WWW.DISSERTATION.XLIBX.INFO
FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials
 
<< HOME
CONTACTS



Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |   ...   | 75 |

«Date:_ Approved: _ Richard B. Hays, Supervisor _ Douglas Campbell _ Mark Goodacre _ Stephen Chapman Dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of ...»

-- [ Page 1 ] --

Sons, Seed, and Children of Promise in Galatians:

Discerning the Coherence in Paul’s Model of Abrahamic Descent

by

Bradley R. Trick

Department of Religion

Duke University

Date:_______________________

Approved:

___________________________

Richard B. Hays, Supervisor

___________________________

Douglas Campbell

___________________________

Mark Goodacre

___________________________

Stephen Chapman Dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of Religion in the Graduate School of Duke University 2010

ABSTRACT

Sons, Seed, and Children of Promise in Galatians:

Discerning the Coherence in Paul’s Model of Abrahamic Descent by Bradley R. Trick Department of Religion Duke University Date:_______________________

Approved:

___________________________

Richard B. Hays, Supervisor ___________________________

Douglas Campbell ___________________________

Mark Goodacre ___________________________

Stephen Chapman An

Abstract

of a dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of Religion in the Graduate School of Duke University 2010 Copyright by Bradley R. Trick 2010 Abstract The central portion of Paul’s letter to the Galatians consists of three main arguments, each of which invokes a different image of Abrahamic descent: sons (3:7) in 3:6-14, seed (3:16, 29) in 3:15-4:11, and children of promise (4:28) in 4:21-5:1. Current interpretations of these Abrahamic appeals typically portray them as logically problematical, collectively inconsistent, and/or generally unpersuasive, a situation that then leads most scholars to identify them as ad hoc responses to the Galatian agitators.

This inability to find a coherent model of Abrahamic descent in Galatians, however, threatens to undermine the very gospel itself by suggesting that it cannot effectively counter a Judaizing call that derives from a simple appeal to Abraham.

This dissertation argues that Paul does indeed present the Galatians with a coherent account of Abrahamic descent that accords with his persuasive intent of refuting a law-based circumcision. Its key insight lies in the suggestion that Paul understands the Abrahamic διαθήκη in 3:15-18 as akin to a Hellenistic adoptive testament. As a result, the promised Abrahamic seed must be both a son of Abraham and, because of Abraham’s divine adoption through the διαθήκη, a son of God, hence Paul’s identification of Christ as Abraham’s sole seed (3:16).

This twofold nature of the Abrahamic seed then suggests a distinction in Paul’s other terms for Abrahamic descent. The dissertation accordingly contends that “sons of Abraham” in 3:7 designates, as it typically did in the mid-first century C.E., the Jews, i.e., those physical descendants of Abraham who also share his faith. In contrast, “children of

–  –  –

blessing, i.e., the Spirit of sonship that makes them children of God. Each group thus requires incorporation into Christ to establish their status as Abrahamic seed: the Jews so that they might share in the gentiles’ divine sonship, the gentiles so that they might share in the Jews’ Abrahamic sonship. This interdependent union of the Jewish sons of Abraham and the gentile sons of God in Christ then constitutes the single divine Abrahamic seed who inherits (3:29).

Paul employs this model to refute the necessity of law observance as follows. In 3:6-14, he argues that Christ’s accursed death on the cross divides faith from law observance as a means of justification for Jews; the full sons of Abraham accordingly become those Jews who, by dying to the law and embracing Christ, exhibit the same radical trust in God as their forefather exhibited. In 3:15-4:11, he argues that God added the law and its curse to ensure that the Jews could not receive the Abrahamic blessing promised to the nations—i.e., the Spirit that would make the Jews sons of God and, thus, Abrahamic seed—apart from the one seed, Christ. Finally, in 4:21-5:1, he argues that, like Hagar, the non-adoptive Sinaitic διαθήκη produces Abrahamic descendants (i.e., non-Christian Jews) who share the general human enslavement to the στοιχεῖα, whereas the adoptive Abrahamic διαθήκη produces Abrahamic descendants (i.e., Christian Jews) whose divine adoption frees them from this enslavement. Each appeal to Abraham thus undermines the gentile Christians’ motivation for submitting to the law by demonstrating that Jewish Christians do not even remain under the law.

–  –  –

Abstract

Acknowledgments

1. Sons, seed, and children of promise: Abrahamic descent in Galatians

1.1 The challenge of Abrahamic descent in Galatians

1.2 Paul’s persuasive intent as a crucial constraint on interpretations of his Abrahamic arguments

1.3 Identifying a coherent model of Abrahamic descent that accords with Paul’s persuasive intent

2. “These are sons of Abraham”: Jewish sonship and the Abrahamic blessing of the gentiles in Galatians 3:6-14





2.1 Introduction

2.2 Galatians 3:6-7: Justification by faith as the basis of Jewish Abrahamic sonship

2.2.1 The role of 3:6 in Paul’s argument: Establishing 3:6-7 as a deductive argument for sonship based on Abraham’s example of justification by faith..........48 2.2.1.1 Problems with 3:5-6 as an inductive argument

2.2.1.2 The coherence of 3:6-7 as a deductive argument that appeals to the authority of Abraham’s example rather than the authority of scripture.................53 EXCURSUS: Douglas Campbell and the nature of “justification by faith”..........65 2.2.2 Problems with 3:6-7 as a christological argument for gentile sonship............71 2.2.3 Putting it all together: The case for Jewish sonship in 3:6-7

2.3 Galatians 3:8-10: God justifies the gentiles by faith apart from law

2.3.1 Problems with 3:8-9 as an argument from Abraham

–  –  –

EXCURSUS: Problems with 3:8-9 as an argument from experience..................108 2.3.1.2 Problems determining the function of the conclusion in 3:9

2.3.1.3 Problems understanding why ὅσοι ἐξ ἔργων νόµου are under a curse in 3:10

2.3.2 Resolving the problems: 3:8-10 as an argument from the integrity of scripture for the gentiles’ justification by faith

2.4 Galatians 3:11-12: Jewish justification also ultimately rests on faith, not law observance

2.4.1 Galatians 3:11 as a reference to Jewish—not Christian—justifying faith.....159 2.4.2 Galatians 3:12 as an argument for faith’s primacy over—not independence from—law

2.5 Galatians 3:13-14: The christological twist

2.5.1 The C-C´ twist (3:11-12, 3:13): Freeing the Jews from (the curse of) the law

2.5.2 The B-B´ twist (3:8-10, 3:14a): So to the gentiles the blessing might come in Christ

2.5.3 The A-A´ twist (3:6-7, 3:14b): So the Jews might receive the promised Spirit of sonship

2.6 Conclusion

3. “One [seed], who is Christ”: Abrahamic inheritance, the law, and the dual sonship of the Abrahamic seed in 3:15-4:11

3.1 Introduction

3.2 “One [seed], who is Christ”: Testamentary adoption and the identification of Christ as Abraham’s seed in 3:15-4:11

3.2.1 The historical viability of Greek testamentary adoption as a potential background for Gal 3:15-4:11

–  –  –

3.2.3 The Greek background of Paul’s adoption (υἱοθεσία) language..................255 3.2.4 Greek testamentary adoption as the overarching background for Gal 3:15Testamentary adoption and the identification of Christ as Abraham’s sole seed

3.3 “Not... as concerning many but as concerning one”: The singular seed and the elimination of the law as a basis for the promised inheritance in Gal 3:15-20....288 3.3.1 The structural unity of Gal 3:15-20

3.3.2 The law’s inability to cancel the promise inherent in the earlier Abrahamic διαθήκη in 3:17-18

3.3.3 The singular seed in Gal 3:16 and the plurality of Israelites who receive the law in Gal 3:19-20

3.4 “Until the seed should come”: The united Abrahamic seed as the fulfillment and end of the law in Gal 3:19a and 3:21-4:11

3.4.1 “It was added for the sake of transgressions”: The twofold role of the law in promoting both faith and Christ according to Gal 3:19, 21-22

3.4.2 “All of you are one in Christ Jesus... You are Abraham’s seed”: The dual nature of Abraham’s single seed and the end of the law in Gal 3:23-4:11.....330 3.4.2.1 “We are no longer under [law]”: Implications for Jews of gentiles’ becoming sons of Abraham in Christ (Gal 3:23-29)

3.4.2.2 “You are no longer slaves”: Implications for gentiles of Jews’ becoming sons of God in Christ (Gal 4:1-11)

3.5 Conclusion

4. “You are children of promise”: The gentile children according to Isaac and the Jewish children of the free woman in Galatians 4:21-5:1

4.1 Introduction

–  –  –

4.2.1 The Sinaitic διαθήκη: A non-adoptive testament failing to liberate its charges from the στοιχεῖα rather than a covenant enslaving them to the law.......403 4.2.1.1 The enslavement associated with the Sinaitic διαθήκη

4.2.1.2 Situating a Sinaitic enslavement to the στοιχεῖα in the flow of Paul’s argument

4.2.2 The Abrahamic διαθήκη: An adoptive testament enabling entrance into the free Jerusalem above according to Isa 54:1

4.2.3 “These women are... διαθῆκαι”: The typological nature of a testamentary reading in Gal 4:24-27

4.2.4 Conclusion

4.3 Identifying the free children of promise: Distinguishing non-Christian Jews, Christian Jews, and Christian gentiles as sons of Abraham in Gal 4:21-5:1.............468 4.3.1 Problems with a two-column approach to Gal 4:21-5:1

4.3.2 Sons of the slave woman and sons of the free woman in Gal 4:24-27:

Distinguishing non-Christian Jews and Christian Jews as sons of Abraham.........484 4.3.3 Sons of flesh and sons of promise in Gal 4:28: Distinguishing Jews and gentile Christians as sons of Abraham

4.3.4 Merging the typologies in Gal 4:29-30: The union of Jew and gentile in Christ as the true fulfillment of the free woman’s children of promise..................496 4.3.4.1 Galatians 4:29: Locating Jewish Christians in the flesh (Jew) / promise (gentile Christian) typology

4.3.4.2 Galatians 4:30: Locating gentile Christians in the slave (non-Christian Jew) / free (Christian Jew) typology

4.3.5 Concluding summary and exhortation in Gal 4:31-5:1: Gentile Christians must stand firm with their free Jewish counterparts

4.4 Conclusion

–  –  –

5.1 Jewish sons, Christ the seed, and the gentile children of promise: A coherent model of Abrahamic descent in Galatians

5.2 Implications and areas for further research

Bibliography

Biography

–  –  –

program at Duke University. Many people have accordingly contributed to its completion in one way or another, only a few of whom can I highlight here.

First, the generous financial support of The Duke Endowment (academic years 2002-2007; summer 2007) and, subsequently, the Dolores Zohrab Liebmann Fund (academic years 2007-2010) enabled me to take the time that I needed to research an argument that took many unexpected turns.

Second, I am indebted to my colleagues and friends at Duke—many of whom were also working on Galatians—for their collegiality and scholarship. In this regard I should also mention the attendees of the October 2009 Duke New Testament and Judaic Studies Colloquium, where I delivered a paper on the Hellenistic background of Paul’s διαθήκη language. The lively discussion that followed my presentation helped to shape what is now a section of Chapter 3.

Third, I would like to thank the members of my dissertation committee: Richard Hays, Douglas Campbell, Stephen Chapman, and Mark Goodacre. Of this group, Hays and Campbell deserve special mention for meticulously reviewing preliminary drafts of each chapter. Their comments and questions have greatly strengthened the final product by exposing unclear arguments, sharpening my understanding of others’ positions, and highlighting potential problems. Problems that remain are, of course, entirely my own.

–  –  –

enabled me throughout this process in ways both big and small, and for my 2-year-old daughter Makara, who always brings me the books I have failed to put away with an exultant smile, I am eternally grateful. This dissertation is as much theirs as it is mine.

Finally, I pray that this dissertation might glorify the God who has made it possible and whose grand design it seeks to articulate. To him and to his son, the sole seed of Abraham, be the glory forever and ever. Amen.

–  –  –

1.1 The challenge of Abrahamic descent in Galatians The concept of Abrahamic descent looms large in Paul’s letter to the churches of Galatia. It first appears in Gal 3:6-14, which infers from a citation of Gen 15:6 that οἱ ἐκ πίστεως are “sons of Abraham” (υἱοὶ Ἀβραάµ, 3:7). Galatians 3:15-4:11 then focuses on the single “seed of Abraham” (τοῦ Ἀβραὰµ σπέρµα), a designation that Paul applies to Christ (3:16) and, subsequently, to those who are “of Christ” (3:29). Finally, Gal 4:21develops an allegorical interpretation of Abraham’s two sons and their mothers in which Paul identifies the Galatians as Abrahamic “children of promise” (ἐπαγγελίας τέκνα, 4:28). The bulk of Gal 3-4—roughly a third of the total letter—thus consists of

three main arguments, each of which invokes a different image of Abrahamic descent:

sons, seed, and children of promise, respectively.



Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |   ...   | 75 |


Similar works:

«Timaree L Schmit, Ph.D. 215.900.2245 timaree.schmit@gmail.com http://sexwithtimaree.com Curriculum Vitae Education 2010: Widener University: Doctorate of Philosophy in Human Sexuality  Dissertation: “How Body Morphology Changes Affect Preference for Thinness and Attractiveness in Partners Among Women Attracted to Women,” December, 2010  Founding Chair of the Human Sexuality Education Student Organization  Laureate Counselor, founding executive committee member and inductee of Gamma...»

«BWANA ASIFIWE IN THE USA: LANGUAGE AND IDENTITY IN EAST AFRICAN CHRISTIAN FELLOWSHIPS IN THE UNITED STATES By Candis Driver Smith A DISSERTATION Submitted to Michigan State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY English 2011 ABSTRACT BWANA ASIFIWE IN THE USA: LANGUAGE AND IDENTITY IN EAST AFRICAN CHRISTIAN FELLOWSHIPS IN THE UNITED STATES By Candis Driver Smith In an effort to expand the sociolinguistic knowledge regarding the East African...»

«Hoover Press : Damon DP5 HPDAMO0500 02-26-:2 09:23:05 rev2 page 85 Educating the Stoic Warrior Nancy Sherman in a remarkably prescient moment, James B. Stockdale, then a senior Navy pilot shot down over Vietnam, muttered to himself as he parachuted into enemy hands, “Five years down there, at least. I’m leaving behind the world of technology and entering the world of Epictetus.”1 Epictetus’s famous handbook, the Enchiridion, was Stockdale’s bedtime reading in the many carrier...»

«HIGH PERFORMANCE COMPUTING FOR IRREGULAR ALGORITHMS AND APPLICATIONS WITH AN EMPHASIS ON BIG DATA ANALYTICS A Thesis Presented to The Academic Faculty by Oded Green In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the School of Computational Science and Engineering Georgia Institute of Technology May 2014 Copyright c 2014 by Oded Green HIGH PERFORMANCE COMPUTING FOR IRREGULAR ALGORITHMS AND APPLICATIONS WITH AN EMPHASIS ON BIG DATA ANALYTICS Approved by:...»

«Centered Communication Clas Weber School of Philosophy Australia National University Clas.Weber@anu.edu.au According to an attractive account of belief, our beliefs have centered content. According to an attractive account of communication, we utter sentences to express our beliefs and share them with each other. However, the two accounts are in conflict. In this paper I explore the consequences of holding on to the claim that beliefs have centered content. If we do in fact express the...»

«COLLABORATIVE DISSERTATIONS IN COMPOSITION: A FEMINIST DISRUPTION OF THE STATUS QUO A Dissertation Submitted to the School of Graduate Studies and Research in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Laura M. Mangini Indiana University of Pennsylvania August 2015 © 2015 Laura M. Mangini All Rights Reserved ii Indiana University of Pennsylvania Schol of Graduate Studies and Research Department of English We hereby approve the dissertation of Laura M....»

«EFFECTIVE REMOTE MODELING IN LARGE-SCALE DISTRIBUTED SIMULATION AND VISUALIZATION ENVIRONMENTS A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE DEPARTMENT OF COMPUTER SCIENCE AND THE COMMITTEE ON GRADUATE STUDIES OF STANFORD UNIVERSITY IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Sandeep Kishan Singhal August 1996 c Copyright 1997 by Sandeep Kishan Singhal All Rights Reserved ii I certify that I have read this dissertation and that in my opinion it is fully adequate, in...»

«Techniques for Model Inference and Bug Finding by Chia Yuan Cho A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Computer Science in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Dawn Xiaodong Song, Chair Professor Sanjit A. Seshia Professor John Chuang Fall 2013 Techniques for Model Inference and Bug Finding Copyright 2013 by Chia Yuan Cho 1 Abstract Techniques for Model Inference and...»

«Reverse Engineering Software Ecosystems Doctoral Dissertation submitted to the Faculty of Informatics of the Università della Svizzera Italiana in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy presented by Mircea F. Lungu under the supervision of Michele Lanza October 2009 Dissertation Committee Prof. Dr. Matthias Hauswirth University of Lugano, Switzerland Prof. Dr. Mehdi Jazayeri University of Lugano, Switzerland Prof. Dr. Radu Marinescu Politenica...»

«EXPLORATORY STUDY OF RFID APPLICATIONS FOR AIR CARGO OPERATIONS By MAGALIE LANIEL A DISSERTATION PRESENTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA 2010 1 © 2010 Magalie Laniel 2 To all who guided me throughout my lifetime, making this milestone possible 3 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This work has been carried out under the guidance of my advisor Dr. Jean-Pierre Émond. His brilliant ideas...»

«ROBOTIC MOBILITY REHABILITATION SYSTEM USING VIRTUAL REALITY BY RARES FLORIN BOIAN A Dissertation submitted to the Graduate School—New Brunswick Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Graduate Program in Electrical and Computer Engineering Written under the direction of Professor Grigore C. Burdea and approved by New Brunswick, New Jersey January, 2005 Abstract OF THE DISSERTATION Robotic Mobility...»

«Tel Aviv University The Lester & Sally Entin Faculty of Humanities The Shirley & Leslie Porter School of Cultural Studies Morpho-phonological and Morpho-thematic Relations in Hebrew and Arabic Verb Formation THESIS SUBMITTED FOR THE DEGREE “DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY” by Lior Laks SUBMITTED TO THE SENATE OF TEL AVIV UNIVERSITY May 2011 This work was carried out under the supervision of Prof. Outi Bat-El Prof. Tal Siloni Table of Contents Abstract Acknowledgements Chapter 1. Introduction 1.1....»





 
<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.