FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 25 | 26 || 28 | 29 |   ...   | 39 |

«A Resource Guide for Parents and Teens Developed and Compiled by the Youth Council of the DuPage Workforce Board A Letter to Parents: Your teen’s ...»

-- [ Page 27 ] --

Much of Sorby’s analysis is based on nonrandom samples of students since, after the first year, students opted to take the course rather than being randomly assigned. Therefore, the women who remained in engineering after taking the course may have been more motivated to succeed in engineering to begin with, and the higher retention rate could be a result of their motivation rather than the course. Nonetheless, Sorby’s findings were consistent and compelling enough to convince the departmental chairs and the dean at Michigan Tech to require the spatial-skills course for all students who fail the PSVT:R during orientation,

–  –  –

Sorby believes that well-developed spatial skills can help retain women in engineering and help attract more girls to STEM. She sees well-developed spatial skills as important for creating confidence in one’s ability to succeed in math and science courses and ultimately in a STEM career, because spatial skills are needed to interpret diagrams and drawings in math and science textbooks as early as elementary school. In a pilot study Sorby found that middle school girls who took a spatial-visualization course took more advanced-level math and science courses in high school than did girls who did not take the course. Sorby recommends that this training happen by middle school or earlier to make a difference in girls’ choices.

Sorby’s research shows that with training, women and men achieve consistent and large gains in tests of spatial skills. First-year engineering students, undergraduate students outside engineering, high school students, and middle school students have all shown improvement with training. Sorby’s work demonstrates that spatial skills can indeed be developed through practice.

–  –  –

Parents, AAUW volunteers, and teachers, especially engineering educators, can help young

people, especially girls, develop their spatial skills in the following ways:

–  –  –

Many young women graduate from high school with the skills needed to succeed in majors in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics, yet college-bound women are less likely than men to pursue majors in these fields (National Science Board, 2010). The culture of academic departments in colleges and universities has been identified as a critical issue for women’s success in earning college degrees in STEM fields (National Academy of Sciences, 2007). This chapter profiles two research projects that demonstrate how improving the culture in science and engineering departments can help keep capable female students enrolled in these majors.

Jane Margolis and Allan Fisher’s research on women in computer science at Carnegie Mellon University and Barbara Whitten’s work on women in college physics departments found departmental culture to be a key factor in female students’ decision to remain in or leave these majors. Both projects provide practical ideas for improving the climate at college for female students in STEM. These researchers demonstrate that small changes in recruitment, admissions, and course work and creating and promoting opportunities for positive interactions among students and between students and faculty can make a big difference in students’ experiences.

C U lT U r E o F A Co M P U T E r S C i E n C E d E PA r T M E n T

Margolis and Fisher conducted a four-year study of women and computing at the School of Computer Science at Carnegie Mellon University, one of the premiere schools of computer science in the United States. Between 1995 and 1999 they interviewed more than 100 students multiple times, beginning with the student’s first semester in the computer science department and concluding when the student either graduated or left the major. Margolis and Fisher also held discussions with faculty, examined student journals, and observed classes. At the beginning of their study, women made up only 7 percent of the undergraduate computer Jane Margolis is a senior researcher at the UCLA Graduate School of Education and Information Studies. Through 7 her studies of the gender and race gap in computer science, she examines social inequities in education and how fields become segregated. She is the co-author of two award-winning books, Unlocking the Clubhouse: Women in Computing (MIT Press, 2002) and Stuck in the Shallow End: Education, Race, and Computing (MIT Press, 2008). Allan Fisher is vice president for product strategy and development at the Laureate Higher Education Group. He served until 1999 as faculty member and associate dean for undergraduate education in the School of Computer Science at Carnegie Mellon University and wrote Unlocking the Clubhouse: Women in Computing with Jane Margolis.

AAUW 58 science majors and were almost twice as likely as men were to leave the major (Margolis & Fisher, 2002). As the associate dean for undergraduate computer science education, Fisher was concerned about the attrition of female majors. Margolis was a social scientist with a background in gender and education and an interest in how fields become segregated and was intrigued to understand why so few women study computer science. Margolis and Fisher characterize their work as an “insider-outsider” collaboration.

Departmental culture includes the expectations, assumptions, and values that guide the actions of professors, staff, and students. Individuals may or may not be aware of the influence of departmental culture as they design and teach classes, advise students, organize activities, and take classes. Margolis and Fisher described how the computing culture reflects the norms, desires, and interests of a subset of males—those who take an early interest in computing and pursue it with passion during adolescence and into college. Margolis and Fisher point out that throughout the life cycle “computing is actively claimed as ‘guy stuff ’ by boys and men and passively ceded by girls and women” (ibid., p. 4). This pattern of behavior is influenced by external forces in U.S. culture that associate success in computing more with boys and men than with girls and women and often makes women feel that they don’t belong simply because of their gender. In an interview with AAUW, Margolis explained: “There is a subset of boys and men who burn with a passion for computers and computing. Through the intensity of their interest, they both mark the field as male and enshrine in its culture their preference for single-minded intensity and focus on technology.” Within that environment this particular male model of “doing” computer science becomes the measure of success; however, because young women and men often have different experiences with computers and different motivations to study computer science, this model can alienate women.

Many young men in computer science report having had an immediate and strong engagement with the computer from an early age. That engagement intensified in middle and high school and led the young men to declare a computer science major. On the other hand, many women who are interested in computer science and have similar talent do not report a similar experience. Many of these young women report a more moderate interest in computer science, especially early on, that builds gradually. Distinguishing between an interest in computer science and an interest in computers and technology is important. Historically girls had less interest in and experience both with computers and in computer science. Today women and men are interested in and equally likely to use computers and technology for educational and communication purposes (Singh et al., 2007), but the gender gap in the study of computer science remains.

About three-quarters of the men that Margolis and Fisher interviewed fit the profile of someone with an intense and immediate attraction to computing that started at a young age,

–  –  –

Other researchers concur that feeling like a misfit can lower confidence, especially among women. Female undergraduates often report lower confidence than male undergraduates report in their math or science abilities and their ability to succeed in their STEM major (Seymour & Hewitt, 1997; Cohoon & Aspray, 2006). Even among women and men who have similar grades, women in computer-related majors are less confident than their male peers of their ability to succeed in their major (Singh et al., 2007). Margolis and Fisher also found that the group of female computer science majors who were brimming with confidence and excitement about their major in the earliest interviews were no longer “buzzing” by the second and third semester. Margolis and Fisher (2002, p. 92) argue, “The decline in women’s confidence must be acknowledged as an institutional problem.” Curriculum can also play a role in signaling who belongs in the major. Computer science programs often focus on technical aspects of programming early in the curriculum and leave the broader applications for later. This can be a deterrent to students, both female and male, who may be interested in broader, multidisciplinary applications and especially to women, who are more likely to report interest in these broader applications. As with many changes, Margolis and Fisher found that many men, as well as women, might benefit from a redesigned computing curriculum. In their interviews with Margolis and Fisher, male computer science majors also expressed an interest in the broader applications of computer science; therefore, the researchers argue that defining computer science broadly expands its appeal to both women

and men. In an interview with AAUW, Margolis emphasized:

It is really important to redefine or re-envision [what we mean by computer science] because for so long people thought of computer science as focused on the machine and hacking away at the computer. But computer science is now a discipline that is playing a key role in invention and creation across all sorts of disciplines from biological science to film and animation, and that expansion of the field and how critical it is across all disciplines increasingly makes it more meaningful.

Culture can also influence what faculty, students, and others in the department believe a computer science major should look like. The iconic image of the computer science major was for AAUW 60 many years the asocial “geek”—a person in love with computers, myopically focused on them to the neglect of all else, at the computer 24/7. Although Margolis and Fisher found that female and male students agreed that the overwhelming image of a computer science major at Carnegie Mellon is the geek, more than two-thirds of the women and almost one-third of the men said that the image did not fit them. Yet the geek image was especially damaging to women. One-fifth of the women interviewed questioned whether they belonged in computer science because they did not have that intense connection and focus that they observed in their male peers. According to Margolis and Fisher (2002, p. 71), “The rub for women in computer science is that the dominant computer science culture does not venerate balance of multiple interests. Instead the singular and obsessive interest in computing that is common among men is assumed to be the road to success in computing. This model shapes the assumptions of who will succeed and who ‘belongs’ in the discipline.” Today Margolis and Fisher agree that the geek image has evolved since they concluded their study. As computers and computing have become integrated into other disciplines like digital media, including music and film, the geek image has shifted from that of a socially isolated person to include a chic geek image where it can be cool to know about computers and computing. “Nevertheless, although the geek image and focus have softened, it is still an issue that departments deal with,” Margolis and Fisher said in the AAUW interview.

These factors—the expectations that go along with being a computer geek, coupled with a male-dominated environment and the focus on programming or hacking—can all contribute to an environment and culture that are major deterrents to the recruitment and retention of women. Margolis and Fisher (2002, p. 6) insist that the goal should not be to fit “women into computer science but rather to change computer science.” The majority of the women interviewed, including those who remained in computer science, expressed dissatisfaction with the culture of the discipline. Margolis and Fisher stress that departments should pay attention to the student experience to improve recruitment and retention of women and that having diverse faculty is also critical (see figure 19).

As a result of Margolis and Fisher’s work, the School of Computer Science at Carnegie Mellon implemented several changes that helped create a more welcoming culture and improved the recruitment and retention of female students. The proportion of incoming female students increased from 7 percent in 1995, the first year of the study, to 42 percent in 2000. Retention of women also improved during that period (Margolis & Fisher, 2002).

–  –  –

Source: Margolis, J., & Fisher, A., 2002, Unlocking the clubhouse: Women in computing (Cambridge: Massachusetts Institute of Technology), p. 139.

–  –  –

Margolis and Fisher offer computer science departments the following recommendations.

These could also apply to departments in other STEM disciplines that want to attract and retain diverse and talented students.

–  –  –

• Address p eer cult ure.

Peer culture within a department has a tremendous effect on students’ experiences and is determined primarily by how students treat and relate to one another. Faculty should, therefore, pay attention to peer culture to ensure that no student clique (for example, hackers) dominates or becomes the ideal way of being in the major.

• Broaden the scop e of ear l y course work.

Offer introductory courses that show the wide variety of computer science applications and a curricular pathway to complete the degree that does not assume years of computer science experience.

–  –  –

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 25 | 26 || 28 | 29 |   ...   | 39 |

Similar works:

«Sustainability Management Accounting System (SMAS): Towards a Conceptual Design for the Manufacturing Industry Abstract The study reported in this paper aims to identify an effective management accounting system using sustainability accounting concept for environmental and social cost measurement to add value to organizations. The motivation for undertaking this research is driven by the current practice of activity based costing (ABC), which has not identified and allocated costs of...»

«3rd SPREP Meeting on Climate Change & Sea Level Rise in the Pacific, ORSTOM, Nouméa, 1997 APPROACHES TO VULNERABILITY ASSESSMENT ON PACIFIC ISLAND COASTS: EXAMPLES FROM SOUTHEAST VITI LEVU (FIJI) AND SOUTH TARAWA (KIRIBATI) D.L. Forbes1 & S.M. Solomon1 South Pacific Applied Geoscience Commission [SOPAC], PMB/GPO, Suva, Fiji 1 present address: Geological Survey of Canada, Bedford Institute of Oceanography, 1 Challenger Drive (POB 1006), Dartmouth, Nova Scotia, Canada B2Y 4A2...»

«ADNAN KASMAN ÖZGEÇMİŞ Adres Dokuz Eylül Üniversitesi, İşletme Fakültesi, İktisat Bölümü, Kaynaklar Yerleşkesi Tinaztepe 35160 Buca-Izmir Phone : (232) 412 8209 Fax : (232) 453 5062 E-mail: adnan.kasman@deu.edu.tr, EĞİTİM 1994-1999 Vanderbilt Üniversitesi, Nashville, Tennessee ABD Doktora Ekonomi 1994-1997 Vanderbilt Üniversitesi, Nashville, Tennessee ABD Yüksek LisansEkonomi 1993-1994 Western Michigan Üniversitesi, Kalamazoo, Michigan ABD Yüksek LisansUygulamalı Ekonomi...»

«The Changing Content in the Short Stories of Zakariyya Tamir The Changing Content in the Short Stories of Zakariyya Tamir1 Yaseen Kittani 1. Introduction The development of the literary products of Zakariyya Tamir is framed within modernism. The writer does not move from one literary school to another. Rather, he remains within the same narrative trend he started since his first story at the late fifties. The development of the content of his stories, however, is achieved through withdrawing...»

«Enjoy your double Lyndall Clipstone University of Adelaide This paper explores the uncanny status of the moral monster as Other in Vladimir Nabokov’s 1955 novel Lolita. Using Jameson’s concept of the ‘quilting point’ as a collective site of cultural anxiety, it will examine the constructions of moral monstrosity as a projection of cultural tensions. In Grimaces of the Real, Žižek examines the concept of the ‘double’ in relation to the uncanny, writing that ‘The double is “the...»

«CAMP GLEN ARDEN TUXEDO, NC Since 1951 CAMPER/PARENT HANDBOOK ALL FORMS ARE DUE BY May 15th PRINTABLE FORMS ARE ONLINE Camp Glen Arden P.O. Box 7 Tuxedo, NC 28784 1261 Cabin Creek Road Zirconia, NC 28790 office@campglenarden.com www.campglenarden.com (828) 692-8362 phone (828) 692-6259 fax TABLE OF CONTENTS Our Mission..page 1 Camp Fees..page 2 Activities at Glen Arden.page 3 Travel Information..page 3, 4 Packing for Camp..page 4, 5, 6 A Note from the Nurse..page 6, 7 Helpful Information..page...»

«May 5, 2016 Vol.1, No.1 APNNS NEWS Autumn in Kyoto City Shinnyodo (Shinsho-Gokurakuji temple) See Page 10: Information on the 23rd International Conference on Neural Information Processing (ICONIP), the Annual Conference of Asia-Pacific Neural Network Society (APNNS) Vol.1, No.1 (May 2016) Table of Contents 1. President’s message 2. Society Structure 3. Membership Information 4. Column: AlphaGo and Sedol Lee Heralded a New Era 5. ICONIP 2016 Kyoto 5.1 Kyoto in autumn 5.2 Conference...»

«Authors’ Pre-print Manuscript Effect of Handrail Shape on Graspability by Donald O. Dusenberry, Howard Simpson, and Steven J. DelloRusso Simpson Gumpertz & Heger Inc. Accepted for Publication in Applied Ergonomics Elsevier Amsterdam, The Netherlands Anticipated publication: early 2009 Manuscript Effect of Handrail Shape on Graspability Donald O. Dusenberry, Howard Simpson, ScD, and Steven J. DelloRusso Simpson Gumpertz & Heger Inc. 41 Seyon Street, Building 1, Suite 500 Waltham, MA 02453...»

«'Growl more softly, you machines; Because the White men are as stone. Can you, of iron, not be gentler? Hush your roaring in the mines And hear what we would say to you When that far day, now hidden, dawns, And we, at last, will cry: Machines! You are ours, the Black men's, now! wide range of craftwork kaftans unusual gifts constant exhibitions W A L S H M A R A B GALLERY n P A B H Y R Q A D D U R B A N / PHONE G63S1 130LC MAY, 1974 No. 10 EDITORS : MIKE KIRKWOOD TONY MORPHET POETRY 2...»

«1 By Ryan Hodson Foreword by Daniel Jebaraj 2 Copyright © 2014 by Syncfusion Inc. 2501 Aerial Center Parkway Suite 200 Morrisville, NC 27560 USA All rights reserved. I mportant licensing information. Please read. This book is available for free download from www.syncfusion.com on completion of a registration form. If you obtained this book from any other source, please register and download a free copy from www.syncfusion.com. This book is licensed for reading only if obtained from...»

«115 Winter Street, Troy, NY 12180 283-2420 November 2013 May 2015 John J. McAuley Jr., Pastor Website: www.thirdchurchtroy.org A Study of the Ten Commandments: Part 4 Exodus 20:8-11 “The Day the Lord Has Made” Remember the Sabbath day by keeping it holy. Six days you shall labor and do all your work, but the seventh day is a Sabbath to the LORD your God. On it you shall not do any work, neither you, nor your son or daughter, nor your manservant or maidservant, nor your animals, nor the...»

«SANTIAGO DE COMPOSTELA Y KUMANO, DOS PEREGRINACIONES HERMANAS ANTE UN NUEVO MILENIO MARILÓ R. DEL ALISAL ESCUELA OFICIAL DE IDIOMAS DE MADRID, DEPARTAMENTO DE JAPONÉS, ESPAÑA PRESIDENTA DE LA FUNDACIÓN INSTITUTO DE JAPONOLOGÍA EllO de diciembre de 1993 el Camino de Santiago fue declarado Patrimonio de la Humanidad por la Unesco; desde el año 1998 se halla hermanado con el Camino de Kumano, en Japón. Esta amplia zona en la prefectura de Wakayama que forma el Parque Natural de Kumano....»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.