FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 30 | 31 || 33 | 34 |   ...   | 49 |


-- [ Page 32 ] --

The following chapter extends this discussion by presenting a model to help understanding and to pinpoint specific, practical ways through which the teacher development process can be improved. A component of this model is a typology of trainee primary teachers in relation to PE which is an outcome of the data analysis process. Whilst chapters 5 and 6 separately explored the phenomena from individual and external structure perspectives, each element is brought together within the model so that the combined effect of both dispositions and structural factors is made explicit. The typology itself exemplifies trainees’ dispositions and experiences seen within this study and suggests ways in which the possibilities of action can be developed beyond the currently limited opportunity for a few trainees who begin ITT with an already positive disposition towards the subject. The model, and consideration of training needs for different trainees across the typology, enables a range of recommendations to be made to better support the development of all trainees as teachers of primary PE during ITT and within CPD opportunities.

–  –  –


Introduction Chapters 5 and 6 developed an understanding of dispositional and structural influences on trainee primary teacher experiences during PEITT; this chapter considers in detail the dual influence of structures and disposition and the relationship between each. In doing so the third research question is addressed with particular reference to structuration theory introduced in

chapter 4:

How does primary ITT impact on the development of trainee primary teachers as teachers of primary PE and how can provision be developed to better support trainee primary teachers in this regard?

This question necessitated viewing the trainees’ lived experiences of primary PEITT from the interrelated perspectives of dispositional and structural elements to fully understand how these work in tandem to enable or constrain practice for trainee primary teacher development. By approaching the issues from this perspective, several implications for the development of primary PEITT are highlighted.

The discussion in this chapter is supported by a detailed exploration of 5 individual trainees’ experiences during ITT and the relationship between structures, disposition and practice in each case. As discussed in Chapter 4 (and as detailed in appendix 9), the research was centred on a decreasing sample of respondents who were studying a three year, undergraduate, ITT course. The PSPP and PIP scales, administered to 83 trainee teachers at the outset of the investigation and the ITT course, yielded data regarding dispositions which suggested themes for further investigation through subsequent qualitative enquiry. In particular, the patterns and trends identified within the PSPP and PIP data supported the initial identification of ‘types’ of trainee primary teacher in relation to PE. As the research progressed and the number of participants decreased, the qualitative data informed the development and refinement of this typology, taking account of the dynamic relationship between structure and disposition in individual trainees’ experiences. Twenty four trainees took part in group interviews (Stage 1b); fifteen trainees participated in the first individual semi structured interviews (Stage 1c). In Stage 2 of the research, the number of respondents reduced from fifteen to fourteen and then to six, enabling a detailed qualitative exploration of experiences. These six trainees (Becky, James, Kay, Leanne, Ria and Sarah) participated throughout each stage of the investigation;

five of this group are the focus of the detailed discussion and analysis in this chapter. Four of these trainees (James, Kay, Leanne, Becky) each represent a specific type of trainee, whilst the fifth (Sarah), demonstrates the dynamic nature of the structure, disposition, practice relationship; Sarah is a trainee who straddles two of the four categories within the typology.

The sixth, Ria, is not included as a case study in this chapter; data collected and analysed in relation to this trainee confirmed findings represented by the others trainees and analysis of this data here would be repetitious. During Stages 3 and 4, the sample was broadened again (to eight, twenty six and finally one hundred and twenty) to test, refine and confirm the typology and theoretical representation of the relationship between structure, disposition and practice.

In Stage 4, a draft typology and theoretical representation of the relationship between disposition, structure and practice was shared with the original eighty three respondents and, a year later following further amendments, with one hundred and twenty final year trainee teachers at a different institution. Feedback received during the final stage of the investigation supported refinement of both the typology and understanding of the relationship between structures, disposition and practice.

The dynamic relationship between structures, disposition and practice As discussed in chapters 5 and 6, a range of factors has been seen to influence the experiences and practice of trainee teachers in this study. For each of the five detailed cases, a highly individualised, complex and multi-layered relationship between structures, dispositions, and practice was observed. The properties of primary PEITT have been shown to be a medium and outcome of the practices they recursively organise (Giddens, 1984, p. 25), neither the actions of the trainees nor the influence of the ITT structure independently offer sufficient explanation for the observed phenomena. The structures of primary PEITT, themselves the outcome of earlier actions, pre-existed and placed conditions of action on the trainees. However, the experiences of trainees in this study also demonstrated potential for individuals to ‘do otherwise’ by drawing on a set of particular ‘rules and resources’ which became available through social interaction (Giddens, 1979). There is a balance, therefore, between structures placing constraints on individual trainee actions and the potential for individual choices and decisions to be made; this relationship did not always lead to a tension or dissonance and the structures are viewed as either enabling or constraining in this regard.

The experiences of each trainee within the study have not been linear or entirely predictable, although identified patterns and trends suggest that trainees fall within generalized categories, or types. In any one trainee’s case, however, the extent to which disposition or a specific element of the ITT structure becomes the key influencing factor in determining practice is highly individualised and care should be taken to ensure that the dynamic nature of the model is acknowledged. The relationship between structures, disposition and practice is conceptualised in figure 7.1 as a series of dials, the relative position of each for individual trainees being determined by a wide range of factors.

Figure 7.1: A model of structures, disposition and practice in primary PEITT The model shown in figure 7.

1 enables a range of practice to be envisaged as an outcome of the relationship between disposition and structures, as disposition interacts with various elements of ITT, other people within ITT, and wider influences. As shown in figure 7.1, a central dial represents the range of dispositions towards PE and sport shown by the trainees, categorised as positive, negative or ambivalent. This range of dispositions, as discussed in chapter 5, is strongly linked to previous life experiences, including the trainees’ own experiences of PE as school pupils. Moving outwards from the dispositional centre, five further dials represent the range of structural factors which have been identified within ITT, namely elements of the university course, school based practice, the influence of other people and the effect of prevailing policies (for example, the curriculum and subject strategies) as discussed in chapter 6. The ordering of these dials may be different in each trainee’s case as particular factors assume greater or lesser degrees of importance at any particular stage. Some factors evident within a particular dial, such as an immediate exposure to the teaching of PE in school following university lectures, may foster the development of disposition in a more immediate way than others. Similarly, other dials will have very little bearing on trainee disposition where particular practices are not evident within immediate experiences.

The outer dial of the model represents the range of practices demonstrated by the trainees in the investigation. This is made up of four generalised categories, each of which is typified by specific practices and particular learning and development needs. This outer dial represents a typology of trainees in primary PEITT, the categories of which include all trainees observed within this study. The dynamic structure of this model suggests potential for changes to disposition or structural influences to result in a trainee’s practice becoming more recognisable as a different ‘type’. The boundaries between the types are shown as dotted lines to represent the possibility of change and the prospect of movement between types as a consequence of particular experiences. The exact positioning of trainees within the typology is dependent upon the relative positions of dispositional and structural factors. In this way, it is possible to imagine each dial moving as a consequence of particular factors and experiences, combining to create a constraining or enabling influence on trainee teacher development in PE.

Case studies Kay: a confirmed avoider At the outset of the ITT course, Kay exhibited a very negative disposition towards PE and sport. This was indicated by low PSW score (6, being the lowest possible score, shared with 2 other students in the sample of 83), along with a low sport competence (6, being the lowest possible score, shared with 2 other students) and low PIP sport importance score (2, being the lowest, shared with 6 other students). Factors influencing disposition were seen to include negative personal experiences in school PE and sport and a lack of wider life experiences that were seen in other cases to impact positively on disposition. Kay’s prior experiences in PE and sport concur with the notion of an influential apprenticeship as an influence on learning to teach (Curtner-Smith, Hastie & Kinchin, 2008; Rusznyak, 2009), a phenomenon which was seen to have enduring impact for Kay throughout the ITT experience. Despite this very negative starting point, Kay tolerated compulsory PE lectures in year 1 of the ITT course,

confessing to being a little surprised that the experience was, at times, enjoyable:

I wasn’t looking forward to it, but the tutor was quite sympathetic and we were all pretty much in the same boat… well at least the students who I worked with were all quite like me really, not sure about it… The sporty ones were doing things a bit faster, but I just took my time and actually learnt quite a lot of tips (Stage 1b).

As a consequence of this course, Kay acknowledged that PE had some importance for children and demonstrated an improved awareness of the PESSCL strategy. For Kay, the importance of

PE was rationalised for its health benefits. She explained that:

I have got some ideas now that I could use in school, although I am not sure what I’ll remember in the future and I am not sure whether I’ll be any more confident in teaching PE in school. The tutor explained that there is a big push about PE and sport at the moment, so we’ll see, but it is important, what with obesity and those concerns (Stage 1b).

In this way, Kay’s disposition was seen to change slightly; within figure 7.1, the central dial can be perceived to turn so that a less negative stance is evident as a consequence of PE lectures during the university course. Although Kay’s experiences in compulsory lectures were more positive than she initially anticipated, the on-going structure of the course did not allow sufficient time for negative prior experiences in PE to be the rich resource for exploration advocated by Brown and McNamara (2011). Kay completed the PE course without

experiencing the full range of NC activity areas and this itself raised questions in her mind:

The lectures did give me some ideas and I think I might be able to go back to my notes if I had to teach PE…but not in all areas…to be honest though, I am still not confident and it’s going to take more than this to make me into a PE teacher.

It was alright, but I still feel that it just isn’t me… it’s not where I feel comfortable (Stage 1c).

The structure of the NCPE, based on six activity areas, was therefore seen to be problematic, raising concerns regarding the extent to which Kay felt confident and able to teach all activity areas. Linked to prior experiences, Kay perceived the subject as being akin to sport, characterised by competition, performance and physical prowess. This was further reinforced through course documentation, such as the PE audit (appendix 13) which placed an emphasis on the activity-based structure of PE. Unsurprisingly, Kay did not elect to study further PE modules in years 2 and 3 of the course, and was not encouraged by professionals in the ITT context to do so. Although a movement of Kay’s dispositional dial was originally perceived as a consequence of PE lectures, the overall impact of the university PE course and NCPE structure restricted and negated this potential for change. The dispositional dial can be perceived to slip back into a firmly negative position as a result of these experiences.

This constraining effect was also seen through the impact of school-based experiences, which served to highlight the role of current educational policy. Kay’s experiences in school were largely devoid of PE related opportunities, a consequence of the remodelled workforce and various class teachers’ practice. In year 1, Kay was placed in a school where external coaches taught PE lessons during PPA time. This confirmed the impact of the remodelled workforce previously noted by others (e.g. Lavin et al., 2008; Griggs, 2010) who claimed that this had led to a dramatic increase in the number of adults other than teachers working in primary PE.

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 30 | 31 || 33 | 34 |   ...   | 49 |

Similar works:

«1 Voorwoord Met trots presenteren wij het locatiespecifieke pedagogisch werkplan van KDV De Globetrotters. Dit is een uitwerking van het werkplan kinderdagverblijf welke van toepassing is op al onze kinderdagverblijven en onderdeel is van het algemeen pedagogisch beleid van SKS Alles Kids. In dit werkplan laten wij zien hoe wij bij KDV De Globetrotters te werk gaan. SKS Alles Kids geeft kinderen de “vijf”. Wij bedoelen hiermee, dat wij werken vanuit vijf speerpunten en dit in praktijk...»

«AN ANALYSIS OF TEACHER ACTION RESEARCH FOCUSED ON DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTION FOR STUDENT SUBGROUPS IN ONE FLORIDA SCHOOL DISTRICT IN 2009-2010 by MICHELLE MARIE MADDEN B.S. University of Central Florida, 1998 M.B.A University of Central Florida, 2004 A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Education in the School of Teaching, Learning, and Leadership in the College of Education at the University of Central Florida Orlando, Florida Fall...»

«Just So Stories Karina Maceczek Kmaceczek@aol.com P.S. 200 The Benson Elementary School 1940 Benson Ave Brooklyn NY, 11214 (718) 236 –5466 For more information, contact: Teachers Network IMPACT II Program Attn: Peter A. Paul 285 West Broadway New York, NY 10013 Phone: (212) 966-5582 Fax: (212) 941-1787 E-mail: ppaul@teachersnetwork.org Web Site: www.teachersnetwork.org Just So Stories Karina Maceczek CSD20 P.S. 200 Program Overview..2 ? ? Resources ? ? Implementation ? ? Elements of the unit...»

«International Exchange Programmes Fact Sheet 2014-2015 Lille & Nice Campus ADDRESSES: LILLE CAMPUS: 24 avenue Gustave Delory, CS 50411, 59057 Roubaix Cedex 1, France NICE CAMPUS: 393 Promenade des Anglais, BP 3116, 06202 Nice Cedex 3, France LOCATIONS: International Campus in Lille : Following an extensive search for the perfect location, EDHEC has chosen to build its new Lille International Campus on an exceptional site of 21 acres. Located in the heart of the Greater Lille metropolis, just...»

«SERVICE-LEARNING: MOTIVATIONS FOR K-12 TEACHERS Marjori Maddox Krebs A Dissertation Submitted to the Graduate College of Bowling Green State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF EDUCATION December 2006 Committee: Judy Jackson May, Advisor Jean Gerard Graduate Faculty Representative Mark A. Earley Dianna Lindsay © 2006 Marjori Maddox Krebs All Rights Reserved iii ABSTRACT Judy Jackson May, Advisor The purpose of this dissertation is to describe the...»

«The Impacts of Personal Counseling on Stress, Academic Success, and Retention in Community College Students by Jenna Welsh A Social Work 298 Special Project Presented to the Faculty of the School of Social Work San José State University In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Social Work Professor Kathy Lemon Osterling Field Instructor Barry Goldman-Hall April, 2009 2 Abstract This research focused on the impacts of personal counseling on stress, academic...»

«WHEN IS A FORMAL ASSESSMENT PLAN NECESSARY IN EITHER RTI OR TRADITIONAL ENVIRONMENTS? Diana Browning Wright When student(s) are observed, interviewed or tested, school staff must consider whether parental informed consent for these procedures is required. IDEA 2004 does allow “screening” procedures without parental permission, such as determining phonemic awareness proficiency and other progress monitoring activities necessary to inform instructional programming. Many schools are beginning...»

«AADTC Spring 2016 Class List This document has 7 pages, registration forms are on pages 6+7. For Puppy Orientation or club information call 734-995-2801 or go to www.aadtc.org “*” One asterisk (*) Classes have NO DOGS FIRST NIGHT. PLEASE READ CLASS DESCRIPTIONS PLEASE CHECK THE WEBSITE FOR CHANGES OR ADDITIONS Section Class Instructor # weeks Starts Day Time Room # Cost 000 PuppyOrientation(10-18 wks) multiple 6 weeks 1st &3rd Friday 7:45-9 PM Rm 3&4 $10/wk 001...»

«Yogis, Destiny and the Wheel of Time K.N. Rao Contents • Preface • Preface to the Second Edition • Chapter 1 That Great Guru • Chapter 2 A Profile of Guru's Life • Chapter 3 Prabhu Bejoy Krishna Goswami • Chapter 4 I Meet My Guru • Chapter 5 Awakened Kundalini • Chapter 6 Astrological Instruction • Chapter 7 Pre-destination: The Negative Side • Chapter 8 Rokadia Hanuman Baba • Chapter 9 My Jyotish Guru-I • Chapter 10 My Jyotish Guru-II • Chapter 11 Pre-destination and...»

«The Hungarian who taught mathematics to tribal Papuans Original article in Hungarian by Anna Mécs http://index.hu/tudomany/2014/03/28/dienes_zoltan/ English translation by Adam Klein. Edited by Bruce Dienes. Zoltán Dienes, who inspired the thinking of children throughout the world with his mathematical games, passed away this January at the age of 97. A mathematics teacher, sometimes also called a magician, he wanted to protect students from the misery that was in wait for them in classrooms,...»

«Advancing Schools and Communities for Student Success Proudly serving the Public School Districts of Northwest Florida since 1967 CALHOUN – FAMU D.R.S. – FRANKLIN – GADSDEN – GULF – HOLMES – JACKSON JEFFERSON – LIBERTY – MADISON – TAYLOR – WAKULLA – WALTON – WASHINGTON PANHANDLE AREA EDUCATIONAL CONSORTIUM What is PAEC? The Panhandle Area Educational Consortium (PAEC) is Florida’s first, legislatively created Educational Consortium, founded in 1967 as a support unit to...»

«The Riches of Divine Wisdom Myrtlefield Expositions Myrtlefield Expositions provide insights into the thought-flow and meaning of the biblical writings, motivated by devotion to the Lord who reveals himself in the Scriptures. Scholarly, engaging, and accessible, each book addresses the reader’s mind and heart to increase faith in God and to encourage obedience to his Word. Teachers, preachers and all students of the Bible will find the approach to Scripture adopted in these volumes both...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.