FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 26 | 27 || 29 | 30 |   ...   | 31 |

«A thesis submitted to the University of Birmingham for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Department of Theology and Religion School of Philosophy, ...»

-- [ Page 28 ] --

and recommendations are aligned safely with both the Islamic tradition and modern human rights. Special consideration has to be given to the feasibility of combining the positive components of the scholars’ approaches into a single model of European Islam – one that makes use of al-Qaradawi’s unobtrusive, adaptive jurisprudential methodology for dealing with fiqh issues, and, at the same time, is based on Ramadan’s interpretation of the principles of respect and universalism for engineering a peaceful co-existence between different members of society, who, while remaining unique in their own right, are united by a common general purpose. Although the connotation of Islamization within al-Qaradawi’s da’wa may hint at the struggle for one-sided Muslim dominance, the scholar’s emphasis on the use of intellectual persuasion (as opposed to militant violence) to convey the message of Islam seems to bode well for Europe’s largely-positive approach and capacity for intercultural and interfaith dialogue.

Ramadan’s focus on behavioral preaching (through his formulation of shahāda discussed in Chapter 4.3) fits neatly into this picture – the prospect of conveying the message of Islam mainly through exemplification (rather than verbal preaching) is likely to be encouraging and practical to Muslims and non-forceful to the wider society.

In addition, his focus on the psychological problems of Muslim minority status helps bring clarity to the underlying setbacks to the progress of Muslim integration and thinking and incite a positive and proactive attitude towards self-reformation. The combination of al-Qaradawi’s adaptive fiqh and Ramadan’s acknowledgment of the positive aspects of European society allows a space for Muslim minorities to find an increasing sense of ease in belonging to more than one association. Above all, both scholars manage to show that what is urgently needed for the future of European Islam

–  –  –

understanding of its objectives combined with a pluralistic Muslim perspective - their approaches largely acknowledge the idea that such form of understanding can only occur by way of producing “fresh interpretations of the religion without destroying its original soul, spirit, and character” (Bakar, 2009, p.72).

–  –  –

8.1 Introduction As described in the introductory chapter of the thesis, this study is designed to examine and provide a critical response to al-Qaradawi’s and Ramadan’s conceptualizations of European Islam and reform. The first three chapters in the thesis introduce the theoretical background, historical context, purpose, significance, scope, and methodology of the study as well as provide a brief biography of Yusuf alQaradawi and Tariq Ramadan (Chapter 1 - Introduction, Chapter 2 - Islam and Muslims in Postwar Europe, and Chapter 3 - Yusuf al-Qaradawi and Tariq Ramadan), while the succeeding three chapters enquire into the scholars’ formulations of European-Muslim identity and the role of Muslims in Europe, their conceptual and methodological approaches to reform with regard to fiqh and ethics, and their views on Islamic criminal law and women’s rights in Islam (Chapter 4 - Da’wa and Shahāda, Chapter 5 Adaptive Reform and Transformative Reform, and Chapter 6 - Sharia in Europe: The Question of Incompatibility). Taking these points further, Chapter 7 expounds the strengths and weaknesses of the scholars’ positions and discusses the ways in which they help set the boundaries of a “balanced” form of European Islam as well as the problems they face in doing so, while this conclusion chapter reviews the main findings in all the four chapters that precede it and presents concluding statements on the basis of the overall study and implications of the work for future research.

–  –  –

of da’wa and shahāda respectively in delineating the ways in which Muslim minorities can fuse religious allegiance with national belonging. Following the deconstruction of these two concepts, the study finds that there are various points of convergence and divergence between the scholars’ thinking; the latter, however, are more numerous and substantial than the former, creating a sharp contrast and a distinct sense of individuality between the scholars’ thinking.

–  –  –

difference between al-Qaradawi’s da’wa and Ramadan’s shahāda in their emphases on intra-Muslim responsibilities53, their choices are driven by different motivations. It is argued that al-Qaradawi seemingly portrays Muslim minorities as “victims” trapped in an undesirable position (i.e., living in the West), whereas Ramadan insists that they are “at home” by virtue of the fact that they have access to the right to worship in freedom.

The two scholars hold different evaluations of European society (and its values); alQaradawi perceives it as one that, albeit blessed with advanced technology and wealth of opportunities, is rife with decadence, hedonism, materialism, arrogance, and godlessness, while Ramadan (with seeming reluctance to be overly critical) regards it as one that “seems to have forgotten God”, but which laudably upholds human rights and freedom of religion and belief (a boon to its Muslim population). Their evaluations here are in line with their understandings of the relationship between religious identity

–  –  –

dominant of the two, while Ramadan portrays them as being complementary to one another. The study further demonstrates that al-Qaradawi’s and Ramadan’s definition of the ideal Muslim response to integration as being both participatory in society and resolute in standing up for their “differentness” reveals that they similarly strive to keep to the “middle-ground” in their reformist theologies. In addressing the problems that impede Muslim integration in the West, al-Qaradawi tapers his rhetoric to the issue of Islamophobia and the general trend of irreligiousness in the region, while Ramadan, albeit not denying the concerns highlighted by al-Qaradawi, devotes much of his writing to the issues of low self-esteem and pessimistic assumptions that come wrapped within the minority status.

Another significant difference between the scholars’ use of da’wa and shahāda highlighted in the study is their positions on the role of preaching in Islam. It is explained that al-Qaradawi’s assignment of Muslim minorities as “agents of Islamic proselytization” is imbued with the scholar’s Islamist fervor, while Ramadan’s designation of them as “bearers of the Islamic testimony” is woven into the thinker’s conceptualization of Islamic pluralism. The former’s belief in the “Divine-intended” mission to Islamize the West through the power of intellectual persuasion and sociopolitical influence runs in conflict with the latter’s conviction that the Islamic duty to convey the message of Islam does not transcend beyond simply making the Islamic message known by non-Muslims. Thus, while al-Qaradawi appears to want to impose Islamic values wherever possible, Ramadan seems to want to import Islamic values into European public life. Nevertheless, both scholars are determined to inculcate a Godloving and God-fearing sense into the European consciousness.

–  –  –

three important arguments regarding the scholars’ positions. First, despite their differing rhetorical emphases, both scholars manage to find a way to invoke a sense of citizen empowerment in Muslim minorities by interlacing their ideas on integration with Islamic principles. Second, al-Qaradawi’s Islamist vision allows the suggestion that the scholar follows a dualistic thinking that creates a rigid, though not noticeably hostile, partition between Islam and “the Other”, while Ramadan’s “uncontextualized monotheism” is based on a universalist demand for social cohesion that is driven by common values and norms with seemingly-limited reference to religious and cultural differences between Muslims and the wider community in Europe. Third, al-Qaradawi’s da’wa - in its “Islamization” sense – disregards the pluralistic and secular reality of the European context and risks tapping into the fears and skepticism surrounding the theory of “Eurabia”, while Ramadan’s shahāda – in its sense of achieving universality through stripping Islam down to its basic monotheistic message and humanistic teachings and roping other religious and secular ideologies into this “bare” version – seems too general that it risks eclipsing indelible religious and cultural differences into the background and subsequently dragooning Muslims into yielding credibility to other secular frames of reference.

8.2.2 Adaptive Reform and Transformative Reform Chapter 5 probes into al-Qaradawi’s adaptive fiqh al-aqalliyyat and Ramadan’s transformative “ethical reference”, examining their conceptual origins and methodological frameworks in the attempt to determine where they are similar and different and tease out their problems and contributions. The study learns that the two

–  –  –

helping Muslim minorities avoid drifting into religious attrition due to the hardship of maintaining some of their beliefs by offering them the most lenient of solutions, to encourage them to be cognizant of their rights and duties as citizens, and to improve the odds of Islamic proselytization. Despite the scholar’s significant use of ijtihād and its accompanying methods, he remains close to the general teachings of the Qur’an and Sunna. Chapter 5.3 clarifies that Ramadan’s ethical reference, on the other hand, is intended as a universal guide that addresses existing and anticipates potential challenges that prevent society and its members as a whole from progressing towards the realization of common ethical values54. The scholar requires the ‘ulamā to consider both the Revelation and the Universe as a dual source of law and ethics, to collaborate with scientists from all fields in the elaboration of ethical principles, and to hold a two-fold specialization - one in the study of Islam and the other in that of the sciences. The study further notes that al-Qaradawi’s fiqh operates in the narrow context of personal space and is, thus, unobtrusive to the wider community, while Ramadan’s ethical reference is expansive and intent on transforming the order of society, which requires drawing on contributions from every one of its group members.

–  –  –

As expressed in the study, both al-Qaradawi and Ramadan, through their use of ijtihād, elevate the context to the same level as the Revelation as a source of legislation.

However, similar to what has been discovered in Chapter 4 on da’wa and shahāda, this

–  –  –

approaches. It is observed that al-Qaradawi applies ijtihād and its concomitant principles55 in a cautious (albeit flexible) manner, while Ramadan appears intent on getting more out of ijtihād by using it to ruminate beyond the confines of the traditionalist Muslim thinking; some of the outcomes of the Swiss thinker’s transformative thinking, such as his collection of the objectives of Sharia, do not appear as distinctively “Islamic” as he insists, although this dovetails with the particular notion of universality that he embeds in his shahāda. Despite this difference in motivation, the study suggests that the scholars’ approaches are, nevertheless, similarly based on the principle of maqāṣīd; while al-Qaradawi’s approach is driven by the need to protect Muslim minorities’ adherence to religion, Ramadan’s approach can be pegged to the general need to protect one’s “wellbeing”.

–  –  –

which echo the arguments made in the preceding section. First, there is no clear formula on which al-Qaradawi bases his determination of issues as invoking the principle of necessity and requiring the application of ijtihād. Given his cautiousness in using reason in his fiqh al-aqalliyyat, it does not seem reasonable to pin the scholar’s use of ijtihād to the assumption that the principle of necessity always prevails where the Islamic tradition is silent. Second, Ramadan’s portrayal of the Revelation and the Universe as being complementary to one another is identical to the manner in which he defines the relationship between religious identity and citizenship in the concept of shahāda. This notion of “divine-intended interaction” between different elements of the West-Muslim experience appears to be characteristic of his thinking.

–  –  –

within the overarching themes of criminal law and women’s rights in Islam in order to determine the manners in which and the extent to which the scholars use their reformist thinking to align challenged Muslim beliefs with the conventions of human rights in Europe. The study unfolds that both scholars present a balance of traditional and reformist tendencies, keeping close to the prevailing thinking in the Muslim world in some cases and exhibiting willingness to make compromises in others. Additionally, Ramadan, in particular, exhibits many instances of ambiguity.

–  –  –

in the study with regard to the issues of ḥudūd and morality. First, neither scholar contests the scriptural bases of most of the penalties associated with the penal code.

Second, they both call for the suspension of ḥudūd in the Muslim world, but remain adamant that Muslims should always refrain from adopting “non-Islamic” modern norms56 regardless of spatial context. Third, both agree that ḥudūd should be seen as more of a deterrent than punishment, and that lack of evidence to support any criminal charge under its provisions must constitute grounds for acquittal. Fourth, both scholars call for the use of ijtihād in determining the terms and boundaries of ḥudūd. Beyond these four general similarities, the scholars differ rather starkly. Al-Qaradawi is clear in his position that “the laws of Allah” are absolute and must be established eventually, while Ramadan creates ambiguity in his rhetoric, showing neither condemnation nor support for the penal code’s application in general. As for the issue of Islamic morality, al-Qaradawi presses on the importance of Muslims being opposed, although not

–  –  –

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 26 | 27 || 29 | 30 |   ...   | 31 |

Similar works:

«ODYSSEY OFTHE MIND SPONTANEOUS PROBLEM SOLVING SPONTANEOUS PROBLEMS Verbal Hands -On Hands -On Verbal VERBAL In a Verbal spontaneous problem, the team is given a brainstorming-type problem to solve in a specific amount of time and scored according to he number and creativity of responses generated. The order in which members respond is usually random, and a higher point value is awarded for a creative answer than a common one. Examples: Name uses for a jack-o-lantern after Halloween. Name...»

«CHAPTER 1 Qualitative Research and Habits of Mind Story is far older than the art of science and psychology and will always be the elder in the equation no matter how much time passes. —Clarissa Pinkola Estes Women Who Run With the Wolves (1996) B ecause the researcher is the research instrument in qualitative research projects, it is important for the researcher to practice and refine techniques and habits of mind for qualitative research. Habits of mind in this text will include observation...»

«Diffusion: the UCLan Journal of Undergraduate Research Volume 4 Issue 2 (December 2011) The role of religion in social transformation within Poland since1970 Paul Ryder (Religion, Culture and Society) The political and social structure of the state At the close of the Second World War in 1945, Poland was consumed by the totalitarian, communist regime of Joseph Stalin’s Soviet Union. The ideology of Stalinism was heavily based on the work of Karl Marx and what later became known as Marxism....»

«CURRICULUM VITAE Alan G. Green PhD University of Southern California Rossier School of Education Waite Philips Hall –WPH 604B 3470 Trousdale Parkway Los Angeles, CA 90089-4036 Fax: 213-740-2367 email: alangree@usc.edu EDUCATION PhD Counseling Psychology, Howard University, Washington, DC, May 1997 Dissertation: “Adolescent Stressors, Coping Responses and Psychological Adjustment in Guyana”, J.W. Fulbright Student Fellowship. MS School and Community Counseling, California State University,...»

«100+Amazing things you can do with Microsoft Dynamics CRM on your phone and tablet // 1 100+ Amazing things you can do with Microsoft Dynamics CRM on your phone and tablet Introduction // 2 100+ Amazing things you can do with Microsoft Dynamics CRM on your phone and tablet Why did we make this book?When we started working on this book, we had two goals in mind: 1. We want to show people how cool a mobile CRM client really can be 2. We want to provide a list of cool things you can get inspired...»

«Article Constructing the Cool Wall: A Tool to Explore Teen Meanings of Cool Fitton, Daniel Bowen, Read, Janet C and Horton, Matthew Paul Leslie Available at http://clok.uclan.ac.uk/7405/ Fitton, Daniel Bowen, Read, Janet C and Horton, Matthew Paul Leslie (2012) Constructing the Cool Wall: A Tool to Explore Teen Meanings of Cool. PsychNology Journal, 10 (2). pp. 141-162. ISSN 1720-7525 It is advisable to refer to the publisher’s version if you intend to cite from the work. For more information...»

«EDMUND GOSSE’S FATHER AND SON: RENEGOTIATING BIOGRAPHY THROUGH ILLUSTRATION KATHY REES Edmund Gosse (1849–1928) is known today for one classic text, Father and Son (1907), the account of his early life from 1849 to 1870 in his Plymouth Brethren home. It is a profile of mid-Victorian dissenter religion, where the recollections of the urbane narrator are periodically animated by the voice of the precocious but fragile child-focaliser. On publication the book was applauded for its...»

«CURRICULUM VITAE 2016/09/06 ELIZABETH PAGE-GOULD, PH.D. CANADA RESEARCH CHAIR IN SOCIAL PSYCHOPHYSIOLOGY CONTACT INFORMATION Social Psychophysiological Research & Quantitative Methods Lab Phone: (416) 978-3401 Department of Psychology Fax: (416) 978-4811 University of Toronto Email: liz@psych.utoronto.ca 100 St. George Street, 4th Floor Web: http://page-gould.com Toronto, Ontario M5S 3G3 DEGREES Ph.D. University of California Berkeley, Berkeley CA 2002 2008 Psychology, May 2008 Mentor: Rodolfo...»

«Chinese Military Modernization and Asian Security Michael Swaine August 1998 1 2 Chinese Military Modernization and Asian Security* Michael Swaine I’ll speak on the question of Chinese military defense modernization and its implications for the Asian security environment. I’ll try to keep my remarks at a level where we can talk about broader issues and concepts, and the implications of all this for regional evolution in the security environment, U.S. security interests, U.S.-Japan...»

«1 Sociocultural Issues in Learning English for Women in Northwest Pakistan Dissertation zur Erlangung des Grades eines Doktors Englische Philologie am Fachbereich Philosophie und Geisteswissenschaften der Freien Universität Berlin vorgelegt von Sabina Shah Berlin, February, 2015 2 Erstgutachter/in: Prof. Dr. Gerhard Leitner (Institut für Englische Philologie) Zweitgutachter/in: Prof. Dr. Ferdinand von Mengden (Institut für Englische Philologie) Tag der Disputation: 14. Juli 2015 3 Contents...»

«Louisiana Architecture: 1945-1965 The Contemporary House NATIONAL BACKGROUND Introduction: “I am not going to sit on furniture that continually reminds me of a machine shop or a hospital operating room.” Albert Einstein Machined modernism in art and architecture wasn’t for everyone. If Einstein had been talking about houses, he might have had in mind the high-art Farnsworth House near Chicago, a serene steel and glass box designed by the supreme modernist Mies van der Rohe (Photo 1). But...»

«Bandolero Byers Guide A Guide to Bando Basics and Inspection The Cars The Bando has been carefully designed with safety in mind. Some areas of the car are designed to “crush” and absorb energy in an impact. This “crush” also makes the cars somewhat fragile. Be prepared to repair/replace body panels, bumpers, frame horns and occasionally a front or rear clip. If necessary the entire rear frame behind the drivers compartment can be replaced. The front frame area, aprox 2 feet forward of...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.