FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 6 | 7 || 9 | 10 |   ...   | 12 |

«JOURNAL OF SCIENTIFIC EXPLORATION A Publication of the Society for Scienti¢c Exploration Volume 22, Number 1 2008 Page Editorial 1 Editorial Peter ...»

-- [ Page 8 ] --

In an early publication on the reincarnation cases (Stevenson, 1960, Part II of a winning essay in a contest in honor of William James), he opined that the study of alleged memories of a previous lifetime might provide a more plausible means of demonstrating survival than could be had through the study of mediumistic communication. This, he suggested, was because the study of possible reincarnation cases involves trying to find evidence that someone presently living had lived before (and died), whereas in efforts to prove survival via mediumistic communications one must try to find evidence that someone who has died is in some sense still living (see Stevenson, 1960: 117, his concluding statement). In his many years of later work on possible reincarnation cases, he was interested not merely in cognitive content (i.e., possible ‘‘memories’’) related to a putative previous lifetime but also, very importantly, in affective, behavioral, and even presently visible physical influences of the supposed previous lifetime (e.g., birthmarks or deformities). Dispositional psychological/ behavioral evidence, rather than just supposed cognitive-perceptual memories, presumably held special interest for Stevenson because behavioral/affective inclinations, especially those that manifest in everyday life over a long term, may be less likely to be the result of ordinary psi communication. Of course, they also have special relevance to the development of a view of personality that is informed by survival research, something in which Stevenson, as a psychiatrist, certainly had a strong interest. For him, survival research potentially held real meaning for understanding human personality in the present time. I suggest that it was this broader, closer-to-life picture of the meaning of survival that fired in Stevenson a special enthusiasm and resulted in many years of research on this topic. This was true even though he never claimed that he had anything like definitively shown that the cases he studied were due to reincarnation, although he pointed to a variety of lines of what he regarded as convergent evidence favoring the reincarnation hypothesis over alternative ones.

Nonetheless, he always discussed a wide variety of alternate interpretations of the data and frankly, but humbly, noted that in his view the reincarnation interR. Stanford pretation was more plausible for some cases. This brings me to the discussion of Stevenson’s character, which is, in many respects, the most important aspect of my commentary.

There are many things that Stevenson’s life and work can convey to us that should be take-home messages when we think of and honor him and his work.

Please permit me to mention a few, not in any special order:

1. He was an individual of outstanding intellectual honesty, which he greatly valued in others too. Although he personally favored certain interpretations of his data, he did not, as I just noted, overstate his preferred interpretation by claiming that he had ruled out beyond all reasonable doubt any of the many alternate hypotheses that he discussed. Nor did he state or imply that those who disagreed with him were foolish or intellectually dishonest. I suggest that this fairness of spirit and conservatism of statement went a long way toward his being able to present his findings and preferred hypotheses even in a variety of nonparapsychological outlets. I many times saw him look for—and report when he found it—evidence that went contrary to what seemed to be his personal inclinations. In subsequent discussion of it he did not ‘‘gild the lily.’’

2. I worked at his center for five years, and I can say honestly that in addition to his intellectual honesty, he was very honest personally. He greatly valued truthfulness and was not afraid to tell the truth, even when telling it might not be easy.

3. He was uncommonly bold in the areas he was willing personally to investigate and in the audiences to whom he was willing to present his evidence. For example, it requires outstanding courage to claim, especially in certain nonparapsychological publications or meetings, to have evidence suggesting memories of past lifetimes or other kinds of evidence suggesting reincarnation, and Stevenson had all the courage needed to present his evidence and ideas, usually to a scientific audience, but sometimes to a broader one. He had great curiosity about strange events and did not hesitate to study them. Dramatic incidents or reports that some parapsychologists might hesitate to investigate seemed deeply exciting to him, and not investigating them—or, at least, not encouraging others to do so— would have been unthinkable to him.

4. Stevenson presumably would have scored very high on the personality trait of conscientiousness. He very much desired to do tasks carefully, fully, and properly, and he would recruit others in areas that went beyond his knowledge or skills. Most of my work at the University of Virginia was on my own projects, but I collaborated with him on several projects and heard him report his research on many occasions. Based on these experiences, I never had reason to believe that he would even think of doing less than his best on any task, be it planning, investigating, or reporting. I always was confident in working with him that he would, to A Man from Whom We Should Learn 123 the best of his ability, carefully monitor both himself and anyone else involved with the project.

5. A word that could accurately characterize Stevenson is professionalism.

He exemplified all the qualities of professionalism, including conscientiousness (already noted), high standards of professional ethics, and proper social conduct, including fairness and kindness in his dealings with people. He was at one time much involved with developing ethics guidelines for the Parapsychological Association, but, most importantly, he himself exemplified those high standards of professional conduct. He was always very careful in his thinking, writing, speaking, and acting, and he taught his co-workers the importance of these virtues. He often gave practical advice. For example, he noted the importance of ‘‘always leaving a paper trail’’ to document what one did and did not do or say, not leaving things to the vagaries of memory or bias. He sometimes dispensed sage advice on grant getting. He clearly felt a sense of responsibility to himself, to his colleagues, and to his professional disciplines.

6. He may be deemed a superb role model for persons planning to do work in unorthodox areas such as parapsychology, because before he became deeply involved with parapsychology he had already earned a high regard for himself in psychiatry, his profession of training and practice. He had, for example, published a well-respected textbook on psychiatric interviewing (Stevenson, 1960/1971), and he was at one time Chair of the Department of Psychiatry at the University of Virginia School of Medicine. It is extremely wise to establish a very solid reputation in a socio-scientifically more acceptable and traditional area before embarking on parapsychological research and publication. There are reasons for this that are beyond the scope of the present discussion, but there have been other examples of this in the field, both historically and today. What is more, the knowledge derived from other scientific fields can enhance one’s later psi research. Stevenson’s ability to present his work in nonparapsychological journals and meetings undoubtedly was enhanced by his solid reputation in psychiatry and his holding a tenured position in that field.

7. Last, but not least, please do not forget that Stevenson also was able to continue with his work in unorthodox domains because (a) he had a home for it at a respected university and medical school and (b) the funding for it was largely raised by him. I believe he was successful in the latter regard at least in part because of being in such a setting, because of his personal character and accomplishments in psychiatry and in parapsychology, and because he cultivated support by being unafraid to address bold, but potentially very important issues. I must say also that he knew much about how to treat people, including potential donors. That included cultivating donors by being respectful, truthful, and honest in his dealings with them.

He also had many traditional grant-getting skills, and that is something 124 R. Stanford that can be fostered by contact with grant-getting colleagues, usually after having established a home in a grant-getting institution.

Stevenson was an individual who stood out in parapsychology on account of his boldness, courage, and—even by that field’s standards—unorthodox hypotheses. He also stood out because of his success in gaining support. He exemplified in his personal and professional life many qualities that are fundamental and important in any field of science. In my view, he exemplified a professional high road that we too seldom see in any field. By his everyday words and deeds he showed that intellectual boldness can successfully be melded with professional ethics, scientific carefulness, and social responsibility in public discourse. In remembering him, we would do very well to emulate his professionalism, conscientiousness, hard work, and honesty.

It is sad to say goodbye to such an individual, but it is gratifying and edifying to contemplate his example.


Stevenson, I. (1960). The evidence for survival from claimed memories of former incarnations. Part II.

Analysis of the data and suggestions for further investigations. Journal of the American Society for Psychical Research, 54, 95–117.

Stevenson, I. (1968). The combination lock test for survival. Journal of the American Society for Psychical Research, 62, 246–254.

Stevenson, I. (1970). Telepathic impressions: A review and report of thirty-five new cases.

Proceedings of the American Society for Psychical Research, 29, 1–198. (Also published by University Press of Virginia) Stevenson, I. (1971). The Diagnostic Interview (2nd ed.). Harper and Row. (Original work published 1960) Journal of Scientific Exploration, Vol. 22, No. 1, pp. 125–127, 2008 0892-3310/08 Ian Stevenson and the Society for Scientific Exploration

–  –  –

The key role that Ian Stevenson played in the Society for Scientific Exploration came about only as a result of events in two faraway cities: Montreal in Canada and Cambridge in England.

The Cambridge connection dates from 1954 to 1955, when I was a research fellow at St. John’s College. There were two or three visiting scholars that year, and one of them was a Professor of Philosophy from the University of Virginia.

His name was David Yalden-Thomson, born in Scotland and a fiercely proud Scotsman all of his life. David returned to Charlottesville in the summer of 1955, and I was scheduled to move to Stanford in the fall, so David invited me to visit him in Charlottesville after I was settled in California.

I do not remember exactly when my first visit occurred, but I do remember going to a horse race (in a party that included the English philosopher John Wisdom, who was a horse-racing fanatic) and climbing a small mountain called Old Rag (in a party that included David’s future wife Barbara). At that time, I was working in plasma physics rather than astrophysics, so my first contact with the University was with the Physics Department. Some years later, in the 1970s, I met Larry Fredrick while he was Secretary of the American Astronomical Society (AAS). Charlie Tolbert was also an office holder in the AAS, responsible for organizing the Shapley Lecture Series. So during my fairly frequent visits to Charlottesville to visit David and Barbara, I had the privilege of developing a friendship with Larry and Charlie.

Robert Jahn, then Dean of the School of Engineering and Applied Sciences at Princeton University, came to spend a few months of sabbatical leave at Stanford in the spring of 1978. In view of my interest in the UFO problem and the great difficulty I had experienced in getting my articles on that subject reviewed – let alone published – by a scientific journal, I had begun to meditate the need for a new scientific society, and its journal, that would be open to the discussion and publication of work on topics considered improper – or even heretical – by the scientific establishment. Meeting Bob, and learning that he was facing a similar dilemma, had provided the necessary impetus to proceed with such an initiative.

Plans for what became the Society for Scientific Exploration were therefore

125126 P. A. Sturrock

beginning to take shape around 1980, and I already had the generous support of Larry and Charlie at the University of Virginia. However, it was shaping up to be a society heavily weighted by physicists and astronomers, and that would have been unduly restrictive from both an intellectual and a sociological point of view. This is where Ian Stevenson came upon the scene, but that happened only because of events in Montreal.

Ian and David were both alumni of McGill University, to which they were both very attached and of which they were both very proud. This common background led to a strong social connection between David and Ian that developed over the years into a strong and affectionate bond. As a result of this connection, David and Barbara were very familiar with Ian’s bold but meticulous research into evidence ‘‘suggestive of reincarnation’’ (to use Ian’s cautious terminology). Hence, when during a visit to Earlysville (David and Barbara’s new home near Charlottesville) I discussed with them the evolving plans for a new society, David told me about Ian and his remarkable research. I was of course most anxious to meet him.

In due course, David telephoned Ian to ask if he would be willing to meet an ‘‘astrophysicist from Stanford University,’’ and Ian replied that that would be ‘‘quite agreeable.’’ In preparation for the dinner party at which we were to meet, Barbara studied Ian’s recently published book, Twenty Cases Suggestive of Reincarnation, to ensure that we had good discussions during dinner and over brandy (but no cigars!).

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 6 | 7 || 9 | 10 |   ...   | 12 |

Similar works:

«LUBLIN IT UPLAND – THE CASE OF A SMART CITY Kinga Bednarzewska Maria Curie-Sklodowska University, Poland bednarzewska@gmail.com Zbigniew Pastuszak Maria Curie-Sklodowska University, Poland z.pastuszak@umcs.lublin.pl Abstract: The development of information and communication technologies (IS / IT) requires that contemporary cities should improve their functionality. In order to survive the crisis and the ever-changing environment, cities are taking up technological challenges in the field of...»

«Multicultural Rhymes Aruba (Caribbean) Monkey see, monkey do, Monkey get in trouble too. India The cuckoo calls, coo, coo, coo, Don’t touch the mangoes any of you, For I am the mango queen you see, Eating mangoes is for me. Through the jungle the elephant goes, Swaying his trunk to and fro, Munching, crunching, tearing trees, Stamping seeds, eating leaves. His eyes are small, his feet are fat, Hey elephant don’t behave like that. Trinidad & Tobago (Caribbean) One, two, three, four, Johnny...»

«A Geographical Look At The Air Pollution In Malatya MALATYA’DAK HAVA K RL L Ğ NE COĞRAF BAKIŞ∗ A Geographical Look At The Air Pollution In Malatya Doç. Dr. Ramazan SEVER∗∗ ▼ Özet Doğu Anadolu Bölgesi’nin hızla gelişen şehirlerinden biri olan Malatya’da, bu hızlı gelişmeye bağlı olarak, çeşitli çevre sorunları yaşanmaya başlanmıştır. Bu sorunlar arasında etkileri ve boyutları bakımından en önemlisi hava kirliliğidir. Şehirde, özellikle 1984’te...»

«United Nations Development Programme Human Development Report Office OCCASIONAL PAPER Background paper for HDR 2004 “Nation State” or “State Nation”?: Conceptual Reflections and Some Spanish, Belgian and Indian Data Juan J. Linz, Alfred Stepan and Yogendra Yadav 2004/15 UN/HDR2004draft 1 “Nation State” or “State Nation”?: Conceptual Reflections and Some Spanish, Belgian and Indian Data Juan J. Linz, Alfred Stepan and Yogendra Yadav* * Owing to the recent illness of Alfred...»

«CURRICULUM VITAE: Alastair McIntosh (Academic Version, as of March 2013) 26 Luss Road Drumoyne Glasgow G51 3YD Scotland Tel: +44 (0)141 445 8750 mail@AlastairMcIntosh.com www.AlastairMcIntosh.com Full Name: McIntosh, Alastair Iain Date of Birth: 17th November 1955 Current Research and Teaching Interests: Spiritual underpinnings of human ecology, including ontological, epistemological and applied aspects of community empowerment, nonviolence, climate change, sacred natural sites and land reform....»

«Writing Technologies http://www.ntu.ac.uk/writing_technologies/index.html Special issue on Heidegger, writing, and technology Guest edited by James Holden Is SF handwritten? Adam Roberts Writing Technologies 2.2 (2009), 55-69 ISSN 1754-9035 Is SF Handwritten? 55 Is SF handwritten? Adam Roberts I want to start with Heidegger’s late work Was heiβt Denken? (What Is Called Thinking?, 1951-52), and also with the reading of Heidegger Jacques Derrida undertakes in his essay ‘Heidegger’s Hand’...»

«International Journal of Interdisciplinary and Multidisciplinary Studies (IJIMS), 2014, Vol 1, No.6, 151-155. 151 Available online at http://www.ijims.com ISSN: 2348 – 0343 Bamboo flowering and its impact on the Adis of Upper Siang District of Arunachal Pradesh, India Oimang Megu Dept. of Anthropology, Rajiv Gandhi University, Rono Hills, Doimukh, Itanagar,India Abstract Bamboo flowering is always associated with rise of rodent population and ultimately famine. Bamboo flowering not only...»

«Copyright by Joshua Seokhyun Yoon 2016 ABSTRACT In Luke’s two volumes, Luke is not interested only in Gentiles and those with high social status but also in the marginalized and those who are outsiders. This dissertation seeks to read Luke’s concern for outsiders and the theme of the inclusion of outsiders in the new kingdom of God in Luke’s narrative of the Ethiopian eunuch’s conversion in Acts 8:26-40. This paper examines the Ethiopian eunuch’s complex identity from the perspectives...»

«Section 6 Notable Outbreaks and Case Investigations Section 6: Notable Outbreaks and Case Investigations Contents Bacterial Diseases Bacillus anthracis — Imported Inhalation Anthrax — Pinellas County Bordetella pertussis — Fatal Pertussis Infection in a 6-Week-Old Infant — Palm Beach County Bordetella pertussis — Pertussis Outbreak among Unvaccinated Children in an Extended Family — Escambia County Capnocytophaga canimorsus — Fatal Capnocytophaga canimorsus Infection in a...»

«Christern & Co: 1876-1899. Formaci´n de una firma o alemana en Maracaibo Ebelio Esp´ ınola Ben´ ıtez To cite this version: Ebelio Esp´ınola Ben´ıtez. Christern & Co: 1876-1899. Formaci´n de una firma alemana en o Maracaibo. Encuentro de Latinoamericanistas Espa˜oles (12. 2006. Santander): Viejas y n nuevas alianzas entre Am´rica Latina y Espa˜a, 2006, s.l., Spain. CEEIB, pp.88-104. halshse n 00103044 HAL Id: halshs-00103044 https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00103044...»

«Enterprise Transformation CULTURE Rx CULTURAL MALAISE MAY BE STIFLING YOUR CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENT PROGRAMS – WE’VE GOT THE REMEDY AUTHORS As continuous improvement (CI) matures in non-traditional environments such as support services, corporate centers, and white collar functions, new Brian Prentice Philippe Gouel challenges are being faced. Many companies are starting to realize why their CI initiatives aren’t working: Communication is lacking, leadership teams aren’t taking action,...»

«Collected Poems Neilson, John Shaw (1872-1942) A digital text sponsored by Australian Literature Electronic Gateway University of Sydney Library Sydney 2000 http://setis.library.usyd.edu.au/ozlit © University of Sydney Library. The texts and Images are not to be used for commercial purposes without permission Source Text: Prepared against the print edition published by Lothian Book Publishing Company Melbourne and Sydney, 1934 All quotation marks are retained as data. First Published: 1934...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.