FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 40 | 41 || 43 | 44 |   ...   | 53 |

«A thesis submitted to the Department of Political Science and International Studies of the University of Birmingham for the degree of Doctor of ...»

-- [ Page 42 ] --

5.5.1. Britain as the Internal “Other” in the EU Generally, the UK represents a special case when it comes to the EMoS/ ESM because, like America, its social model is neo-liberal. As the discussion so far has shown, the Commission articulations indicate that its idea of how social life should be organised strongly opposes the neo-liberal model. Instead, its vision advocates greater involvement in social issues for the state and the supranational level in the EU context. In the past this has led to British opting-out of EU-level legislation on social policy, which represents a tangible manifestation of the existence of an internal border between the UK and the rest of the EU on this particular issue. Although it joined the Social Chapter in the Treaty of Amsterdam in 1997, the trend of Britain disagreeing with the rest of the EU on social policy issues is still present. For example, in the beginning of the new millennium, the Directive on Information and Consultation of workers raised: “considerable concern and worry … in the UK”144 and in the summer of 2005, the UK expressed its opposition to the proposed legislation at EU level for the number of hours a week that a worker is allowed to do. This constitutes the discursive background within which the articulations of the Commission operate. My argument is that despite its efforts to the contrary, due to the different visions of the UK and the Commission, Commission social policy discourse 144 Anna Diamantopoulou, European Social Policy: Revising the Challenge of Modernisation, SPEECH/01/170, 10.04.2001, p. 5 215 constructs the UK as the “Other” thus recreating the existing division between the UK and the rest of the EU. This leads to an inconsistency in the Commission discourse, which is articulated through linking the UK with the “US” and “deregulators”, which both emerge from the Commission social policy discourse as “Others”.

In concurrence with the de-bordering trend under the first reading some articulations of the Commission indicate its desire to overcome the internal border between the UK and the other member states on social policy issues. This is enunciated through a two-step process. Firstly, the Commission has referred to the British position as a serious issue because it obstructs the integration process. 145 This is because “there are two different legal bases for the pursuit of social policy at European level … one [that] applies across the Union and is based on the social provisions of the Treaty of Rome … and the other applies to 14 Member States and is based on the Agreement on Social Policy.” 146 Secondly, the Commission has clearly shown that it is in favour of discontinuation of this situation: “My plea – here today – for an end to a separate social chapter simply reflects what has in recent years informed the whole European Social policy”; “I hope the UK will come to recognize that having two legal frameworks for social legislation is what threatens jobs, puts workers‟ confidence and security at risk and weakens competitiveness.” 147 This clearly indicates that the Commission supports taking the internal EU borders down, which importantly should be done through accepting the developments at EU level.

The promotion of the establishment of a common social space in the EU and the inclusion of the UK in it are further advanced by some Commission articulations, which emphasise that the UK belongs to the ESM. Most often this is done by acknowledging the diversity of the social systems of the member states, a technique, which I looked at in the section on de-bordering. As I argued there, the inclusiveness is implied by the insistence on the existence of common underlying values and aims, which supersede these differences in the detail. The following statement is a good illustration of this in the case of the UK: “The 145 Jacques Delors, Press Conference before the Maastricht European Council, SPEECH/91/135, 05.12.1991, p. 2 146 European Commission, Facts about the „Social Chapter‟, MEMO/97/13, 05.02.1997, p. 2 147 Both quotations are from Padraig Flynn, The Social Chapter – Cost or Benefit?, SPEECH/96/223, 26.09.1996, p. 5 216 way in which these values are implemented in the Member States of the European Union, with their different traditions, varies … For example, the United Kingdom has the National Health Service, whereas Germany has a system of insurance funds …but the basic common direction of all systems is clear.”148 However, there are other articulations that can be interpreted along the line that the UK represents a special case in the EU, thus contradicting the claim that a common social space exists in the EU.

The first way in which the inconsistency is articulated is through linking the UK and the US. Thus, despite the above claims about Britain‟s belonging to the ESM, from the discourse of the Commission it also emerges as a state that has macroeconomic indicators similar to the US: “… when we look at both income inequality and literacy inequality, we find that the Nordics – Denmark, Sweden, Norway – are at one end of the spectrum, in both cases. And that the US, and unfortunately the UK too, are at the other end.” 149; “… US workers work 5 to 10 per cent longer hours per year than European. Even longer than the British!”150 Thus, these documents link the UK with the US through establishing a clear resemblance between them. As the previous section showed the US is constructed as one of the main “Others” of the EU. Therefore, the link of the UK with it contributes to the exclusion of the UK from the EU, rather than to its inclusion, hence constructing an internal border in the Union.

This perception of ambiguous belonging of the UK to the ESM is further reinforced by the frequent reminder in Commission documents that the UK is a part of the integration project and faces the same challenges as the other member states: “Over the next decade, Europe, including Britain, faces a fundamental choice of directions about its response to intensifying global competition.” 151; “That is the core of the European employment and social policy, for the UK and Europe, in the next decade.”152 These have: “… been a test of 148 Vladimir Špidla, The European Social Model: Wishful Thinking or Reality?, SPEECH/06/291, 11.05.2006, p. 2 149 Anna Diamantopoulou, The Modernisation of the European Social Model and the Forthcoming Stockholm Summit, SPEECH/01/113, 09.03.2001, p. 4 150 Ibid., p. 3 151 Peter Mandelson, A Modern Social Agenda for Europe, SPEECH/05/381, 23.06.2005, p. 2 (emphasis added) 152 Padraig Flynn, A Personal Perspective on the Development of Social Europe, SPEECH/99/112, 07.09.1999, p. 4 (emphasis added) 217 the UK‟s ability to address both its own identity in Europe, and its own … performance, in European terms.”153 These statements promote a European identity for the UK. However, the fact that these reminders are constantly necessary154 implies that in Britain, the identification with the EU is not that strong, that the British often feel apart, rather than a part of the EU. Thus, although they are members of the EU, this indicates that there is an important dividing line between them and the rest of the Union on social policy issues, which points towards the existence of an internal EU border. This can be illustrated by the fact, admitted openly by Commissioner Flynn that in the UK there is: “… sometimes bitter, and essentially sham, battle which surrounds any mention of “Europe”, and, especially, the “S” word”155 and that the British tabloid press (perhaps more that the national press in any other member state) is notorious for its: “… spread of fear and loathing of the Union”. 156 The latter leads to the question what, if anything makes the UK different? As I said earlier, in distinction to the socio-economic models on the continental part of the EU, the British one is neo-liberal. Therefore, it can be expected that in comparison to other European social models, the predisposition on social issues in the UK has been towards less intervention, deregulation, or lower social spending. Currently this predisposition is a result of the policies of the Conservative governments that ruled the country for almost two decades after 1979. This incline has meant that (especially when the Conservative party was in power) the UK was finding it difficult to come to terms with the philosophy underpinning EMoS/ ESM. This distinction is reflected in the Commission discourse, which can be well exemplified by the following quotation of Commissioner Flynn: “Lady Thatcher, the former Prime Minister of the UK, used to say that she didn‟t know what society was. I know.”157 It clearly points to the contradictory positions of the two politicians, thus putting them on the opposing sides of the dividing line. These positions are 153 Ibid., p. 2 154 Although on certain issues, or during particular periods other EU member states can also be regarded as an internal “Other” emerging from European Commission discourse, the UK is the EU member state to which this is most often applicable. Furthermore, as the years of the documents referred to in this section indicate, this tendency has been pronounced virtually throughout the whole period in question. Thus, I regard the UK as a “special case” and one of the most important examples of the construction of internal EU borders.

155 Padraig Flynn, Social Policy and the Economy, SPEECH/97/35, 11.02.1997, p. 2 156 Ibid., p. 5 157 Padraig Flynn, European Social Policy - a Help or a Hindrance, SPEECH/96/127, 20.05.1996, p. 1 (emphasis added) 218 informed by the different philosophies they hold. For the EU Commissioner: “People and their skills, enterprise and confidence, as consumers, investors and workers, are both the future of our economies, and of its bedrock, families and society. The economy has to be strong. The values of the market are necessary for enterprise and business. But for citizens, for people, it‟s more complex. Human values are more than – and different from – market values.”158 As we have seen earlier, various Commission documents promote the idea that a very important part of these citizens‟ values are the social models in the EU, which stand in favour of solidarity and equality. These, however, require active redistributive policies. It is exactly this kind of policies that Margaret Thatcher was opposing and in turn, this has led her to proclaim that she did not know what society is.

This differentiation between citizens values and market values is again reminiscent to a line in the Commission discourse on US‟ “Other”. Taking this into account, however, allows drawing more parallels between the socio-economic systems of the US and the UK.

This further contradicts the claim of the UK‟s belonging to the ESM and constructs it instead as “Other”, just as the US is, and in this way – establishes an internal border in the EU. Further evidence in support of such argument is that according to the documents of the European Commission, some important positive and negative aspects of British economic performance are closer to these of the US. For example, in terms of its achievements under the European Employment Strategy: “The UK in many ways is a very positive role model, although there is an issue of balance with respect to employment and social policies. In our work on labour markets within the Employment strategy … we see that the UK performs well in terms of a number of traditional flexibility criteria. And it has shown an impressive capacity to respond to change, especially regarding new technologies. Nevertheless, there remains work to be done … there is lack of social partnership, at a time when we envisage an enhanced role for the social partners at both European and national level …” 159 The second main inconsistency in the Commission discourse on social policy that contributes to the emergence of an internal border between the UK and the rest of the member states is the articulation of those in favour of deregulation as “Other”. According

158 Ibid.159 Anna Diamantopoulou, The European Dimension, SPEECH/00/298, 12.09.2000, pp. 4-5

219 to the Commission, there are clear dangers in deregulation: “… we must avoid … drifting back to the policies and practices that failed to deliver in the past – like wholesale market de-regulation. Not only did they not work, they proved counter-productive. Creating social strife and conflict. Slowing the process of reform and progress. Failing to address the real labour market problems we face.”160; “… deregulators … offer us the low pay, low productivity route.”161 Instead, the Commission promotes the rationale for the existence of social policy at Union level and is at pains to emphasise and reassure that its aim is not to regulate at any price and that it only does so when there is a necessity for that: “Our [EU]

economic objectives cannot be achieved without the social dimension.” and this is because:

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 40 | 41 || 43 | 44 |   ...   | 53 |

Similar works:

«ADVERSITY QUOTIENT IN PREDICTING JOB PERFORMANCE VIEWED THROUGH THE PERSPECTIVE OF THE BIG FIVE MASTER THESIS MAY 2007 MASTER’S DEGREE PSYKOLOGISKE INSTITUTT UNIVERSITY OF OSLO Elizabeth Le Thi ABSTRACT The aim of the present study is to theoretically and empirically investigate a theory labeled the Adversity Quotient (AQ). Its claim of being able to predict all facets of human capacity and performance is being tested by comparing it with the more established Five Factor Model (also known as...»

«Psychological Explanation, Ontological Commitment, and the Semantic view of Theories Colin Klein 1 Introduction Naturalistic philosophers of mind must assume some philosophy of science. For naturalism demands that we look to psychology—but to be guided by psychological theories, one must have some story about what theories are and how they work. In this way, philosophy of mind was subtly guided by philosophy of science. For the past forty years, mainstream philosophy of mind has implicitly...»

«The Hand-drill By Alan Halcon Introduction Growing up, I had a fascination with the outdoors. Every summer my dad would take us camping. After each trip, I would find myself preparing for the next trip by reading anything that I could on camping and outdoor survival. I remember hopping on my bike, riding to the local library, and sitting there for hours just looking through all the books on camping. I would constantly beg my mom to take me to the local sporting goods store in order to check out...»

«Bandolero Byers Guide A Guide to Bando Basics and Inspection The Cars The Bando has been carefully designed with safety in mind. Some areas of the car are designed to “crush” and absorb energy in an impact. This “crush” also makes the cars somewhat fragile. Be prepared to repair/replace body panels, bumpers, frame horns and occasionally a front or rear clip. If necessary the entire rear frame behind the drivers compartment can be replaced. The front frame area, aprox 2 feet forward of...»

«January 2010 Wartime Rescue of Jews by the Polish Catholic Clergy The Testimony of Survivors Edited and compiled by Mark Paul Polish Educational Foundation in North America Toronto 2009 Rescue activities on behalf of Jews were carried out by priests, nuns and monks in more than one thousand Roman Catholic Church institutions throughout Poland during World War II. The number of priests and religious involved in these activities was many times higher. This effort is all the more remarkable since...»

«Your Benefit Guide State Vision Plan For Active Employees and Retirees Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan is a nonprofit corporation and independent licensee of the Blue Cross and Blue Shield Association. Welcome Welcome to your State Vision Plan, administered by Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan (BCBSM) under the direction of the Michigan Civil Service Commission (MCSC). The MCSC is responsible for implementing your vision benefits and future changes in benefits. BCBSM will provide certain...»

«What Indoor Cats Need To enrich the lives of indoor cats, we have developed this resource checklist; and some suggestions for making changes. Informed Owners As an owner, one of the most important things you can do for you cat is to educate yourself about feline idiosyncrasies. These resources will help you do just that. Books From the Cat's Point of View answers nearly every question the new cat owner could have and gives the experienced cat owner a look at life from the other side of the...»

«Making sense of antipsychotics making sense antipsychotics Making sense of antipsychotics This booklet is for anyone who wants to know more about antipsychotic medication. It explains what antipsychotics are, how they work, possible side effects and information about withdrawal. Contents What are antipsychotics? 4 Could antipsychotics help me? 11 What are the safety issues? 16 What dosage should I be on? 23 What if I'm pregnant or breastfeeding? 26 What side effects can they cause? 29 What's a...»

«Political Psychology, Vol. 31, No. 4, 2010 doi: 10.1111/j.1467-9221.2010.00768.x The Behavioral Logic of Collective Action: Partisans Cooperate and Punish More Than Nonpartisansp ops_768 595.616 Oleg Smirnov Stony Brook University Christopher T. Dawes University of California, San Diego James H. Fowler University of California, San Diego Tim Johnson Stanford University Richard McElreath University of California, Davis Laboratory experiments indicate that many people willingly contribute to...»

«Incidents in the Life of Madame Blavatsky by A.P. Sinnett Incidents in the Life of Madame Blavatsky by A.P. Sinnett Compiled from information supplied by her relatives and friends The Theosophical Publishing House, London 1913 AUTHOR'S PREFACE [Page 5] THE first edition of this book, published in 1886, was issued during Madame Blavatsky's lifetime as an indirect protest against the cruel and slanderous attack on her embodied in the Report to the Committee of the Psychical Research Society...»

«Le Mans (not just) for Dummies The Club Arnage Guide to the 24 hours of Le Mans 2015 Every input was pure reflex things were coming at me everywhere I looked. For about 50 percent of the lap I felt like I was on the verge of a massive accident. Mark Blundell commenting his pole position lap in a 1.100 hp Nissan Group C at Le Mans 1990 Copyright The entire contents of this publication and, in particular of all photographs, maps and articles contained therein are protected by the laws in force...»

«3rd Edition, 2009 Introduction to the 3rd Edition nd It has been just over a decade since the 2 Edition of the Mush with P.R.I.D.E. Sled Dog Care Guidelines were published. During that time, scientists have made great strides in their understanding of dog physiology, psychology and behavior. Researchers have studied working sled dogs, with the support of their mushers, some of whom are also Mush with P.R.I.D.E. members. Many of these research projects have validated sled dog care methods that...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.