness of hyperverbal translation and nonhuman communication‖ (17). Black concludes her treatment

of Ghosh as follows:

As Ghosh‘s writing asks how fiction in English might accommodate the multiplicity of multilingual and antilingual experience, it copes with the borders between Black (2010, 167) connects Ghosh‘s preoccupation with new practises of textuality with a larger trend of experimenting with the relationship between linguistic form and social difference she discerns within the twenty-five-year span she examines in her book (1980-2005). She mentions novels such as The Bone People (1983) by Keri Hulme, Kafka’s Curse (1997) by Achmat Dangor and Londonstani (2006) by Gautam Malkani as texts occupied with the various ways of depicting socially explicit usages of the English language. Especially Hulme comes close to Ghosh in her delineation of silence and visual arts as forms of representation. Of course, the ‗chutneyed‘ English of Rushdie‘s Midnight’s Children (1981), and the ‘sanskritized‘ English of Raja Rao from earlier decades also come to mind here.

languages by divesting English of exclusive aesthetic privilege. The flattened language of The Glass Palace eschews the hierarchies of dialect, favouring instead the visual techniques of modernist photography, and the crowded selves of The Hungry Tide forge a compromise between the utopianism of the unspoken and the fallible speech of translation. These aesthetic renunciations, paradoxically, expand the capacity of English to represent non-English worlds of experience. They testify to possible strategies for lives lived across the borders of language.

(2010, 199) The Hungry Tide, which among Ghosh‘s novels has received the largest amount of substantial ethical criticism, has been approached from this angle also by Terri Tomsky, whose interpretation of the characters of Kanai and Piya as well as their relationship is strikingly close to mine (see the article in IV.6.).

But Tomsky also examines the way the characters of Nirmal and Nilima in the novel can be ethically approached through Edward Said‘s concept of ―anxious witnessing‖ (Said 2000, xxi), originally conceived as denoting the relationship of the writer to his/her community. Anxious witnessing is in Tomsky‘s view inseparable from ethical inquiry as it brings the creative vision of the displaced (or exiled) writer together with the ethical obligation of the intellectual (58). Consequently, Tomsky foregrounds anxious witnessing as ―a useful hermeneutic for understanding the model for ethical action advanced by Ghosh‖ (Tomsky 2009, 54). She further maintains that Ghosh, like Said, ―recognizes that ethical intervention is only effective when accompanied by the economic agency of the transnational bourgeoisie.‖ In her view, anxious witnessing ―collapses into modes of melancholia and incapacity without financial mobilization‖ (54), thereby emphasizing the importance of this cosmopolitan component. However, Tomsky is observant enough to recognize that Ghosh‘s ethics also comes through as ―a meditation on the transformative power of close human relationships‖, which I highlight in my article and which Tomsky characterizes as having an effect on the political actions (cf. Nilima) and philosophical interests (cf. Nirmal) of the characters. Tomsky also brings the concept of the affect à la Sara Ahmed (2000) to bear on her interpretation of the novel.

As I have endeavoured to establish, the writing of Ghosh is affiliated both with postmodernism and liberal humanism. In general, the criticism written on his works tends to adopt one of the following four stances in relation to this ambivalence: the avoidance of both postmodernism and humanism (eg. Dixon 1996), affiliation with both (eg. Mondal 2007), or seeing his writing as primarily humanist (eg. Viswanathan 1996) or postmodernist (eg. Kaul 1995). In addition to his own argument, Mondal offers an apt discussion on the views of the other three scholars mentioned above (Mondal 2007, 169-172). The presence of both postmodern and humanist sentiments in Ghosh‘s output is quite evident and, as will be shown in the next sub-section, this duplicity does not indicate an escape from both realms by avoiding affiliation with either, as Dixon would have it. On the contrary, it ―denotes a strategic commitment to both‖ (Mondal 2007, 171; original emphasis). Ghosh‘s texts cannot be defined solely as postmodern or humanist without eclipsing a significant amount of important material in them. His texts weave together elements of both ideologies for certain purposes. The articles in this dissertation chart the historical and cultural contexts of this ambivalent approach, while trying to establish the goals of the ensuing ideological texture.





As Mondal (2007, 171) observes, although Ghosh‘s writings have been explored thoroughly from theoretically and politically informed angles, their political status and viability have largely been left unresolved. Of the four above mentioned critics, Viswanathan, Kaul and Dixon respectively maintain that Ghosh either fails to consider political problems in his forced humanist syncretism (In an Antique Land), proposes the use of amorphous imagination that has no consequences on material reality (The Shadow Lines), or lets his text flow free of any affiliation, be that humanist or postmodernist. The central thesis proposed by Mondal is that Ghosh has a strategic commitment to both humanism and postmodernism, and that this explains the ambivalent attitude that his texts reveal towards both. My own stance in this respect has been explicated in the articles and will be returned to in these concluding remarks, but suffice it to mention here that I am closest to Mondal on this issue. But a caveat is in order: with Ghosh, it is only safe to say that his narratives are equally preoccupied with matters pertaining to both liberal humanism and postmodernism, not so much with these two as theoretical disciplines or sets of methodological tools. Ghosh the writer of fiction is not to be confused with Ghosh the academic.

In addition to the concern about the political implications of Ghosh‘s writing expressed by several critics, the matter of gender in Ghosh‘s output merits a mention since it has clearly been neglected by critics in the subcontinent and the West alike. This is commented on by Mondal, who briefly discusses the representation of gender in Ghosh‘s novels (2007, 165-169). In addition to Mondal, texts on Ghosh that specifically take up gender include those by Nagesh Rao on cosmopolitanism, class and gender in The Shadow Lines; Suchitra Mathur on third-world women and the politics of science, that includes The Calcutta Chromosome as one of three examples on its theme; and Shameem Black (2006) on The Shadow Lines. This dissertation does not concentrate on questions of gender in any detail. But it is worth noting that Ghosh‘s narratives are mindful of gender and that the significance of gender in his output has been on the increase.

As I have attempted to establish, Ghosh‘s works resonate strongly with the history of the assimilation and/or refutation of Western ideas (be they modernist or postmodernist) in India and especially in the Bengali tradition from the mid-nineteenth century onwards. The ambivalence inherent in this tradition between the initially successful creation of cultural/political strategies for facing colonialism and the resulting defeat in the form of the failure of the construction of a politically functional Indian nationalism comes through in Ghosh‘s writing. What creates the more positive dimension of his fiction is the outlining of strategies for transcending or avoiding the boundaries set by modernist knowledge production strategies and the political systems based on them.

The representational strategies developed by Ghosh advocate the establishment of connections through ethical principles, which help to avoid the pitfalls lurking in the mechanisms of an unguarded discursive representation of the other. Ghosh explores the colonial and post-colonial situation through an amalgamation of postmodernism (politics of difference) and humanism (ethics of connections). As I clarified in section III.2., both humanism and postmodernism are an integral part of the ideological history of India. As I shall attempt to show in the following section, in Ghosh‘s writing this ideological fusion comprises an ethical project not indicative of political failure, or a failure to cope with political discourses. It is, rather, representative of the simultaneous representation of both ethical and political dimensions of human existence.

V.2. From ethics to politics – political viability in the writing of Amitav Ghosh As I mentioned above, certain critics (especially Viswanathan and Kaul) of Ghosh‘s writing have dismissed his work on the grounds that it is incapable of taking political responsibility and/or confronting political realities. Presumably, this dismissal is motivated by a certain kind of ‗activist‘ conception of what constitutes political behaviour or responsibility. This conception presupposes that politics automatically involves action and that a discourse is politically significant ―to the extent that it can be acted upon‖ (Mondal 2007, 172). Politics would then require choices that make for a certain course of action. Ghosh‘s ambivalence, his concentration on both the ethics of connections and the politics of discourse and difference causes a problem in this respect, because he seems to be espousing two political positions, making two choices at once. Mondal connects this ambivalence with Ghosh‘s dislike of binary models evident, as I have shown in the article in IV.1., right from The Circle of Reason.

Mondal claims that Ghosh chooses to pick both stances: he chooses not to make a choice based on a binary model. According to the ‗standard‘ view, in politics people cannot follow two allegedly opposing courses of action simultaneously. Ghosh‘s model remains open-ended when examined from those premises.

Mondal‘s explanation concerning Ghosh‘s two-dimensional representational strategy, or as he characterizes it, Ghosh‘s ―politics of ambivalence‖ (2007, 173), is quite close to the interpretation I proposed in the introductory sub-section on ethics and language in Ghosh (III.1.2.) and later in the articles. In Mondal‘s view, postcolonial circumstances are best met with such an ambivalent political attitude, because they demand two registers: one that acknowledges the metaphysic of modernity, its institutions and its governing ensembles of knowledge such as the state, citizenship, equality, social science and the rule of law etc.; and, on the other hand, another register which exceeds and resists that metaphysic because it does not observe the forms of rationality that inhere in the emancipatory projects of modernity. Indeed, this politics recognises that those projects involve an epistemic violence against other ways of thinking and being in the world – hence the strategic value of alignment with postmodernism – whilst also acknowledging the importance of modernity‘s universal frameworks in any struggle to establish social justice on a global scale. (2007, 173) I have referred to this ambivalence on several occasions (e.g. subsection III.1.2.; the articles in IV.4. & IV.5.), but shall repeat the main purpose behind these two registers again here. It seems that Ghosh is above all attempting to create narrative representations that establish connections across totalities constructed by modernist discourses. He does this by narrating into existence ethical relationships ensuring agency and voice to all while avoiding the appropriation of these voices to any one discourse.

This is achieved by juxtaposing representative strategies and deconstructing the hegemonic position of certain versions. The transcending of borders inevitably requires a certain emphasis on difference, as well as an awareness of realities as discursive constructions in the poststructuralist vein. In a sense, Ghosh has to play the postmodernist games of textuality and of ‗discourse as power‘ in order to deconstruct modernist totalities and to be able to avoid discursive appropriation and abstract homogenizing of heterogeneous groups. But this recognition of difference is effected on the basis of ethically conceived relationships that transcend the discursive totalities created by representations.

As Mondal acknowledges, Ghosh‘s choice of both these registers proposes a commitment to ethical problems involved in the encounter with the other. And this two-dimensional representation refuses ―the subordination of the ethical to the political, the means to the ends, theory to practise, and deliberation to action,‖ all of which are set up by the ‗activist‘ branch of politics in the form of oppositions that bring forth a certain kind of concept of politics (Mondal 2007, 173). Ghosh‘s political ambivalence opens a way to the ethical negotiation of cultural difference that would be blocked by political activism, which is set on achieving ends at the cost of exploring the means.



Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 25 | 26 || 28 | 29 |   ...   | 30 |


Similar works:

«TERRY ASLA WAS A 6-YEAR-OLD BOY WHEN HIS FATHER WENT TO WAR IN 1951. DAD NEVER RETURNED. IT WOULD BE ALMOST HALF A CENTURY BEFORE TERRY WOULD LEARN WHAT HAPPENED TO HIM. Sunday, September 17, 2000 BY ROY WENZL, The Wichita Eagle Mist fell gray through the glare of depot lights. In the passenger shelter the family huddled close Dad, Mom and their two little stinkers, as Dad called them. Terry could feel the Oregon damp on his face. In the hard shadows, Dad hugged Mom for long moments, then...»

«Nieuwland 1 MegaWatt PV Project, Amersfoort 1. Introduction In the Waterkwartier district in the Nieuwland expansion area of the city of Amersfoort, the worlds' largest urban PV project (1999) has been realized. The project consists of over 500 houses and several other buildings such as schools and a sports facility with PV solar modules integrated in the façade and the roofs. The total PV power is 1.35 MWp, about 12,300 m2. The main investor of the project was the energy company REMU (now...»

«A Review of Substance Misuse Involving Children and Young People by a working group of the Children, Young People and Learning Overview and Scrutiny Panel Mephedrone Alcohol April 2015 Table of Contents Page No. Lead Member’s Foreword 1. 1 2. Executive Summary 2 3. Background 3 4. Investigation, Information Gathering and Analysis 5 5. Conclusions 31 6. Recommendations 33 7. Glossary 34 Appendix 1 – Review Scoping Document 35 Appendix 2 – The Four-Tiered CAMHS Framework 38 Acknowledgements...»

«EMBASSIES IN INDIA Embassy of Afghanistan in New Delhi, India 5/50F, Shantipath, Chanakyapuri New Delhi 110021 India City: New Delhi Phone: 26883601, 26883602, 24100412,24103331, 26111527, 26875686 Fax: 26875439, 24670486,24671425 Email: embassyafghanistan@yahoo.co.in Working Hours: Monday to Friday 9.30 A.M. to 3.30 P.M. National Day: April 28 Anniversary of the Victory of Jehad Independence day : August 19 Honorary Consulate of Albania in New Delhi, India Sara House, A-31, Hauz Khas New Delhi...»

«GRANDVIEW-WOODLAND COMMUNITY PLAN Neighbourhood Planning through Dialogue Workshop Series Housing CONTENTS Introduction 1 Homelessness and Supportive Housing 17 Non-Market Rental Housing (Social Housing and Co-ops) 21 Market Rental Housing 25 Secondary Suites, Laneway Houses and Rented Condos 30 Home Ownership 34 Grandview-Woodland Community Plan Neighbourhood Planning through Dialogue: Housing Background Package February, 2013 INTRODUCTION Housing is a basic need. The availability of quality,...»

«TRANFORMAÇÕES E RETRANSFORMAÇÕES NO BAIRRO MARACANÃ Andréa de Oliveira Raimundo ­ acadêmico Beatriz Pereira Triane ­ acadêmico Bruno Cunha Vianna ­ acadêmico Carolina de Campos Carvalho ­ acadêmico Eric Quintino Costa ­ acadêmico Jimena Harguindeguy ­ acadêmico Jonathan da Silva Marcelino ­ acadêmico Julio Cesar Ferreira Santos ­ acadêmico Marta do Nascimento Silva ­ acadêmico Pablo Jordão da Silva ­ acadêmico...»

«Merit Aid, College Quality and College Completion: Massachusetts’ Adams Scholarship as an In-Kind Subsidy Sarah R. Cohodes and Joshua S. Goodman∗ By We analyze a Massachusetts merit aid program that gives highscoring students tuition waivers at in-state public colleges with lower graduation rates than available alternative colleges. A regression discontinuity design comparing students just above and below the eligibility threshold finds that students are remarkably willing to forgo college...»

«Lab 1: Getting familiar with LabVIEW: Part I The objective of this first lab is to provide an initial hands-on experience in building a VI. For detailed explanations of the LabVIEW features mentioned here, the reader is referred to [1]. LabVIEW 8.0 can get launched by double clicking on the LabVIEW 8.0 icon. The dialog window shown in Figure 2-17 should appear. Figure 2-17: Starting LabVIEW. 1 L1.1 Building a Simple VI To become familiar with the LabVIEW programming environment, it is found to...»

«WELCOME TO PASSFIELD HALL! We hope you enjoy your stay here. Moving into halls and starting university is an exciting and wonderful time, but we know that right at the start, you’re often faced by a bewildering amount of information. So we’ve put together this small and friendly guide to help you get started and sort out the essentials. You have a fantastic year ahead of you. Enjoy every moment!WELCOME MESSAGE FROM THE PRESIDENT Congratulations on getting your place at the LSE, and...»

«1 SOPHISTIC ARGUMENT Contrasting Views Plato was correct to regard them as masters of illusion who presented men not with the truth but with fictions, images, and “idols,” which they persuaded others to accept as reality. Marcel Detienne, The Masters of Truth in Archaic Greece In his Elements of Logic (1836), Richard Whately conjures up an illogical antagonist with whom to contest his points, particularly on the efficacy of the fallacies. This device constitutes a kind of running dialogue...»

«G. Tecuci, Y. Kodratoff (eds.): Machine Learning and Knowledge Acquisition; Integrated Approaches, Academic Press, 1995, Ch. 8, 99 197-245 Knowledge Acquisition and Learning by Experience The Role of Case-Specific Knowledge Agnar Aamodt University of Trondheim, Department of Informatics, N-7055 Dragvoll, Norway (Email: agnar@ifi.unit.no) Abstract As knowledge-based systems are addressing increasingly complex domains, their roles are shifting from classical expert systems to interactive...»

«~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Back To Home Page ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Dental Care With Oils Testimonials I have a daughter who was considered a high risk dental patient from her first dentist visit. Her baby teeth came in with not enough enamel on them and she would have up to 5 cavities every 6 months even though she brushed, flossed, etc. After her first check up after using Dentarome for 6 months she had NO...»





 
<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.